Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

What's the verdict on Windows 10 April 2018 Update?

May 4, 2018 4:08PM PDT

Before I jump headfirst into this latest April 2018 update for Windows 10, has anyone done it already? If you have, what's the verdict? Is it stable and have any problems cropped up that I should be made aware of? I'm sure I'm not the only one who is holding off on it until the signs are positive. Thankfully I didn't have any issue with the Fall Creators update, however I read enough about other people's problems that I am a bit paranoid this time. Any insight on the newest update that you can share, good or bad, will be helpful. Thank you kindly.

--Submitted by Tyler F.

Post was last edited on May 11, 2018 1:04 PM PDT

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Cor! Thirty minutes.
May 13, 2018 7:13AM PDT

Thanks Gerdd
Off to buy a fresh magic stick!
16GB should be enough?
I would appreciate any/all information circa your continuing success.

- Collapse -
Sure! Mine was 8GB.
May 13, 2018 2:11PM PDT

And the ISO files are +- 330 MB.

- Collapse -
since you need the "stick" too
May 13, 2018 2:21PM PDT
- Collapse -
Win 10 Pro problems
May 12, 2018 6:03PM PDT

I've four computers running Windows 10. Two are Pro. Windows home has updated seamlessly. My two with Pro just about made me think my SSD's were toast. I got them working now but one doesn't shut down cleanly and the other sometimes locks on bootup.

- Collapse -
Drivers and Firmware
Apr 20, 2019 2:48PM PDT

Did you try the latest SSD firmware and drivers? When I was doing a/v work at the office, I remember one director's laptop coming back with a full status. The owner said I was lying because he had some other guy install a "brand new" 64 GB SSD. Turns out that the issue was a bug in the firmware for the drive. It wasn't properly maintaining the free-space bit maps on the drive so Windows thought the drive was 1/2 empty but the drive itself claimed it was full. After the guy left, the new owner said the laptop was TERRIBLE. I upgraded firmware and it was then lightning fast. And half empty again.So, my suggestion would be to look at both the firmware (from the drive manufacturer) as well as make sure you have the correct Win 10 drivers (including 32-bit vs. 64-bit differences). May not help but won't hurt.

- Collapse -
Update killed palm reject function
May 12, 2018 9:44PM PDT

The update screwed up my asus pen. Palm reject no longer works in any of my programs. Spent hours troubleshooting, reinstalling drivers, programs etc. Tried different combos, (tablet mode on/ off, plugged in, rotation lock, pushed and held different buttons etc..). "Ignore touch input when using my pen" is essentially dead, can't figure out why.
The pen functionality is the only reason why I bought this 2-in-1 (Asus transformer mini).

Initially windows "Hello", sensors didn't work either, but reinstalling drivers fixed that.

Windows store also now caught in refresh loop when I try to "get" apps. Nothing fixed this either (including resting program). Therefore can't download any new programs from the store.

This update SUCKS.

- Collapse -
What's the verdict on Windows10 April 2018 Update
May 13, 2018 9:25AM PDT

Well I must say it went surprisingly well. First time ever. It was very busy updating and then came the dreadful question: reboot? So I did and was sweating it out but it went alright. I guess they finally did it right. Not too early!

- Collapse -
Unstable
May 13, 2018 10:27AM PDT

Since I installed Version 1803 OS Build 17134, I have had had frequent irregular problems..At times the system will not shut down properly and then hangs saying there is a problem. Also at times the system does not recognize items such as the printer, an SDHC card and even once the wireless keyboard and mouse. If I reboot the system then recognizes the features (if I can get past the reboot). Ah yes, I cannot add new Microsoft software or updates without doing a clean system.

- Collapse -
(NT) So far all is good.
May 13, 2018 1:50PM PDT
- Collapse -
"your computer is not compatible with Windows 10 anymore"
May 13, 2018 2:30PM PDT

After receiving the lastest update and barely being able to get my CPU to finally and barely function, I contacted Microsoft and I was told that I sould junk my HP and buy a new CPU, when I told them my model number!



My CPU has worked flawlessly on Windows 10 for almost four years The CPU is still working properly It appears that no one at Microsoft and/or HP had the forethought that some of us don't change our CPU's every three years!



The suggestion to go to Windows 8.1 (because "HP ONLY supports that", according to the MIcrosoft tech is outrageous) Microsoft sells Windows 10 as a complete and total upgrade to Windows 8.1 machines when it was introduced



I WOULD NEVER ALLOW THIS UPDATE TO INFECT MY CPU HAD MICROSOFT AND/OR HP GAVE A DISCLAIMER TO THIS ROTTEN UPDATE!



Any other thoughts by any one and/or similar nightmare experiances like this?!

- Collapse -
" Four years?
May 13, 2018 2:41PM PDT

Were you on the Windows "insider program?
You need to explain more.
Dafydd.

- Collapse -
There's an entire class of PCs that flunk out on updates.
May 13, 2018 2:55PM PDT

Don't ask me about the number of those 32GB storage Windows tablets and PCs. Just don't ask.
I don't accept them for work and defer the owners back to the maker. These were bad news.

- Collapse -
Is it one of those CPUs?
May 13, 2018 2:41PM PDT

" The following Intel Clover Trail processors are currently not supported on Windows 10 Creators Update:

* Atom Z2760

* Atom Z2520

* Atom Z2560

* Atom Z2580"

- Collapse -
My Netbook; My Netbook!
May 13, 2018 4:04PM PDT

Well, I guess it has to stay on Win XP!

Heh

- Collapse -
I have one of these Atom CPU netbooks on W10
May 13, 2018 4:11PM PDT

Microsoft blocked this update. Still runs fine.

- Collapse -
Linux Mint...
May 14, 2018 9:48AM PDT

Linux Mint (based on ubuntu) is running great on my 2 Acer NetBooks with 2gb or less ram!

- Collapse -
Intel Cherry Trail Z8300 CPU Laptops Destroyed
May 14, 2018 9:36AM PDT

We have two Windows-run Intel Cherry Trail Z8300 CPU laptops that were destroyed by the recent big Windows update. They won't boot up (black screen after maker's name is shown), won't repair (after clicking that button), can't system restore (pressing that button shows that there is no restore point or previous version of Windows to revert back to), and can't even install a fresh clean, fresh install from a USB drive with the Windows 10 OS on it (This results in a fail also.) I've been fiddling with these machines for at least a week now, with no luck. I think this is the moment that is going to send me fleeing to one of the versions of the Linux operating system. Does anyone know which version/flavor of Linux is easiest to use for former Windows users?

- Collapse -
I think that's best.
May 14, 2018 9:38AM PDT

But other than Linux I'm about to try out ChromeOS on such as well.

These will be retired to use as Chromebooks.

- Collapse -
Here's an option!
May 14, 2018 9:45AM PDT

Linix Mint (based on ubuntu) is very light weight and Windows Like.
i am running it on several, very old pcs. i have 2 Acer NetBooks with 2gb or less with it on them and they run quite well!

- Collapse -
THANK YOU!
May 14, 2018 5:51PM PDT

Thank you for the helpful tip! I'll check out Linux Mint as a replacement option for Windows.

- Collapse -
As mentioned previously: Puppy Linux is a great starting poi
May 14, 2018 10:00AM PDT

Zero effort to get started. Then, if you feel like it and have become more familiar with the Linux way, try migrating to Mint or any of the other Ubuntus - I haven't tried Mint myself but only heard good things about it. In the not too distant future a bit of light reading on the Unix/Linux way would probably be helpful. It will go a long way towards understanding what is digferent from Windows and why.

- Collapse -
THANK YOU--i'll check it out.
May 14, 2018 5:52PM PDT

I will check out Puppy Linux, then. Thank you for the suggestion!

- Collapse -
Two of three good, so far
May 13, 2018 4:59PM PDT

Two of my three computers have updated to 1803 without any serious issue. There is a preference that got reset. They turn off the screen after 15 mins. Didn't take long to find that and change it. A very minor annoyance.

- Collapse -
Mixed Bag
May 13, 2018 5:12PM PDT

Installing the April 2018 was a disaster on one of our computers and smooth as silk another one.

The first computer just won't install the update whether it's done through Windows Update or using the Media Creation Tool. In one case, the update just froze the computer. In the other case, the update froze at 20%. I was forced to use a back up image of the "c" drive to get the computer working again (always make a back up image of the drive on which your operating system resides before allowing these major updates). This computer is older with an AMD FX-8300 or thereabouts CPU.

The other computer -- with an AMD Ryzen 1700 CPU, etc -- installed the update via Windows Update without any problems at all, smooth as silk.

So it seems there are two lessons:
(1) Always make a back up image of the drive on which your operating system resides before attempting a major Windows 10 update like this.
(2) Your mileage will vary. Anything can happen with these updates. So tread carefully and maybe delay the update (which you can do with Windows 10 Pro) for a few weeks which will give Microsoft more time to fix the installation bugs.

- Collapse -
No significant problems, 13 machines
May 13, 2018 5:23PM PDT

OK, have been upgrading the Win10 1803 from the 1st May on into 13 machines with the automatic loading/install, few Pro most Home, as well as few Desktops most Laptops, and the most even on remote control, without any significant problems.

The 12th, a Desktop with Home did have an issue with error 0x80070003 in the end of the process after some 3-4hrs, a sigh …, but was cleared up soon quite easily with the Windows Update Troubleshooting procedure.

So, I anyway see this 1803 upgrade already a very reliable and ripe one, compared with the previous four, looked in backwards order, had been having more and more problems, and now already much less, which is quite natural on development process.

Of course there should be taken in consideration, that these machines have been quite standard office/home configurations, but in all there is in question 100's of mill.'s machines, with different configurations and devices and ageing uncompatible hardware and software components, as seen e.g. with the January 2018 routine update catastrophal case, locking 10's or 100's of thousands if not even mill.'s of machines already just after pushing the power button, due to the update addressed to the newer processor techniques, but was of course cleared here and there somehow, myself forced to re-install 3 machines totally from scratch …… (and guess who was willing to pay for the work, got just some really minimal compensation for any of those …&hellipWink

OK, now I have some 10 machines more to be upgraded, of which one Intel i7 Desktop on video production didn't even accept the 1709 upgrade at all despite several 3-4hrs trials and other life-saving procedures ... so, there is at least that one big challenge with 1703 left in the queue …

The others are expected to get upgraded smoothly as these 12 plus 1 sightly problematic have been showing fluency, but you never know …

So, the final verdict from me -> this 1803 upgrade is already a very reliable and ripe one on quite standard cases, but with more and more specialities and ageing, probability for problems will increase and could be expected!

- Collapse -
About the 13th one...
May 13, 2018 5:32PM PDT

Can you tell us what is different about the one computer that didn't go so well? Was there ANY hardware or installed software the other 12 didn't have?

- Collapse -
Sorry, it was the 12th one …
May 13, 2018 5:40PM PDT

Most of these machines are on different sites by different owners and somehow different configurations by hardware and software etc., so, it's too hard or even impossible to compare, sorry ...

- Collapse -
INMY OPINION,CLEARLY A CASE FOR A GOOD CLASS ACTION LAWSUIT!
May 13, 2018 5:23PM PDT

I just got off the phone with the same Microsoft tech (calling from Mumbai , India?) that informed me yesterday that I should junk my cpu!

In all honesty, the update should have been programmed so that it wouldn't load in "non compatible" equipment in the least, and at best, there should have been a new system release, if Microsoft and HP want to sell you new computers

Microsoft made it a point to have a "compatibility test" before installing Windows 10 in computers. They should have done the same with the most recent update, but it is THEIR responsibility to support ALL equipment that has Windows 10 installed, because that is how Windows 10 was originally pandered to all of its customers!

If there are any good law firms out there, in my opinion, this definitely qualifies as a class action lawsuit!

- Collapse -
You believe the tech?
May 13, 2018 5:35PM PDT

Before you see a big time lawyer, better get a second opinion about whether you should junk your CPU. Not that these phone-tech folks in India are ever wrong....

- Collapse -
I wish you the best of luck.
May 13, 2018 5:41PM PDT

But there have been few successes. Maybe you'll win but I doubt it.