Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

X-Box 360, Wii or PS3?

Aug 15, 2009 1:22AM PDT

Christmas is around the corner - I am looking to buy a "family" game that is going to be the most versatile for kids games.

Between the X-box 360, Wii and PS3, which is the preferable and most versatile console?

with a $300 to $500 base investment - I want to get the most out of the purchase.

Thanks for your input.

Bob

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
I'd say Wii
Aug 15, 2009 5:24AM PDT

I'd say Wii if you're looking for something for the entire family, and your kids are a bit younger (10 or under).

But unless it's supposed to be a big surprise to everyone, I would gather everyone around the computer and hit a few game review sites. Look at some of the titles for each system, and see which one has the largest number of games you all (or at least most of) you want to play. Whichever one has the largest number of games, is the one you get.

The only other real redeeming factor to any of the consoles, besides gaming, is that the PS3 can play bluray movie discs -- and I wouldn't use it for that since it will wear out the laser faster, and standalone players are cheaper and easier to replace -- and the 360 has the HD-DVD drive add-on. It may be a defunct format, but there are still probably more HD-DVD movies out there than there are bluray. I suppose Microsoft has made a push for things like Netflix, and I think Hulu support is in the works, but I'd still focus more on the gaming aspect of things. There are generally better devices for all the other functions consoles do besides gaming.

- Collapse -
Not really.
Aug 19, 2009 3:24AM PDT

HD-DVD and Blu Ray had pretty closely sized libraries when HD-DVD died off. By now, Blu Ray has long, long since passed the total size of the HD-DVD catalog, and eclipsed it in terms of quality a dozen more times as well, with most all of it's best movies making the leap. (movies like Children of Men just having come out recently in fact) Not to mention they are impossible to find at retail. For HD movie viewing, it's hard to take HD-DVD seriously anymore as a choice.

- Collapse -
Like I said
Aug 19, 2009 4:56AM PDT

Like I said if you read to the end of my post... There are generally better devices for any of the secondary (i.e. non-gaming) functions of the different consoles.

And personally, I'm not a fan of new hi-def movies. They completely destroy the illusion the way they enhance the foreground while leaving the background alone. I was in a Microcenter and they had Dark Knight playing. I honestly thought it was the video game version of it the way the foreground and background failed to mesh properly. It took me a good minute or so to be absolutely certain that it was actually the movie. And it's the same with every other bluray movie I've seen. If they're going to destroy the illusion the special effects people try so hard to create, then I'll pass.

But again, the question was about which GAME console was better, not which console was the better movie player. I have nothing against the PS3, except that most of the games I want to play are either on the 360 or both, and the 360 has been cheaper up to now... But I look at them as a GAME console. I don't give two craps which one plays what kind of movie or any of the other pointless non-gaming functions they have. The 360 has one of the sorriest excuses for a media player I think I have ever seen, and from the sound of it, the PS3 requires you run a special media server to stream content. I cobbled something together with a cheap open box system from Microcenter and a copy of XBMC that works infinitely better and only took me a few minutes. I care even less about Xbox Live and Sony's PlayStation Network. I have no interest in listening to a bunch of prepubescent kids wax idiotic, or dealing with people who have absolutely no social life, they just spend their entire day playing some game. I'm not going to waste the finite life of my console's laser playing movie discs, because that is normal wear and tear and not subject to a warranty claim. Not to mention that if the PS3 craps out, and it's also my movie player, I can't play games OR watch movies. If I have two devices, if one goes down I can still use the other. Maybe because I work in IT I'm a big fan of redundancy.

Of course what really matters is the original question, which is about which system is better for the whole FAMILY. The 360 and PS3 are for the people who are serious about their gaming, while the Wii is more about people who just want to be able to enjoy a quick game of something. That makes it MUCH more FAMILY friendly. Odds are mom and dad aren't going to be big gamers, and if you want something both mom, dad, and the kids can all enjoy TOGETHER then the Wii is a great option. It won't be for everyone... I don't have one because there just aren't many games out for it that interest me. Maybe when the next Zelda title shows up... But that doesn't mean that when you do the analysis the Wii comes out the clear winner in this case.

So please do check your fanboi-ism at the door. I know sometimes I may make it seem easy, but I do actually go through a rather complex analysis before putting up an answer. It's not just, "The PS3 has a bluray player so everyone should want it." Not everyone gives a crap about bluray movies. And not everyone cares about eye popping graphics in a game. Some people just want a game that they can pick up and play for maybe an hour a week, then put down. I like RPGs with deep stories and lots of character development. I consider Final Fantasy X to be probably the single greatest RPG of all time (to date). But not everyone is interested in devoting 35-40 hours to a single game like that.

So if you don't have more to offer than a fanboi's perspective, you might want to go hang out in Sony's PlayStation forums or something where you can surrender to groupthink.

- Collapse -
Xbox 360, Wii or PS3
Aug 15, 2009 5:32AM PDT

All of the consoles have their good and bad points. The Xbox 360 is the only one of the three I own, but I have played both the Wii and the Playstation 3 as well.

The Xbox 360 is a good purchase, but there are rumors circulating that the normal model, the Premium, is being discontinued. I wouldn't buy yet until I saw if it was true or not. If it is, the top spec model, the Elite, might fall in price too. Another downside to the 360 is its reliability. The 360 is not the most reliable console out - you might have heard of the 'Red Ring of Death'.

The Wii is a good system too, but would it hold your kids attention long? I was bored of the Wii during the two hours or so I had playing with it. Online on the Wii is free.

The PS3 is a great console as well, and the online is free too, just like the Wii. The games on the PS3 are pretty good, and there are some nice exclusives for the console as well, such as Resistance.

Do your kids want to play online games with their friends and other players? The online service for the Xbox is the best, but it isn't free. It's quite affordable though. The PS3's online system, the Playstation Network, is free but it lacks some of the features of the Xbox. I don't know anything about the Nintendo online.

Xbox 360 Pros and Cons :

+ Online is great
+ Durable, high quality controllers
+ Some great games coming out this year
- Reliability Issues
- Online costs

Playstation 3 Pros and Cons :

+ Online is free
+ Some great games coming out this year
+ High quality console
- Flimsy Controllers
- Online lacks a lot of features

Nintendo Wii

+ Free online
+ Lots of child-friendly games
+ Games can help you exercise
- Might not hold their attention for long
- Online lacks a lot of features

That's my opinion, and there are an equal number of pros and cons in my eyes.

- Collapse -
Sounds like you want a Wii
Aug 19, 2009 3:20AM PDT

It has the largest amount of kid friendly and family friendly games available for it, and will be the easiest for the kids and other family members not familiar with games already to actually play. The HD consoles are much more heavily geared towards adult gamers, despite their attempts to dabble in more casual/family friendly games every so often.

- Collapse -
not a text wall
Aug 19, 2009 2:11PM PDT

no text wall here all im gonna say is it all depends on what you want to play if you have epeen issues get the big console (ps3) if you want a wide range of games get the reliable one (xbox360) if you want something that has a good gimmick get a wii. not that you care but i have a wii and a 360 the only reason i doth get a ps3 is because the controls bug me. so basically which ever you like the sound of the best

- Collapse -
Pick your poison...
Aug 19, 2009 4:27PM PDT

Of the three, the 360 was my first and still my favorite, but only just. Plus it has this hanging over its head, though in theory, current production models should be better:

http://blog.seattlepi.com/microsoft/archives/176741.asp

FWIW, I should note that I have an early, first-batch 360 that still is running strong, though I admit that I'm careful not to run the unit when the room temperature is relative hot (low 80s and up). However it seems clear that I'm definitely in the minority when it comes to 360 survivability and longevity.

My PS3 has been good...when entertaining, enjoyable games finally became available for the bloody thing. Blu-ray movies is a plus--for someone else--that I rarely bother with; I use my PS3 for gaming, and that does take away the available time for other uses. My PS3 however has developed a habit of 'black screening'; unlike the notorious red ring of death that 360s have been known for, my PS3 doesn't die completely...it's just that the video content doesn't get to the screen, which is almost as bad. Can't PLAY a game when I can't see anything.

My Wii was initially fun, but the lack of quality titles for older gamers has been a downer and consequently the thing of late is more bookend than usable game console. However, if you have young kids the Wii would be the ideal console, simply because of the immense focus of the Wii's game catalog and library for that target audience. Some of those games actually can be fun for older kids and adults, but at least to me it seems few and far between finding those. Also, my Wii no longer can read its game discs when the unit is set up lying on its side. Don't know exactly WHEN it happened to start doing this, but nonetheless it's been disappointing.

- Collapse -
Advice
Aug 20, 2009 12:40AM PDT

If You can stand it, getting two systems is best in my opinion. I have a nintendo Wii, but am also in the market for an Xbox 360 or a PS3. I started with the Wii, which has some decent titles. This led me to want a more intense gaming experience with the Xbox 360 or PS3. You can't really go wrong here.