HDMI ARC is like that. Hit and miss. Try other connections and setups. If you feel it's defective, pack and return. The industry is not doing well with ARC.
I have a brand new LG SH5 soundbar and a Sony kdl-32w706bsu tv. Yesterday I unpacked the soundbar, plugged it in and connected to my TV using a new HDMI 2.0 cable. I selected the "audio system" sound option in my TV instead of the TV speakers and the soundbar worked perfectly. We watched TV for a while with the soundbar working well. However, when we came to watch TV again later I turned the TV on but there was no sound coming from the soundbar. I noticed that it had turned itself to OPT instead of HDMI when it had been turned on by the TV. I turned it to HDMI but when I turned the TV back to audio system the bar instantly defaulted to OPT. After ~10mins of fiddling I got the sound to work. This morning, the same thing happened, on power up the bar was set to OPT and not HDMI, but now I can't get it to work at all.

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic