Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Thinking of switching from Palm OS to Windows - any advice?

Feb 16, 2006 2:21PM PST

I have a Sony Clie that badly needs replacing. I am used to the Palm OS system & use my PDA alot. I have always liked the look of Windows CE...

Will I have any issues or problems getting all of my data onto the new PDA I buy?

Or should I just stick with a Palm OS product?

Either way - what is a good device around $200-$300? I love the look of my Clie & am looking for something similiar...

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Either or...
Feb 17, 2006 9:02AM PST

You can go in either direction...Palm or Windows Mobile. I used to use the Palm, but switched to the PocketPC a couple of years ago and have been quite satisfied. Below I'll give you some options and let you decide for yourself which road you wish to take. If you stick with the Palm you shouldn't have much of a problem transferring your data using their own system. If you go in the direction of the PocketPC, you'll want to click here for a Cnet Weekend Project tutorial to becoming a WindowsMobile user for free instead of purchasing the costly third-party applications.

Dell X51 low:
* Windows Mobile 5.0
* 416MHz processor speed
* 64MB RAM for multitasking
* 128MB ROM for storage
* Bluetooth only
* Standard 240x320 QVGA display.
* User-replacable battery. (Lasts around 4 hours of use.)
* Accepts SD and CF memory cards.
* On sale for $239 (normally $299)

Dell X51 mid:
* Windows Mobile 5.0
* 520MHz processor speed
* 64MB RAM for multitasking
* 128MB ROM for storage
* Bluetooth and WiFi
* Standard 240x320 QVGA display.
* User-replacable battery. (Lasts around 4 hours of use.)
* Accepts SD and CF memory cards.
* On sale for $319 (normally $399)

Palm Tungsten E2:
* Palm OS 5.4
* 200MHz processor speed
* 32MB internal memory.
* Bluetooth only.
* Non-user-replacable battery. (Lasts around 4.5 hours of use.)
* Nice 320x320 display.
* Accepts SD memory cards.
* $199

Palm TX:
* Palm OS 5.4
* 312MHz processor speed
* 128MB internal memory.
* Bluetooth and WiFi.
* Non-user-replacable battery. (Lasts around 5 hours of use.)
* Beautiful 320x480 display.
* Accepts SD memory cards.
* $299

Hope this helps,
John

- Collapse -
Either or...
Feb 17, 2006 11:53PM PST

Not bad at all - thanks for the feedback. Do you know about a Palm based program that is similar to Avantgo ? I cannot access their service with my Zire 72 and I am looking for an alternative to them - their support page reads like the infield - fly rule of baseball. I got tired of them and I am looking for an alternative or a competitor.

- Collapse -
I've heard of one...
Feb 19, 2006 11:53AM PST

I've heard positive feedback about of one alternative to AvantGo, though I've never tried it. It's called Plucker and you can read about it by clicking here. It's completely free and designed for the Palm OS, so it may be a better fit than the AvantGo convert.

Let us know what you think.
John

- Collapse -
Thank you
Feb 19, 2006 10:21PM PST

I will give that one a tryout - thanks for telling me about it. Keep those tips coming - one never knows where that next gold mine may be buried, waiting to be discovered. Thanks again. If there is a way to find other ones like Plucker, let me know - like I said, the next gold mine is waiting.

- Collapse -
I have a Palm based PDA/cell phone and have...
Feb 18, 2006 9:41PM PST

considered a Windows device but my biggest problem with any but the most expensive Windows based devices is the screen resolution.

My Treo 600 doesn't have a high resolution screen but my Zire 72 does. After having browsed the available pickings in the Windows format I've come away unimpressed. I can't accept the lower resolution of the Windows offerings after having become accustomed to the beautiful screen of my Zire 72. One of the reasons I won't trade my Treo 600 up to a Treo 700w. I'll just stick with Palm based PDAs.

This may be nit-picking to some people but the graininess of the Windows screen is distracting for me and unacceptable. A high resolution Windows PDA is available but it generally costs so much more and isn't available in a phone device. The screen of the iPaq hX4700 is very beautiful but is dark and is not so beautiful that it out-does the screen of my Zire 72. It's also $609.00 at Newegg.

After having used the various programs I have for my Palm based PDAs I am contentedly satisfied with the beautiful 320 X 320 screen resolution Palm provides.

My advice would be to compare both products.