Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

The Flippin' Bird!

Nov 26, 2003 9:09PM PST

It's going on 5:00 a.m. in California and I've been up for hours already. Another traditional Thanksgiving morning, which, as always, tends to make a flamboyant display of the differences between myself and Martha Stewart on the homemaking front. Until that lady learns that fine dinner linen DOES come with names like Bounty ior Brawny, in rolls of 150+ sheets, the fancier ones being double quilted with seasonal motifs imprinted on them, ready to tear off and use, I think we will never see eye-to-eye.

Already, I am facing a stunning blow to my already severely challenged cooking skills. Normally this is best displayed when the time for eating comes round and I try to convince people that having all the courses ready within three hours of each other DOES count as being all ready at once. (This trick works best if the first course is cookies for the kids, and copious amounts of wine for the adults, btw).

But this morning the flippin' turkey and I are already going round and round over its stubborn refusal to thaw. Now, I bought that bird fair and square Tuesday evening (highly advanced planning for me). I dutifully shotputted it onto a shelf in the refigerator once I got it home, not wanting to subject people to salmonella or worse from improper poultry handling. And now, before its still-living friends and relatives are even crowing or gibbering this a.m., the darned bird remains frozen through solid as a rock! I mean, it's only 15 1/2 pounds; not like my usual Tool Time theory of cooking: bigger-is-better!

Right now, after having had a long chat with the bird over my lack of appreciation of its stubborn streak (it frostily ignored me), I have it bathing in the luxury of once-warm water in my kitchen sink (it turned the water to ice water, defeating that plan). Gentle massage under warm running water seems to only cause a wing to flap in derision at my attempts. Yes, I am beginning ot suspect it is flipping me off. I soon found there is not much you can threaten an already dead and frozen bird with. But, like hitting the stubborn cola machine at work, it at least makes me feel like I've engaged in self-help to at least try.

I would put it in the oven on a low temperature to thaw some, but as I recall, last time someone turned the heat up too high to "help," we discovered that that plastic on the bird does indeed melt and adhere to the bird surface at some point. Only the most kind of guests will politely agree that having the Zachy Farms slogan melted into the bird's butt is just a good way of showing everyone how fresh the bird really is.

I am giving some consideration to convincing my daughter that turkey bowling is a new tradition to be performed in the driveway with the yams that my husband despises used for bowling pins. A quick trip to KFC, would solve most of the holiday problems, even providing fancy little desserts with ruffled whipped cream in cute little plastic containers. But before I get to that point, do any of you non-culinary-challenged folks have any ideas of how to force this bird into thawed submission fast?

BTW, how many of you REALLY cute those little radishes into rosebud shapes on the vegetable plate? I keep hoping that the myth of the perfect meal will show up in Snopes, but so far, they have not addressed that point. . .

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Sorry, Diane ....
Nov 26, 2003 9:19PM PST

I think that Monday was the latest to put a frozen turkey in the fridge for thawing. Not sure what to do now. Butterball.com has a lot of info. Maybe they can tell you what to do. Good luck and keep the wine flowing! BTW, have you had any of the new Beaujolais? - I'm serving some today.

- Collapse -
Re:Sorry, Diane ....
Nov 26, 2003 9:46PM PST

Thank you, Mark! I will give the Butterball site a try. I don't think I got roasting bags, and have no clue if we even had a heating pad, so I may have to modify Edward's ideas otherwise.

And as I was so rudely informed last New Years, my lack of knowledge of cooking is vastly exceeded by my ignorance in alcohol - fine or otherwise. I can tell wine only by the clear white type, the pink ones and the red ones. I have NO idea what a Beaujolais is, but if it tastes good, I may try to find some to serve to my intended victims, whoops, I mean guests! I still am unclear about why the large plastic drinking cups from Burger King with the pictures of the basketball players on them were so inappropriate to serve the wine in last time. Perhaps it was football season? Wink

- Collapse -
Re:Re:Sorry, Diane ....
Nov 26, 2003 10:15PM PST

1. Any of your friends/neighbors have tanning beds? (never tried this but might work)

2. How about a sauna? (never tried this but might work)

3. No heat pad? a 100W or better incandescent bulb (husband's trouble light if he works on cars) should serve but without roasting bags may be problematic as far as sanitation goes (hint, if you have to go this route gift certificates to the local emergency room may be reasonable Christmas gifts). (never tried this but should work)

4. Take bird to store with you, get roasting bags, place bird in roasting bag, place bird in bag in engine compartment, go for scenic drive and relax while bird basks (and thaws) in warmth of engine compartment. (never tried this but should work as a slight variation adequately cooks hot dogs--avoid canned goods if trying this)

- Collapse -
You might want to wrap the whole thing in aluminum foil for #4
Nov 26, 2003 10:18PM PST

I actually saw a series of email newsletters about using car engines as the heat source for cooking. Hard to believe.

It is apparently possible to do a good bit of cooking while driving cross country, but you have to make sure everything is sealed up tight.

I don't think I'd try it for a holiday meal. Your heating pad idea sounded more reasonable.

- Collapse -
Re:Re:Sorry, Diane ....
Nov 26, 2003 10:33PM PST

Diane, the Beaujolais Nouveau is the new wine made right after the harvest - it is always released one week before Thanksgiving. It is a light, drinkable red wine which can be served chilled with Thanksgiving dinner. If any wine snobs tell you different, just look down your nose at them and say "Oh really?" Happy

The release of Beaujolais Nouveau is celebrated around the world at the same time, and many restaurants have special meals as part of the celebration.

Here's a website for those interested:

http://www.beaujolais.net/eng/page.htm

Mark

- Collapse -
I hope you enjoy the wine ...
Nov 26, 2003 10:15PM PST

We opened a bottle of the new Beaujolais yesterday evening for supper. My wife always looks forward to Thanksgiving and Beaujolais Nouveau.

I have to admit, though, that I didn't like this year's stuff as much as usual. But that's just me. Others may find it more appealing than I did.

- Collapse -
Re:I hope you enjoy the wine ...
Nov 26, 2003 10:29PM PST

Hmmm, well, I haven't had any yet, but the reviews I've read suggested a good year. I bought some Georges Duboeuf, so we'll see.

- Collapse -
Drink it up and enjoy ...
Nov 26, 2003 10:35PM PST

I didn't think it was awful ... I just didn't like it as well as most of the previous years. You may find it quite satisfactory.

One of the unpredictable things about wine is that individual tastes vary a good bit. Wine that I like may not appeal to somebody else, and conversely.

- Collapse -
Re:The Flippin' Bird!
Nov 26, 2003 9:25PM PST

I'd tell you I laughed hysterically but you might send me into space. If it's any consolation, we have all had our disasters. I've had too many to even admit to. But one that stands out in my mind is the first time it was my turn to be the host. I wanted everything to be special. I had never baked bread b4. After getting the recipe an ignorant 20 yr old set about to do this. Everything looked beautiful at the table, the bird was a picturesque golden brown the potatoes mashed smooth as silk. I opened the oven to get the bread out. It smelled great. I pulled the rack forward and pop , Out came dough flying so high it hit abd stuck to the ceiling. Nobody told me you had to raise the dough b4 baking.

- Collapse -
Re:Re:The Flippin' Bird!
Nov 26, 2003 10:06PM PST

Mary Kay, glad to hear that there are others out there who had had cooking "issues" too! Wink

I've learned many things over the years, including:

1) Never believe the kids when they tell you they thoroughly poked the baking potatoes before putting them in the microwave (and yes, the microwave door CAN be blown off by exploding potatoes).

2) The melted juice of baked sweet potatoes will exceed the holding power of all marketed superglue, yet will still burn with black, acrid smoke if left in the oven for the next time you use it.

3) The Emergency Room cannot do much for parts of knuckles removed while grating cheese or peeling potatoes (also most guests get queasy when the cook's hand is wrapped in bloody bandages).

4) Never serve cranberry or grape juice at the same time you are serving wine and leave the kids to "remember" which cup was theirs. Also, after half a glass, a foul taste will not deter them from seeking more (they also get sloppy about advance potty planning after half a glass of wine).

5) Never let the kids who help with the meals see you remove the dressing. A loud announcement of "Ewwww! That came out of it's BUTT!!!!!!'" takes a bit of explaining to calm the younger guests.

6) If keeping the neck of the turkey to eat, always explain to the young boys ahead of time that it is THE NECK, and not some other part they think a boy bird might have.

7) Never respond immediately to a scream while using the electric beaters on mashed potatoes or gravy unless they happen to match your wallpaper.

Cool Take note of the females who rearrange your silverware settings and make the napkins into swans while denouncing your oversight in that department. Lose their address before next year.

- Collapse -
Re:Re:Re:The Flippin' Bird!
Nov 26, 2003 10:12PM PST

I agree anyone who is less tha exstatic is not welcome back next year. After all, the important thing is the love and sharing . And probably the laughs that are creating future memories. So if it doesn't thaw and you have burgers on the grill. So what? You can see how cranberries taste with them.

- Collapse -
Talking of disastrous meals
Nov 27, 2003 8:22AM PST

the first meal I cooked for Susie - chilli con carne.

I'd been making it for years - packet chilli, tinned beans. Susie had made a bif deal about how3 she used only frech ingredients. Umm.

Bought a cook book, bought the ingrdiants. Only two problems
.. I never knew about chilli oil on fingers. I was blind by the time Sue arrived, in absolute agony with ibflamed running eyes.
... The writers of cook books assume too much knowledge. Cooking the beans without overnight soaking - well, they made great marbles.

ah well.

Ian

- Collapse -
Re:The Flippin' Bird!
Nov 26, 2003 9:25PM PST

Cleverly put Diane but in case you are serious in your quest for "quick thawing" I will offer what has worked for me in the past.

Remember, You MUST roast the bird to an internal temperature of ~140

- Collapse -
Re:Re:The Flippin' Bird!
Nov 26, 2003 10:11PM PST

Thank you, Edward! Happy I don't have a heating pad, but I do have the electically heat sealed bags I can stuff hot, moist towels into. That might just work. Thank goodness the family is not up yet. My sailing the turkey around the sink in fresh hot water, and quietly singing, "Yo ho! Yo ho! A pirate's life for me!" might have been taken the wrong way Wink It's not in the DSM IV TR though, so I figure I'm fine *twitch*

- Collapse -
(NT) Will "The Flippin' Bird!" fit in the microwave for thawing?
Nov 26, 2003 10:27PM PST

.

- Collapse -
Re:(NT) Will
Nov 26, 2003 10:44PM PST

I don't think it will rotate in there, but it is thawed enough at the moment, where I think I can try shoving it in and see. It should stick very nicely to the sweet potatoes that just leaked all over the turn-tray LOL

I figure if I can get it where I can pull the innards out without cutting my fingers on the ice, that's progress!

- Collapse -
I gave up on holiday cooking years ago ...
Nov 26, 2003 10:28PM PST

We're going out to eat. I refuse to cook for a group of people who won't eat this, don't like that, complain about the timing of the meal, ....

I'm a fairly good cook, but some of my tastes are a bit non-traditional, so I don't always prepare holiday dishes 'the way momma did'. From my perspective that makes things fun. It does not always work (some ideas are best not repeated) but it is interesting.

The last big holiday meal I prepared was a Christmas dinner a few years back. We invited my parents and my in-laws and ended up with a large (for us) group of about 9 people. People complained about my choices of wines, the appetizers and almost everything else. At the end of the meal my M-I-L was very deliberately feeding my dessert to one of the dogs (taking it off my plate piece by piece) while complaining about how she wouldn't eat that dessert unless she had fixed it herself.

We haven't invited them back for a holiday meal since then.

- Collapse -
Nt - Hilarious!
Nov 26, 2003 10:36PM PST

.

- Collapse -
NT - How rude :-( - don't blame you for quitting
Nov 27, 2003 7:22AM PST

...

- Collapse -
Re:The Flippin' Bird!
Nov 26, 2003 11:13PM PST

Wife telling me that same happened to friend of hers. She went ahead and put in oven to cook at the proper temp. After appropriate time took out and trimmed all the outer cooked meat and served on platter. Just didn't mention whole bird not cooked yet. Put rest of turkey back in oven to cook for leftovers.

She also says microwave is not that good in thawing poultry. It will heat the bones up and partially cook and dry out the meat.

About best according to her is what you are doing...warm water...changing when cooled.

- Collapse -
Thanks, all!!!! He is defrosted!!! :-)))
Nov 26, 2003 11:39PM PST

I'll split this into two messages since it won't post.

Edward has proven himself to be the real Renaissance Man around here with the engine idea. Now that the bird is thawed enough to stuff and throw in the oven, I may go for the drive MINUS the bird though - sounded like a great idea LOL!

Dr. Bill can appreciate this no doubt. Three years ago yesterday, my mother's car was stolen at my office after work. My mother had Alzheimers and was in a home - she somehow decided I allowed it to be stolen and was furious. She had volunteered me to cook Thanksgiving Dinner for her entire facility the next day, and the search for the car put us at the supermarket at midnight getting the last woebegotten and VERY frozen turkeys they had left, plus some equally questionable veggies.

The delay in thawing the darned birds set us back several hours in cooking and despite staying up all night, I was 2 1/2 hrs. late to my mother's care factility by then. At that point, she had regaled the workers and patients with every example she could recall or make up of my inept cooking and lack of wifely skills - in addition to my being an idiot to get her car stolen.

(continued)

- Collapse -
Re:Thanks, all!!!! He is defrosted!!! :-))) Pt II
Nov 26, 2003 11:43PM PST

Being mad at me as my mother was, and wanting to always make an example of how her cooking was better than mine, by the time I delivered the food, I was faced with the Alzheimers' version of a Saturday Night Live skit on how inept I was. Everything was found wanting and that which was not TOO bad my mother proclaimed I must have bought at the store (not true).

My husband finally removed me from there on some flimsy pretext when he saw my fingers reflexively clenching in anger. I decided after that that it is never a good idea to cook for a home with dementia patients, particularly they find insults good fun.

The ironic upshot of this all is that three years to the day, yesterday, I was coming back from court across the county, when I found what is almost certain to be her stolen car after all this time! I took photos and got the information and notified law enforcement. Even if the turkey turns out horrible today, I finally found the car, although Mom is no longer here to enjoy either. Fate is strange sometimes. Finding the car has made this day a day for giving thanks indeed!

- Collapse -
You must be one brave soul
Nov 26, 2003 11:55PM PST

I cannot imagine trying to cook for a facility full of alzheimer patients.

- Collapse -
Re:it could be worse........
Nov 27, 2003 12:17AM PST

imagine cooking for them and then forgetting where they were Happy)

- Collapse -
Way too late to help this time, but for next time
Nov 27, 2003 12:43AM PST

Local news has been reporting that you can cook a frozen bird directly (but how do you get the stuffing out?). They report that you just increase cooking time to 150% of recommended time for the size bird. However, you would definately want to use a meat thermometer to be sure inside was hot enough I'd think.

All ya'll have a good day. I'm off to work. (But today certainly pays well at least Wink).

roger

- Collapse -
Yup...
Nov 27, 2003 1:36PM PST

A few years ago, we had a bird that wasn't thawed by the time we wanted to start cooking. Hot water in sink was replaced quite a few times. Lifted the bird out of the sink and drained out water inside the bird as well as could be expected through a miniscule hole. Once the legs loosened up, hot water went inside the bird and that really sped up the thawing process. Only about an hour behind schedule. Happy

- Collapse -
Re:The Flippin' Bird!
Nov 27, 2003 2:06AM PST

Hi Diane,

Hope all turns out well with your bird. I always heard to defrost the bird in cold water--as long as it's above freezing it works as well as hot, as far as the bird is concerned. Also, hot water can introduce bacteria.

Thankfully, our focus on T-day is football, so I'll toss a pork loin in the oven when the game is over. Hey, last year I think I made sandwiches. Wink

Cindi

- Collapse -
Re:Re:The Flippin' Bird!
Nov 27, 2003 3:02AM PST

Thanks, Cindi! Happy The bird is still white as a sheet, but at least it's cooking now.

Last Thanksgiving my husband's family literally voted (I didn't have a vote) and they decided my husband and I were to host all family holidays at our house from then on out. This means between 17-35+ people over for Christmas for example. It's one thing that we got tagged with this, but then, to make themselves feel better, I guess, the female members of the family started this vicious lie that I loved cleaning and cooking for large crowds, and would be overjoyed to do this! Smoehow, it would have been better if they just said, "Hey, we're dumping on you and know you hate it, but we need to do this."

When you stop and consider that each one of the things I listed for Mary Kay as things that I've learned, have been actual experiences from past years, you get the idea that this may not be a good idea. Last year, my step-grandson pee'd like a mule on the carpet of the main staircase, causing my daughter to slip with the vacuum and fall down the stairs on her back. Then, he rounded it off by fingerpainting with his poop (his mom "exaggerated" that he was potty trained Sad ) all over the white walls of my staircase as I took the first group on a tour of the house.

He followed that act up by drinking unattended glasses of wine when the adults weren't watching, and then he proceeded to heave two separate times in the middle of the kitchen during dinner, spewing in circles like a scene from the Exorcist. Yes, I have so much to look forward to again this year, as we will no doubt set a different record in what can go wrong! Wink

- Collapse -
NT Lock that kid in the shed! LOL
Nov 27, 2003 6:10AM PST

.

- Collapse -
You let them get away with that?
Nov 27, 2003 7:19AM PST

Reminds me that I was usually asked to take the minutes of meetings because I was usually the only female there. Only happened once - I take terrible minutes. Wink