But I think for a gaming site, it's a bit dark and monotone in colour. With all the carbon and gray you've used, the blue menu with a yellow hover stands out a bit too much. I would try to redesign it to be a bit more inviting looking, colourful (not loaded with colours just a nice colour combination)
I would also suggest making a logo rather than having your "Online Arcade Games" in the corner using the Bleeding Cowboys font. I'd also probably move the "2011 update" to the top and put it in a nice content box rather than just slapped at the bottom with no styling to it.
Hey all.

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic