Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Sony XBR vs. Panasonic TH-42PHD8

by wbb56 Nov 20, 2005 2:56AM PST

Ok, after months and months of research, reading and fence-sitting the decision is down to two sets. One LCD (Sony XBR-KDL-V40XBR1) and one Plasma (Panasonic TH-42PHD8UK).

I have seen both the consumer version of the Pansonic and the industrial version all over town-virtually every restaurant and sports bar use it). I just saw the Sony in Best Buy two days ago.

I am impressed by both. I'm sure both will do the job. However, like everyone else, I'd like to purchase the one that will fit me needs the best.

The set will be in a very open living room/den. There is a lot of glass and pretty significant glare during the day--alhtough most of it can be handled by closing the blinds. It is an odd-sahped room..with some viewing positions within 4-6 feet and others 7-10 feet. I do have good sound system-Onkyo Amp, Aperion speaker set.

Currently using DirecTV (Non-HD) with TiVo. We get all of our programming through DirecTV, including local channels.

Our viewing habits are primarily network TV, sports, some per-per-view movies/HBO movies and probably watch a DVD movie once every other week.

When we purchase the TV we will be upgrading to DirecTV-HD--but not immediately.

So..the questions.. considering the room, equipment, viewing choices, etc.. which is best? (subjectively of course!) Is it absolutely necessary to upgrade to DirecTV-HD right away? Is and LCD screen better in a bright room--is the Sony worth the price difference?

Thanks very much in advance for helping me--finally make a decision..!

-William

Discussion is locked

2 Posts

- Collapse + Expand Details

- Collapse -

is the Sony worth the price difference

by jcrobso Nov 28, 2005 6:01AM PST

No one can make that descison for you.
Both are top of thier respetive class. Both will do a good job in high ambient light.
However you will have to replace the lamp in the Sony from time to time. John

- Collapse -

I was wondering about that.

by mrobzo Nov 28, 2005 6:14AM PST

When I first got my sony, it had a great picture. As time went on it has gotton progressivly worse to the point that I would rather watch a none digital TV My Panasonic, which is a regular TV, gets a much better picture than my Sony 720p and 1080i. Do I have to replace the light? Maybe I should have gone with Panasonic. Too late to go back now.

Back to TVs & Home Theaters forum