Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

- Collapse -
Answer
Not the first time or the only place.
Oct 9, 2015 7:24PM PDT
Montreal sewage dumping controversy deepens

Coderre has the backing of the Quebec government, and is accusing the federal Conservative government of “playing politics” with the issue to gain votes on the eve of the federal election. On Wednesday, TVA reported the city of Longueuil flushed 150 million litres of sewage water into the river last March as part of construction work, with the federal government’s consent. The Victoria and Esquimault regions of British Columbia dump 130 million litres of raw sewage a day into the Juan de Fuca Strait, CBC News reported, and municipalities like Montreal and Toronto regularly spill sewage water into their nearby rivers and lakes when heavy rains overflow their sewage systems.

The most recent, and severe, criticism of the proposed dumping, came from south of the border.


opposing side says

Sarah Dorner, associate professor of civil, geological and mining engineering and the Canada Research Chair in source water protection, told CBC Montreal's Daybreak that the city has no choice but to divert the wastewater into the river.

"There really is no other engineering or technical solution to this," Dorner said.

Dorner said the interceptor that's being closed is a massive and expensive piece of infrastructure that took years to build.

'This is more than 30 kilometres long, up to five metres wide. There's a reason it took so long to build this. You can't just build that overnight.'
- Sarah Dorner, Canada Research Chair in source water protection

She said schemes to replace or bypass it temporarily are impractical
- Collapse -
(NT) Reminds me of WV
Oct 9, 2015 8:40PM PDT
- Collapse -
Answer
what they need is....
Oct 9, 2015 10:44PM PDT

....plenty of forested area where such sewage is pumped so it can nourish the forest industry instead.

- Collapse -
Sounds reasonable though maybe impractical
Oct 10, 2015 3:20AM PDT

What I'd want to know is the composition of the "raw" sewage. If it's primarily biological waste from residential areas, it's one thing. If it's industrial and chemical waste, that's another. We need to consider that biological waste is a product nature recycles into useful material to replenish and not something that would better if jettisoned into outer space. Of course humans have created their own chemical contaminants in the form of medicines that have, heretofore, not been excreted into the bio-system. If that's a problem with the waste water, we can certainly opt for other solutions. Stop gorping down all those hormones and mood altering dopes. Wink