Happy
or
Sad
or
Grin
Love
Mischief
Cool
Devil
Silly
Angry
Laugh :^O
Wink
or
Blush
Cry
Confused
Shocked
Plain ![]()
Looks like Laugh needs to have a zero instead of a capital 'O', too.
The character sequence for the "Shocked" emoticon in the table of emoticons has the colon followed by a capital letter 'O'. It doesn't work in the forums. A colon followed by a zero '0' does work.
(upper O)
:o (lower o)
(zero)

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic