Turns out Windows does this as I move the printer from one USB port to another.
I've yet to find any fix or workaround from Microsoft. Bug? Debateable.
Bob
Environment: 3 identical stationary printers and 1 laptop that's will use any 1 of the 3 given printers at different times.
Goal: to allow the laptop to be switched between the 3 printers without windows creating multiple copies of the same model printer
Problem: each time the laptop is hooked up to a new printer, windows creates another copy of the same model printer in the "printers" list.
I realize there is probably a s/n burned into the firmware of the printers that causes windows to see that it is a different printer (regardless if it's the same make and model). Is there a way to make windows think that all these printers are the same exact printer?
Any help, ideas, or guidance would be greatly appreciated.

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic