Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

This is a minatory post regarding electric power.

Mar 15, 2010 3:15PM PDT

In the late 1970's and 89's the Austrians won all the major competitions in glider aircraft because they recognized that if a winning formula was to be put together, speeds had reached a point where industrial processes needed to be involved, so the national association of modellers received modest funding and assistance from people knowledgeable about creating light carbon fibre structured and bodied aircraft. They fielded a team with virtually the same plane and won year after year. There was no way the independent garage or basement based competitors from everywhere, especially the United States could compete. Now I've been out of aeromodelling for a long time, but at the same time the above happened huge advances were being made in the small electrical motors and battery packs being built for model aircraft in Switzerland and Germany and Scandinavia.

"So what!", I hear you all grumbling. Well advances that can be made small can lead to significant things when enlarged. There are a number of European electric cars ready to go, all because their governments dropped a few hundred thoudand dollars on research in quiet corners, while Detroit was trying to popularize the biggest gas guzzler on the planet, The Hummer, for family use.

Now we'd already seen the Volkswagen come in in the 1950's, and the Japanese come in in the late 60's and 70' and Mercedes and BMW come in in the 80's to the point where Detroit land barges sat on the lots. Ford, UK, had a number of cars that could have done extremely well here, including a replacement for the VW Bug, but Ford didn't want it. They still learned enough not to need bailing out. They got the Escort from Britain, and the Focus, and the Mercury Contour which was a cheapened version of what I drove in Britain, the Mondeo. The Mondeo didn't sell all that well, because they stripped all the nice bits off it, but I notice a surprising number of them still driving around which suggests reliability.

What I'm pointing out is that the car companies abroad and governments abroad are working together to create the vehicles that have hamstrung the American Car industry, and if fuel efficiency, efficiency in size, and a sensible concept of public needs don't get fufilled by the car companies, they're going down the tubes again.

Put the huge transports in special lanes so that they don't mix with small traffic except at lower speeds and keep the cars small and efficient. You'll use less energy, recover a part of your lost share of the car market, and anyone who wants a Lincoln or a Cadillac has switched to a Mercedes or BMW influenced car anyway.

Rob

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Minatory
Mar 16, 2010 2:00AM PDT

From the OED: Minatory ? adjective formal threatening.

Are you saying your post was a threatening post about electric power?

- Collapse -
Thanks for that. I always took minatory as meaning
Mar 17, 2010 3:13PM PDT

a warning rather than a threat, but I could be wrong. I'm certainly not intending to threaten.

Rob

- Collapse -
(NT) You're welcome Polly
Mar 19, 2010 1:09PM PDT
- Collapse -
Something important to consider
Mar 17, 2010 2:27AM PDT

but difficult to calculate is when addition energy is expended to the point of diminishing returns. If our primary goal is to maximize mpg, that single focus might not lead to an overall reduction in energy use. There would be a long list of expenses and energy costs that go into research, tooling, factory building, etc. before a vehicle reaches the market. There are other costs in the way of maintenance that need to be considered...especially with vehicles that tend to be sensitive to such. One thing I've noted over the years is that precision tuned engines seem to require more frequent oil changes though other maintenance items seem to last longer. We also need to consider a vehicles useful life and the energy cost of replacement. Miles per gallon is just one piece of a much larger equation whose other components aren't easily measurable.

- Collapse -
I am hoping for pure electric power, with hybrid as an
Mar 17, 2010 3:37PM PDT

addition for people who have to drive long distances. I really think that 90% of driving can be taken care of by a car that offers 50 miles a day. I also think that new battery technology can raise that to 100 eventually. Now there was a time when I had to do 240 miles every weekend when my mother was in the Nursing Home. I'd have to look for some other form of transport to take care of that, maybe hybrid. But most people don't usually drive much more than 20 miles each way, 40 miles a day. If we had a plug-in car that charged over 10 hours it could work wonders. And if it were free of the complexity of internal combustion engines and was made in large numbers, it could be cheap. I may be wrong but A. you don't need a complex engine or B. a transmission.

The big problem I see is that light electric vehicles will be at a disadvantage in crashes with 4X4's and SUV's and Trucks. I hope there may be some species of fix for this using resilient modern materials, but it's still an issue. Perhaps re-working the interstate system to sequester truck traffic from personal vehicle traffic.

I very well remember a white knuckle drive with my family into Chicago a couple of years after the big building spree of large highways. The reservoir of windshield washer fluid gave out, and all we could do was smear muddy truck-wheel goo. My dad ended up driving using that little semi circle underneath where the windshield wipers went. We made it fine to my Aunt and Uncle's place, and lest you think my dad was a bit reckless, he managed to get through his life without an accident. Wish I could say the same, I got caught by black ice and broke the tail light of the guy in front of me.

Rob