i have netflix and really like it. I would go with at least the 2 movies at a time if i were you. I had the plan with one movie at a time (which is 2 movies a week) and would sometime miss the new releases and it would take forever to get them. Blockbuster is way to expensive. if you rent just 2 movies then that's the price of netflix for one month. I think its 14-16 dollars for 2 movies at a time. when you sign up u put the movies in your Que and you will get them the next day. watch one send it back the following day then watch the other and send it back the next following day. this way you will always have a new movie coming to you house within a day apart. you will probly get 4 movies a week with the 2 movies at a time plan. You also get to watch movies on ur computer and if you have an xbox 360 you will be able to watch them through that too when it updates. that means more HD movies any time you want. I also think you get to try it free for like 2 weeks or a month so you cant go wrong. Just try it.
Who has more BD titles, Netflix or Blockbuster? I live 1/2 mile from a Blockbuster so I could bring them back there, but if Netflix has more titles I'll join them.

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic