When did BOL start? I think it started 4/29/05. If that is the case, I have old shows dating back to then, and it has been Tom and Molly all along.
Back in the good ol' days of Buzz Out Loud (or Buzz Aloud as it's known to some) who was that guy who hosted the show with Molly? This was before Veronica really spoke much, and way before the Earthlink ad. It sounded like a very young guy (like a twenty-year-old kid). It didn't sound like Tom at all. It really sounded more like the "Earthlink guy." In fact, he hosted the show with another guy when Molly wasn't around every once in a while. Does anybody know who that was?

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic