Some write about ease of use (or the don't bother me issue.) Some write about stateful packet inspection. For me it has to do with a clear view of "rules."
Without knowing what makes it the best for you I can only offer that you could survive with the upgraded firewall in Vista but I wouldn't put it past Microsoft to allow Alexa (a known spyware) to chat with mother.
Bob
Which is the best Firewall for Windows Vista ? Or Else should i stick with the built-in Windows Vista Firewall ?

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic