I like the option of 1/2 sheet or a full sheet.
Often 1/2 sheet is enough for what I need.
No I don't cut my sandwiches in 1/2.
This morning I reach for a paper towel. I pull on it and get half a sheet. Why you may ask? Because it's one of those hated rolls that is perforated at half sheet sizes. There should be a big warning notice on these half sheet rolls to avoid getting them by accident. Did you ever see anyone buy a roll of full sheets, bring it home, then cut it across the middle with a hack saw so they could have two rolls of half sheet sizes? NO! NEVER!! Whoever came up with the idea for half sheets of paper towels should end up having to use half sheets of toilet paper too at his home. He should be restricted to half size cups of coffee at a time. He's probably the sort of person who cuts his sandwiches in half too.
What sort of usual consumer items irritate you?

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic