Best Men's Skin Care Products

It used to be that my manscaping routine was more or less set. Lather up with whatever all-in-one body wash/shampoo/antifreeze the gym dispensed, run the trusty Gillette over my mostly barren scalp and rinse off. Usually, the gym provided a choice of suds: industrial-strength white or antiseptic orange. I preferred orange. 

Then I heard about Mantl, the maker of a "formulated regimen" of men's skin care specifically designed for bald men like me. Mantl produces a gentle cleanser, face moisturizer and sunscreen, as well as "no-shine sheets." Gotta say, it's some pretty nice stuff.

The cleanser is light and washes off easily. No sticky film. I used it to soap up before guiding a razor over my dome. Definitely got a closer, longer-lasting shave. The face wash also has a pleasing scent, more appealing than the gym's white, though maybe not as aromatic as orange. 

The moisturizer is similarly agreeable. It's a little thicker than I was expecting, but my skin seemed to absorb it quickly. It isn't greasy. The missus said I looked younger after using it. She also said my cheeks seemed fuller, though that might have been a polite hint to skip a third slice of pizza. 

Mantl's SPF 30 sunscreen is different from other skin protection I've used. It's a clear gel, not a clotty goop that leaves smudges and streaks regardless of how vigorously it's rubbed in. I didn't put any on my scalp because I use what all red-blooded Bay Staters use to shield their heads from the elements: a New England Patriots ball cap. I did, however, apply some to my face. It spread evenly and wore comfortably. 

Mantl also makes no-shine sheets designed to sop up excess oil on your scalp. Seemed a little fussy so I didn't try them. That said, they're probably pretty good if they're anything like Mantl's other products. Also, they're made with bamboo charcoal, which sounds impressive.

Like just about every other business these days, the Mantl people are marketing their products as a service and offer customizable quarterly boxes. A full kit costs $79 every 12 weeks. I'm not ready to drop $280 a year on subscription soap. But if my gym stocked it, I'd definitely use Mantl. Sorry, orange. -- Andrew Morse

Don't let the name fool you. The Art of Shaving Stubble Balm was designed to soften uncomfortable stubble, but it's really a multipurpose skin care addition that made a major difference all around. Joe rocks a full beard and only uses a razor to clean up his neck and cheek areas. Fortunately, he doesn't deal with too much razor burn, but he does get some pretty persistent ingrown hairs and breakouts in these areas.

After adding this to his men's skin care routine for a couple of weeks, there was a noticeable difference in ingrown hair frequency and his skin feel and texture. His skin wasn't as itchy and his beard also felt softer and looked more tamed, even hours after he used the balm.

The texture of the stubble balm falls somewhere between a light conditioner and a gel. It provided relief for his skin and gave his beard game an upgrade without any greasy residue left behind at all. We tested the sandalwood, which smells absolutely divine, but if for some reason, you're not into that musky, smoky scent, there are bourbon and bergamot and neroli options as well.

The Lumin Moisturizing Balm, which targets skin dryness and sun damage, is a GQ Best Stuff pick. As a men's skin care newbie, it took Joe a little while to get used to the extra moisture on his face, but after a week or so -- and some coaching about how a little goes a long way -- he was hooked on this face moisturizer.

Because it's technically a night cream that combats premature aging, the Moisturizing Balm has a thick texture, but it absorbs right into the skin, instead of sitting on top and giving that greasy feel and look. Joe commented several times on how he couldn't stop touching his face because it felt so smooth. It looked baby soft, too.

The difference was especially apparent as we got into the first week of December and the temperatures started to plummet. While he's normally plagued with dry patches on his cheeks and forehead, he hasn't experienced any of that this year, even with temperatures in the 20s. His skin tone has also evened out a lot too, with redness and dark spots decreasing significantly.

The scent was also really pleasant. It wasn't as fragrant as the Stubble Balm, but gave off a light freshly washed unisex aroma.

The Jack Black Beard Oil is a blend of natural ingredients, soothing oils, potent antioxidants and vitamins that work together to condition your beard and improve the skin underneath. And it works.

Just two drops easily tamed all of Joe's rogue beard hairs and provided a light sheen without leaving him feeling greasy. He also made sure to work the oil into his skin underneath his beard to see if it could alleviate the dry, itchy skin that doesn't often get enough care, and it did. He felt relief instantly and, over time, he commented on how he wasn't scratching as often and how he felt like his skin was more pliable and his beard was less stiff.

I felt a noticeable difference in the texture during cuddle time, and his beard looked better and smelled fresh too. With so many fragrant ingredients, it's hard to pinpoint the exact scent, but it was light and pleasant.

The Kiehl's Facial Fuel Energizing Scrub is designed to help break down "tough facial hair" for a closer, more comfortable shave. As such, we were expecting a harsh thickly beaded scrub, but it was anything but. In fact, it was among the best men's skin care products.

The particles in this face scrub, which are made from apricot kernels, were fine and really easy on the skin. They were able to easily slough away dead skin cells without leaving behind any redness or irritation, making this a perfect addition to an effective skin care routine. After a couple of weeks of use, there were noticeable differences in Joe's skin tone and texture and he had far fewer clogged pores on his nose.

Even though he followed up the scrub with moisturizer, it felt moisturizing all on its own and there were times he commented that he didn't even feel like he needed the additional moisture.

In addition to scrubbing particles, the exfoliator also contains menthol and caffeine, which are designed to invigorate the skin, and it did seem like things were getting a little lighter and brighter, but the difference there wasn't totally noticeable in the two weeks of our testing. While the menthol smell of the face wash wasn't his favorite (or mine), he loved the morning wake-me-up and fresh feeling this skin care product provided.