Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Signal problem! I just bought Straight Talk... Help!

Oct 23, 2009 2:24PM PDT

Hi I hope I didn't shoot my self in the foot going cheap, but I just bought Straight Talk from Walmart and all it will show is I'm on Roam. So I'm out of service at home. I got to get back to my old Boost plan if this don't work.

I guess the question I want to know. Who provides the service in my area? I know Sprint only gets 1 or no bars around my home "I had one and my friends has the same issues here", and my friend that has Verizon gets about 2 and sometimes 3 bars? I'm seeing 4 full bars on my Samsung R451C. Anyone know who's signal I'm seeing on Roam? To my knowledge we only have Verizon and Sprint as the CDMA carriers in my area for sale.

Thank you for your help.

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Straight Talk??
Aug 17, 2010 3:47PM PDT

Being able to speak English is NOT the same as being able to converse in English. I spent and hour and twenty minutes with two reps from Straight Talk ("Bob" and "Maria" direct from Thiruvananthapuram this morning after buying and supposedly activating my new phone. Verizon has cut me off and Straight Talk says I don't have an account.

Finally "Maria", after putting me on hold for the 12th time and speaking with her supervisor or "the other department" said it would be up to 7 days before my service was activated.

I have no phone service. My wife is on the road alone in a monsoon rain storm on a 1,000 mile trip to visit family and I can't get in touch with her or her with me!!!! I had to go to a 24 hour drug store and buy a pre-paid Virgin Mobile phone and card just to talk with her. I--AM--PISSED!!! This had better be resolved soon and in an acceptable way and I had better get better service in the future or I am going to go postal on these guys. !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

- Collapse -
Thanks For Helping Me Make A Decision
Sep 18, 2010 11:09AM PDT

After reading all these reviews it gives me pause for thought.

A friend told me about Straight Talk and said they used the Verizon wires.
..but I wonder if there are tiers like mentioned earlier in this thread.

The phone selection looks limited. I just bought a new GSM Nokia A-177.
Not a bad cheap phone if you don't count that stinkin' camera.

I was listening to Leo Laporte the other day and he was talking up Google Voice which I have had for a couple years. I had the old Grand Central setup so we got to use it early.

That customer support sounds like a nightmare. I never knew that they all had American names.**snicker**. Also, the scripts these people read over and over again, NO MATTER WHAT YOU ASK THEM it's the same thing over and over again.

I have told CS reps before to QUIT APOLOGIZING every other sentence and let's get to work. So what do they do, APOLOGIZE again..
If their support is like this, and it sounds like it is, I'll pass.

- Collapse -
My Straight Talk Experience
Jan 11, 2011 10:24PM PST

I bought a Samsung 451C through Walmart a couple of months ago, and have been quite pleased with it. I do, however, live in a large metropolitan area ... with 4 bars almost all of the time.

In contrast to the above I do have one major complaint - SERVICE. I cannot get a knowledgeable English speaking support tech. I agree 100% with your statement "Being able to speak English is NOT the same as being able to converse in English." I simply cannnot understand their accents. However, I have the same problem with other company tech support techs.

For every question I ask they have to go offline and read the book before coming back with any response. Their response seems to indicate they don't know the phone.

Example : The 451c apparently has no key to do a carriage return or line feed. I want to txt "Hello Mr. Doe;" ... then do a line feed to start a new line ... without doing a bunch of "spaces". No one at their tech support has been able to tell me how to do this ... or even understand what I am talking about.

Other than this I am quite pleased with my Straight Talk phone.

Geezer235711

- Collapse -
Same here
Jan 12, 2011 11:21AM PST

I also purchased a Straight Talk Samsung R355c and with no problem. I am saving since I was expending almost $90 a month for talk, text and minutes overage, that was extra and received a bill for $300 for going over minutes during the holidays. I am pleased with the savings, with the phone and with the overall experience I have had with my Straight Talk. Good luck to the persons that are having all those problems.

- Collapse -
Straight Talk Signal
Sep 27, 2010 1:32AM PDT

Wow! I'm surprised at some of these comments. I've been so happy with my Straight Talk phones. No problems whatsoever? Hope you manage to sort it all out. I've saved a bunch of money already.

- Collapse -
straight talk is junk!
Nov 19, 2010 1:13PM PST

applachian wireless is the best, we need to do something about getting our money back from straight talk junk phones.

- Collapse -
Question Samsung 451C
Nov 22, 2010 12:26AM PST

I just signed on with Straight talk using the Samsung 451C, and have been very pleased with it. I do have one question ... how do I do a "carriage return/line feed" when entering txt?

- Collapse -
Straight Talk Prepaid Cell Phone Review
Dec 14, 2010 5:35AM PST

I am encouraging everyone to not do business with Straight Talk. Yesterday, December 13, 2010, Straight Talk changed my phone number without warning and without notification. The only idea I had that something was wrong was that I had no service all day. Then we called customer service last night and reestablished my service.

It wasn't until today, after my wife tried to call me but instead got someone else did we figure out on our own that my number the Straight Talk rep had changed my number without telling us. We called Straight Talk customer service once again, trying to resolve the problem for good. At first, we couldn't even get through to them. We got a message stating "Due to High Call Volume, we cannot take your call now. Try again later."

When we finally got through later, Straight Talk's outsourced customer service reps refused to make the problem they had caused right again. Instead, the hard-to-understand Indian CSRs, with their shrill Indian accents repeatedly recited in broken English their simple, scripted versions of how they were powerless to help us any further.

For both reliability and for safety reasons, my wife and I are discontinuing our Straight Talk service in favor of a reliable provider. I am on disability - my telephone is sometimes my only contact with the outside world. In a medical emergency, I need to be able to contact someone who might help.

Straight Talk is not a reliable provider of cell phone service. You get what you pay for and if you make the same mistake we did in dealing with Straight Talk you will need to call customer service. You will also find out - like we did - that Straight Talk increases its profits by outsourcing its customer service. Your money is better spent instead on a reliable service provider with good customer service who won't make such stupid mistakes in the first place and who will help you when you need it.

- Collapse -
No straight talk from straightalk
Jan 6, 2011 11:13AM PST

I Thought straight talk was an amazing deal and very affordable. I purchard my prepaid card and phone online. I recieved it a week later. When I tried to activate this phone and port my verizon number to straight talk, my verizon phone was disconnected within one hour. However I could never get my straight talk phone activated, even after spending hours with CSR"s in india, speaking only broken english and scripted apologies. After more than ten hours of speaking with CSR's I was informed that my phone was no good and they would be sending me out a new phone. I have since spend five hours trying to find out where my new phone is, more than a week later. Called verizon and had my old phone re-activated and number re-ported within 5 minutes. Re contacted straight to tell them that i was no longer interested in their service and to refund all charges back to my account. They have refused to give me a refund. I told the indian that we call that FRAUD in the United States. Still trying to figure out how I am going to get my money back. DOES ANYONE WANT TO BUY A STRAIGHT TALK PHOME?????.
YOU GET WHAT YOU PAY FOR, WHICH FOR ME WAS NOTHING.
KEEP OUR JOBS IN THE UNITED STATES

- Collapse -
You didn't do your research
Jan 7, 2011 12:22AM PST

While I sympathize with your dilemma, you didn't do your research before the whole process began.

It's never a good idea to actually port the old number until you have already set up the new service and have ascertained that it works sufficiently for your needs. In some cases this may require a few weeks (or longer) if you do not have time to properly evaluate the new service/hardware/features/etc. Once it's working properly, *then* you make the call to port over your old number.

Regarding your comments on keeping jobs in the U.S., this complaint is getting old. Which would you prefer, the opportuntity for your small business to stay afloat, or some draconians measure by right wing nut jobs to force companies to *always* use American labor(?) It's just not realistic since there's no such thing as a one-size fits all unfortunately. The global economy is here to stay.

Keep in mind that certain jobs will simply not be present in the U.S. again in the same numbers (if at all) as they did during our parents and grandparents generations. You can use the shipbuilding industry as an example from this century. The large vessels that used to be made in the U.S. are now (mostly) made in China/Korea, closer to where the labor costs are lower and manchurian/australian iron ore is plentiful. Perhaps someday they will be produced in Africa when some of those economies advance as well. The truth is much of this is a natural progression, economically. There have been suggestions that our progression to more of a service based economy is necessarily a bad thing, which is incorrect. In fact, economies often progress to a point where you become exporters of (much more expensive) advanced goods and services such as consulting work for large multi-nationals, along with computer software/services and networking technologies. These are high value services that actually do create additional jobs back home. The real problem is how we have few built-in ways on a national scale to properly adjust and deal w/ employment re-training, along with providing affordable health care for all. Some have suggested that our economic job prospects could be improved by reforming our higher education system. Instead of forcing young adults to go the academic route of 4 year higher education they could enter a codified tradesman/apprenticeship type program of varying length depending on the industry they happened to choose. To create a path for skilled workers that we require in today's economy mind you, instead of a whole raft of unemployed poetry majors working as waiters or cab drivers Wink.

- Collapse -
Coverage
Jan 17, 2011 5:46AM PST

Straight Talk's coverage is massive so I'm not sure why you'd only get roaming in your house. Boost is pretty good too but it's actually not as cheap as Straight Talk and it also has less nationwide coverage. What's pretty convenient is that Straight Talk has BOTH CDMA and GSM coverage (two of the best networks out there) so it's strange that you're seeing roam on your phone. Walmart is actually really good with returns so if your problem persists, i'm sure they'd let you return the phone.

- Collapse -
You have been misled
Jan 17, 2011 8:43AM PST

Straight Talk handsets are either CDMA *or* GSM, so you only get one 'footprint' at a time. It truly depends where you are trying to use the phone, and which 'flavor' of Straight Talk is being used/marketed in your specific area. Verizon & ATT *do not* cover 100% of the U.S., FWIW.

- Collapse -
when roaming with st dont forget
Jan 18, 2011 7:05AM PST

If roaming bothers you, just remember. its 50 bux a month. no matter how much you roam. its mainly verizon towers. i heard they may do att towers. i think those phones might would take a sim card. i think verizon is a stronger network than att personally, but to each his own. ive had st for a year or so, had the problems with the teck support, number swaps on accident, all that good stuff. it sux when i have problems, but only needing one phone it works fine overall. sorry for those who had really bad experiences. you cant teach a dumb dog a good trick, but that dont mean the trick aint good. there are family plans with some providers that are cheaper than straighttalk. but I think hands down, straighttalk is the best plan out there for the single adult with a life. Yes, they have a crappy selection of phones, but they do have decent phones for good prices, and god phones for decent prices. Good luck!!! Happy

p.s. shortly after i bought my first st phone they shut me off. it took over 4 hours talking to them to find out that they shun the use of the the phones built in modem to get online with my desktop and stream hours of video. :-D so i had to stop the indulgence of mega web browsing. but all in all im happy with it.

- Collapse -
Did you *really* think that...
Jan 19, 2011 12:34AM PST

...the el cheapo ST service would permit tethering? (ROTFL)

I highly recommend Page Plus Wireless if you can't afford post-paid but want/need more of the bells/whistles. It would allow you to bring in many of the Verizon branded handsets (even some wifi enabled smartphones) without such limitations of ST.

- Collapse -
Straight Talk has been great for me
Jan 25, 2011 3:35AM PST

Not the fanciest phones but obv that's the tradeoff for only paying 45 bucks a month to use a smartphone in an unlimited fashion. Thought that I was going to have to get rid of my unlimited plan when I got in to grad school but just got straight talk instead.

- Collapse -
CDMA vs GSM
Jan 25, 2011 5:21AM PST

Straight Talk uses both dominate networks for cellphone coverage. I switched from T-Mobile's GSM network where my reception inside buildings was superior but not so much in rural areas. I have the Samsung R451C phone where the "C" stands for CDMA as opposed to T-Mobile's GSM network. Straight Talk gives you the option to use either network depending upon the phone in which you choose to pick. I now get better long distance range with my CDMA phone, yet my signal within buildings is often too weak to hold it for long. If you are having problems within your home with Straight Talk, I would recommend that you purchase a GSM phone instead of a CDMA phone. For example, Sraight Talk also gives me the option to purchase the Samsung T401G where the "G" stand for "GSM." I would imagine that the T401G would naturally work better within a building since it is on the GSM network. Hope that helps.

- Collapse -
You are making some assumptions
Jan 25, 2011 11:09PM PST

First, keep in mind that the frequency used by a carrier at a specific location may differ depending on where a person using the service lives, etc. Also, it's hard to generalize from your specific situation that some one else would also get good indoor service simply by choosing GSM technology. For example, in some areas Verizon (a CDMA/EVDO carrier) does better at building penetration, and that can also be true even if they are using the 1900MHz frequency band instead of 850MHz. It depends a lot on the individual structure at a specific location as well as the buildout of the network at a specific place. In this sense a carrier using 850 over 1900 at one specific site might not necessarily be the one to choose. There are some variables involved that makes coverage, especially indoor, somewhat a function of trial and error. Straight Talk is certainly no exception.

- Collapse -
Pone
Jan 26, 2011 3:55AM PST

I have great service around my area with the straight talk. Find out if your straight talk is CDMA (Verizon) or GSM (AT&T). Then you can figure out which service is right for you because different phones use different service towers.

- Collapse -
Beware of Straight Talk
Mar 2, 2011 1:58AM PST

I purchase the Straight Talk service in December, what started out as good ended with no acess to the internet services with my renewal plan(Unlimited) for several days, I called customer services only to find that their people can not resolve this problem. Customer service rep. suggested a new phone which he said would be no expensive to me, I received the Fed Ex package today 03/02/2011, when I open the package it was empty but the instruction sheet stated I have to send the defective phone to them before I can received the replacement phone, customer services rep did not discuss this with me during our conversation.I spoke with a female who indentify hersef as a manager, she stated that the instruction was true, no replacement phone can be received until defective one is received, but no one knows if this is the problem or not, if the phone is the problem I can go purchase on if not them the problem of not having access to the internet still stand,in the time frame my phone is on its way to who know where or how long it will take to receive a replacement, it's nothing straight talk can do.Plese be aware of Straight Talk services before purchase,they will not help their customers when there product goes bad.

- Collapse -
Straight Talk been Great
Mar 31, 2011 9:51AM PDT

No way do you want to pick Boost over Straight Talk, Boost is only carried on the sprint network and Straight Talk is on ATT, Verizon, and now T-Mobile too (because ATT bought them.) So there's no real advantage to the boost coverage.

- Collapse -
Corrections
Apr 1, 2011 3:26AM PDT

The FCC has not yet approved the ATT buyout of T-Mobile.

Also, simply because Straight Talk uses ATT, Verizon or T-Mobile (mind you, never all three at once), doesn't necessarily imply that their service would be superior to Boost at a specific location. That will most certainly vary.

- Collapse -
good singal booster
Apr 1, 2011 3:01AM PDT

I have look at your question about the cellphone signal is too weak.so I suggest you buy the signal booster from ebay.you can look for cellphone booster.

- Collapse -
helpinghandscomputerservice
Apr 20, 2011 2:55AM PDT

straight talk phones is on verizon network i does good for me you may have to call straight maybe the people can help you out at straight good luck to you.