General discussion

Wal Mart & Unions

http://money.canoe.ca/News/Economy/2005/02/09/925527-cp.html

Wal-Mart closing unionized store

MONTREAL (CP) - Denying it wants to bust the union, Wal-Mart announced Wednesday it will close a Quebec store whose employees were negotiating to become the first ever to establish a union contract from the world's biggest retailer.

The closest a U.S. union has ever come to winning a battle with Wal-Mart was in 2000, at a store in Jacksonville, Texas. In that store, 11 workers - all members of the store's meatpacking department - voted to join and be represented by the UFCW.

That effort failed when Wal-Mart eliminated the job of meatcutter companywide, and moved away from in-store meatcutting to stocking only pre-wrapped meat.


Wal Mart is Non Union at any expense

Discussion is locked

Follow
Reply to: Wal Mart & Unions
PLEASE NOTE: Do not post advertisements, offensive materials, profanity, or personal attacks. Please remember to be considerate of other members. If you are new to the CNET Forums, please read our CNET Forums FAQ. All submitted content is subject to our Terms of Use.
Reporting: Wal Mart & Unions
This post has been flagged and will be reviewed by our staff. Thank you for helping us maintain CNET's great community.
Sorry, there was a problem flagging this post. Please try again now or at a later time.
If you believe this post is offensive or violates the CNET Forums' Usage policies, you can report it below (this will not automatically remove the post). Once reported, our moderators will be notified and the post will be reviewed.
Comments
- Collapse -
(NT) (NT) well thats wallmarts right
- Collapse -
(NT) (NT) That's right It is
- Collapse -
(NT) (NT) And the people have a right to unionize
- Collapse -
yes they do and wall mart has the right to close

that store so who losses?

- Collapse -
So much for Wal-Mart

being good to it's employees. Another myth busted.

Dan

- Collapse -
wallmart not at fault

why need money sucking union?

- Collapse -
re

In my younger days, I belonged to the CWA(Communication Workers of America) With Ohio Bell. Looking back that many years ago, I can say I am proud to have been affiliated with them. We got a lot of things that are taken for granted by employees today, by walking the picket line. The unions also lobbied legislation for safety, income protection : Like disability payments. Got much of it passed too. Yes there are cases of union abuse but we have much to be thankful for from the unions.

- Collapse -
your right mkay

and you do have a valid point, no arguments at all

but wallmart has the right to say no to a union.

- Collapse -
Really they don't.

If the workers vote in a union then Wal-Mart has to accept it.

Or, they can exercise their narrow, greedy, uncompassionate, hypocritical, sour grapes addled minds and close the store, fire the workers, and forgo the profits.

*sigh*

Dan

- Collapse -
Walmart has to accept it ...

... but they have a right to close a store as well. Unionizing the workforce for large retail establishments is only going to raise the cost of your goods and lower the service. If you think the service is bad now, just bring in a union!

- Collapse -
re

Evie, I don't know where you teach. but are they not unionized? Have you not reaped any of the benefits obtained by the struggles of many in the past through the union???

- Collapse -
Unions have been the kiss of death for quality

education. They protect the incompetent, and aren't much concerned about the kids.

- Collapse -
Some union ...

... some not. In the teaching field it doesn't matter much. Tenure is the only "protection" and I don't agree with tenure. Otherwise, merit is not rewarded in the profession. Only seniority and kissing butt. If my payscale depended even one iota on performance it would make a difference. But so long as a teacher is not failing too many students so that the school can maintain their tuition quotas, that seems to be the important thing these days Sad

- Collapse -
re

I have 3 children and 1 GC in the teaching profession and they are all in a union....

- Collapse -
Your point?

They have probably benefitted. The business (education) and the consumer (parents & tax payers) have definitely not.

- Collapse -
(NT) (NT) and thats wallmarts right as i said
- Collapse -
This is precisely why entire COMPANIES must be unionized,

When it happens store by store or plant by plant, too much chance of the company "making an example" of one unit that dares defy its will.

-- Dave K, Speakeasy Moderator
click here to email semods4@yahoo.com

The opinions expressed above are my own,
and do not necessarily reflect those of CNET!

- Collapse -
(NT) (NT) and the greedy unions want to much stores close
- Collapse -
Workers today don't buy that Dave. Unions have

driven entire industries out of business at the expense of the consumer. Employers today know that they cannot mistreat workers and remain in business. However, they cannot afford to be strangled by unions and still retain their competitive edge. Think railroads.

- Collapse -
Some clarification please

I see the point that if the entire company is unionized they won't close one site to make an example.

Do you also believe that if one site can't reach an agreement the union should close down the entire company? all it's sites?

Should a strike at one site mean a supporting stike at the unionized supplier for the entire company? that's happened before with GM and one of it's sites and suppliers as I recall. The two unions had some sort of support agreement that if one struck, they both did.

So should one site disagreement shut a company down across the country?

JMO

Roger

click here to email semods4@yahoo.com

- Collapse -
Without Unions, 60 hour weeks would still be the norm,

Mark. Yes, Unions can over-reach and damage the economy. But for all of society to benefit, there has to be a balance of power between unions (=workers) and employers. For the last 25 years, that balance has be tipped over to the favor of employers, to the detriment of all but the wealthy stockholders, and more recently, of upper management.

-- Dave K, Speakeasy Moderator
click here to email semods4@yahoo.com

The opinions expressed above are my own,
and do not necessarily reflect those of CNET!

- Collapse -
well acording to the article

union wanted to much money so who loses?

- Collapse -
union wanted to much money

How much is too much?

Too much by whose standards?

What do you think is "fair wage" for 1 hours work in a Wal-Mart

- Collapse -
as i not the owner i don't know

but the article said union wanted to much

so as your so concerned(sarcasm) why dont you call them and say hey your wrong.
as im not in charge but why do i think you wont?

- Collapse -
OK

You're not an owner, but lets say your a worker, How much would you consider a fair wage?

- Collapse -
well as i was

in computer repairs i got 15 bucks an hr
onsite much more.

now i work for myself i get lot more.

but im not working for k mart wallmart, target circut city etc.

of course i wasnt selling cds, or what more teck work


and non union Grin

- Collapse -
As much as I can beg, borrow, or steal and still have a job.

Throw in plenty of vacation also. That sounds fair to me.

- Collapse -
The article didn't say the union wanted too much money

It said that Wal-Mart claimed that the union wanted the wages raised too much and too many more staff hired.

You are presenting their side of the story as fact, when it's just one side of the story.

And FWIW my wife is in a union and would have been out of a job years ago (or wouldn't have nearly the salary or benefits she currently has) were it not for the hard work of her union. It's also the union that protects her against her employer trying to force its people to work excessive hours with inadequate time for rest/sleep, something her employer has been taken to task for more than once.

Unions are not irrelevant because of their past successes resulting in federal laws (which a lot of Conservatives oppose BTW) that protect workers. The need for continued vigilance and action is a real one.

- Collapse -
well all that matters is that

wallmart felt they were asking to much.
if the people would said no union then end of prob

and as i said b4 if it wqs my place and it ment my proffit gone or union id close it but then u new that

- Collapse -
It is the owner and the market who decide that.

The union must boost their members' wages and benefits above their market value before it is useful.

CNET Forums

Forum Info