Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Sling Box

Dec 9, 2005 10:44PM PST

ok, here is a scenario because I love Hockey ( I guess it is a Canadian thing ) and I am now living in Ireland.

If I was to get one of these boxes, could I hook this up in say, my parents place to grab the games, could I stream these over to Ireland to watch? Is this a recorder like this Tivo thing I hear so much about, or it is real time?

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Real time unless combines with a PVR (Like Tivo)
Dec 9, 2005 11:19PM PST

A lot of this is explained on their website...

You feed it a signal (Coax, s-video, or rca), and it then allows you to see that signal. If you wanted LIVE only, you could set it up with your cable input, and then put the IR emitter (allows slingbox to change channels on something that access IR, i.e. has a remote) on your cable box, your tv, or (here is the cool part) your PVR.

So, if you say, put together a Tivo or a MythTV box (open source, knoppmyth is your friend) and had slingbox connected as the output of the PVR (personal video recorded), and the IR Emitter setup on the PVR, then you could control from Ireland either LiveTV or recorded programs through the PVR.
If you set this up in a closet, feeding your cable-in and Network cables to the location, you could piggy back this off of your parents signal without changing anything about thier setup. Neat huh?

You can get even fancier if you wanted to, but that requires knowing specifically what hardware you are using. IMO, if it was a KnoppMyth created MythTV PVR, I'd setup their router so I could get access to the web interface and PuttY of the DVR, just in case it locks up and you need command line access to restart it. THe web interface would allow you to program it without loading the slingbox (KISS, Keep it Simple Stupid).

Ok, enough typing. Happy

- Collapse -
Work Cut out
Dec 9, 2005 11:25PM PST

Thanks for the feedback. Looks like I have my work cut out. I think I will follow your suggestions on this one. I guess what I will have to do is build it here first and the ship it to canada and then get a tech buddy to go over to my parents place to set it up. i like the idea of being able to telnet to it and control it remote. Stupid question though, could a SSL be used??

- Collapse -
SSL
Dec 11, 2005 12:49PM PST

Not sure. mind you, the easy route is a Tivo. I just prefer MythTV (installed using KnoppMyth) because it has no monthly fee, and I was able to get one together for <$200. I would suggest digging around the knoppmyth forums for SSL and other questions. just google knoppmyth.

- Collapse -
Real Time
Dec 9, 2005 11:22PM PST

It's real time. It takes an input from a video source, converts it to a stream, and allows the client (Windows only) to view the stream. One thing to keep in mind is that this thing has no tuner, so your parents would have to be watching the game for you to watch it (or at least have a TV tuned to the game and have the slingbox connected to that).

You can simulate "on-demand" by hooking the slingbox to something like a Tivo. With the IR blaster on the slingbox you can control the Tivo (or a TV for that matter) remotely. At least that's how I understand it.

- Collapse -
Bandwidth issues?
Dec 12, 2005 12:53AM PST

I see how you could do this, but I'm curious about how well this works in reality over the internet. Most cable/DSL connections only have 128-256 Kbps upstream. Will that be enough for streaming a TV signal? And the hops from Canada to Ireland would be sort of interesting, too, as all the packets have to end up on time and in order.

Does anybody in Canada put any of the games up on bittorrent? If so, that would be the easiest way out. And, btw, the broadcasters would probably say that you are infringing on their "content creator rights" by using the slingbox anyway.

- Collapse -
www.mobilephones-info.com/SlingBox.htm
Dec 20, 2005 8:27PM PST