Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

VHS to DVD copying help needed...

Oct 1, 2007 6:25AM PDT

I would like to convert my VHS tapes to DVD's using my PC and need recommendations for hardware and editing software.

My PC is running XP professional, 2ghz, DVD burner, Nero Express.

I have a stand alone SONY DVD burner which I am now using to copy tapes but I need editing software so now I have to use my PC for editing.

A nice touch would be hardware for inputting and outputting the video and audio to my SONY burner after editing.

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
I copied analog video to my computer into digital format
Oct 2, 2007 5:43AM PDT

I went to office depot's software section and found VHS to DVD software. It comes with hardware that lets you connect a VCR or VCP to a peripheral on one end, then a USB or maybe a firewire port on the other end connects to the computer. I also bought Digital Video for Dummies 4th edition at Barnes and Noble which talks about capturing analog video from VHS tapes and transferring it to digital video on computer. I am doing the same thing of transferring my VHS tapes to DVD, but I don't need that software and hardware. I got a new computer that already has it. I can plug my VCR into my desktop PC's composite or S-video port. Then, using my Roxio media import software, all I need to do is click a capture button on the computer, then the play button on the VCR. The computer won't control the VCR so I have to manually rewind and play the VCR to where I want video captured. The computer is an HP m8000n media center desktop PC.

- Collapse -
Dazzle DVC-90
Oct 6, 2007 12:28PM PDT

I used a "Dazzle DVC90 comes with Pinnacle Studio? QuickStart movie making software" that I got from WOOT, I think, and it was very inexpensive. I converted all of my VHS tapes to DVD then "retired" my Sharp SlimCam and the DVC-90 and bought a new 3CCD Panasonic camcorder.

The DVC-90 connects to the computer with a USB cable. I thought the Pinacle software video editing and DVD burning worked fine.

The quality of the video was just ok but then the VHS tape videos were just ok.

- Collapse -
don't buy a dazzle
Oct 8, 2007 12:36PM PDT

I purchased a dazzle to put some home videos onto DVD. I had a very poor experience with the Pinnacle software- it is a very crude editing program. When you capture video, you have to edit it in the pinnacle program, with the option to upgrade. The quality of video was poor, and DVD rendering/writing didn't always work.

- Collapse -
USB2?
Oct 9, 2007 12:48PM PDT

Do you have a computer with USB2 ports? I don't recall having more than a couple of dropped frames when converting 6 or 8 two hour VHS tapes to DVD. Rendering and writing the DVD always worked fine...I think it was Pinnacle Studio 9.

- Collapse -
A bit more complicated than it needs to be, but it works
Oct 8, 2007 10:44PM PDT

..for me anyway. I had lots of trouble with dropped frames using USB capture, I tried a standalone DVD recorder (they're under $70 these days) but I wasn't happy with the MPEG encoding. I finally ended up using my Canon ZR60 camcorder to input analog video & output firewire to my PC. I've had very few cases of dropped frames with firewire. It takes a while to convert to MPEG2 with multiple passes for optimum quality, but if it's saving your home videos for posterity, it's worth the trouble.

- Collapse -
VHS to DVD
Oct 12, 2007 10:26AM PDT

I am using the DVDXpressDX2 kit that comes with the capture device to which you connect your VCR and computer. It comes with CapWiz software to use for your capture step and Ulead VideoStudio 9 SE DVD software for the editing and burning of the video once it is in your computer. My computer is a plain vanilla DELL (not a multimedia like some other poster has), that's why I needed the capture device and software. I'm happy with the results, although I had to do plenty of reading the manual and looking at tutorials before I started the whole process. Good luck!

- Collapse -
Consider using a VCR-DVD Recorder combination unit
Oct 12, 2007 12:02PM PDT

In my particular case, I bought a VCR-DVD recorder combo set at Wal-Mart: MAGNAVOX MWR20V6; this was partly because I do not have a VCR (my tapes all date back from 10 years ago). I dub a VHS tape (or segment therof)to a blank DVD; then I copy the DVD contents to my computer hard drive. Then I convert the original .vob files from the dubbed DVD to .wmv with Windows Media Encoder. Then I import/process/edit the video with Windows Movie Maker and eventually make a new, edited movie to DVD with Windows DVD Maker. I found there were numerous little things you have to take care of to get a good final product. A helpful web site is: http://www.windowsmoviemakers.net/forums/
Good luck and have fun!

- Collapse -
Winfast TV USB II
Oct 12, 2007 6:02PM PDT

I have had a Winfast TV USB II for more than a year now and it does excellent service converting analogue video signals onto my laptop. It also comes bundled with Ulead video factory. Additionally I use TMPenc Authoring for editing and menu creation. You will need a USB 2.0 connection but with the specifications you mentioned I suspect you have more than enough to run this hardware and software.

- Collapse -
Second on the TMPenc Authoring tools
Oct 15, 2007 12:55AM PDT

TMPenc Authoring tools are the best bang for your buck when it comes to menu creation and editing. Sure there are more intuitive tools that cost tons of money, but even they don't do much better than TMPenc. I should shut up because if it becomes too popular they'll probably raise the price.

- Collapse -
Hauppage
Oct 13, 2007 12:47AM PDT

Most any of the Hauppauge video input cards will work. It comes with software for doing this kind of thing. There are lots of forums dedicated to doing what you want to do with a Hauppauge card.

I discourage using a cheap off-brand card.