Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Review: iPod Nano

Dec 4, 2005 8:21AM PST

Ok, it's been two weeks since i got my nano in the mail(3 days from ShenZhen China, FedEx you rock!), and I'm finally over the "OMG IT'S SO AWESOME AND SLEEK" period. So, instead of working on my english paper, i've decided to write this review. Keep in mind that these are just my opinions. Feel free to ask any questions or give your views, as long as you don't say stuff like "IPOD SUX, i ROX". There's no need to get angry, ipods never did anything to hurt you Wink

First: Pros and Cons
Pro: size, looks, clickwheel, iTunes software

Cons: battery, volume control(i'll get into that later)

Looks: I have come to the conclusion that the ipod nano is a great device device. It's well made and the box it comes in is top notch. Apple really makes you feel like you bought a quality product. About all those rumors that the nano is fragile, they're just rumors. From day one, i just kept the protective screen that was on the front on. I have yet to see a scratch anywhere, even tho i keep it in my jeans pocket all the time. It is quite easy to get fingerprints on the back, but that's only because it has such a shiny metalic finish, besides, just breath on it a little and wipe it off with your shirt. the glossy front looks amazing btw.

Size: The first thing that i thought when i took it out of the box was that something went wrong... there was no way that my nano could be so small! But it is, you really have to see it. It's roughly the size of a credit card after you cut off a third of it's width. When i carry it in the little inner pocket of my jeans, i'm so paranoid when i go out to see a movie or something. I'm always afraid i've lost it since i can't feel it when its in there.

Control: OK, the click wheel on the nano is a bit too sensitive on the nano as compared to my friends' 3Gs'. But it's fine for me since i have small hands. That should be apple's new marketing campaign: Impossible for people with big hands. Just kidding... but not really... Anywhoo, the one gripe i have with it is that when i'm in the car driving with my knees, it's very hard to control the volume to a degree and make it stay there, but then again, i'm very precise with this.

Audio: The audio quality for this player is great, the bass is much lower and the treble is much clearer than the ipod 4G. I've listend to other players like Zen Micro and Sony's walkmans and i honestly can't tell the difference. Ok, maybe the other guys sound just a little bit better when you put the kps up all the way to 320, but for the average listener(and i consider myself average), there's not really a difference. But, if you're an audiophlie who has like $300 ear-muff headphones then don't buy an ipod, i guess.

Photo: The photos are very sharp when you put them on the nano. There are fewer colors as compared to a computer, but it's not that big of a deal. There is one awesome thing about the photo viewing i'd like to note. It's called ipod scrubbing, wat you basically do is you take a movie clip and you use any movie player to export the clip frame by frame into pictures. Then you put the pictures onto your ipod and you can view the clip by scrolling with the click wheel.

Software: iTunes is hands down the best software for DAPs. The nano syncs seamlessly with iTunes and automatically transfers individual settings you have put on each song such as volume, album art, and start/stop times. It's really easy and personalized. Also, it lets you convert songs to AAC format which takes up the same space as 128 kps MP3, but has the quality of 192, therefore cutting your music collection's space by a third.

Battery: Ok, this is only other gripe i have about the nano. It does last 14 hours, but if you want to have the backlight on and/or view photos, then you cut that time in half. The time is enough for me, but it may not be enough for audiophiles. Oh, and it takes 1.5 hrs to charge to 80%. This is a decent rate, but after seeing my friend's Sony NW-E407 do a 3hr charge in 3 min, i'm a little jealous. but not really...

Space: the amount of space is fine for me, i have about 600 songs on it plus like a millions pictures, and there's still 1.5 gb left.

Extra Features: The nano has a lot of extra features like a time display at the top of the screen that displays while you listen. Also, the games are pretty neat and nice looking. Now i kno that fans of the Zen Micro and such have expressed hostility in that the nano doesn't have an FM Tuner and a Voice Recorder. I personally have never had a need for these features. First of all, i don't listen to the radio now that i have an ipod, plus even if i did, all the radio stations here are crap. And, i never really understood why anyone would need a voice recorder. Is it to leave yourself messages? o_0 Of course these are solely my opinions and there are certainly people who can put these features to good use. I would advise them to not buy an ipod or pay extra money to buy the accesories.

All in all, the ipod nano is a solid mp3 player with the support of iTunes. it may be pricey for some, but if you have the money or in my case, parents, then it's a solid buy.

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
nice review
Dec 4, 2005 8:57AM PST

that's a good review yangman... it was really un-biased. Wink

no, but really sounds like your happy with what you have, and that's whats most important. I still don't think i'll buy one, but that's me.

so anyway, just one question... are you like sooooo popular now?? haha, kidding. we've had our jokes...

- Collapse -
haha, thanks
Dec 4, 2005 9:02AM PST

well, i'm trying to be helpful for once Wink
btw, all the ladies love my nano. Just kidding, but not really. Haha, 10 pts to whoever knows wat movie that's from.

- Collapse -
DODGEBALL
Dec 4, 2005 9:47AM PST

Anybody who's anybody knows that! Just kidding, but not really.

- Collapse -
Touchet
Dec 4, 2005 9:52AM PST

I'd like to introduce you to the Globogym Purple Cobras: Blade, Lazer,... Blazer, Michelle, and of course Fran Igobavinana. Her nuclear powerplant team has won the Rovania championships 5 years running which makes her the deadliest woman alive... with a dodgeball.

- Collapse -
Actually...
Dec 4, 2005 10:27AM PST

This is the correct version:

I dropped by to congratulate you
on your victory by disqualification



and introduce you to the team that
will win the Las Vegas Dodgeball Open.



My team.



Allow me the pleasure of introducing you to



Blade.



Laser.



Blazer.



I've believe you've met
my fitness consigliere, Me'Shell.



- We met.
- And I almost forgot our last player.



Meet Fran Stalinofskivitchdavitovichski.



In her home country of Romanovia,
dodgeball is the national sport.



Her nuclear power plant's team won
the championship five years running,



which makes her the deadliest woman
on earth with a dodgeball.

- Collapse -
(NT) (NT) haha, you totally just got that off of imdb
Dec 4, 2005 10:36AM PST
- Collapse -
LOL I confess...
Dec 4, 2005 11:51AM PST

I got it off another site, it was IMDB though.

- Collapse -
(NT) (NT) I meant to say WASN'T from IMDB
Dec 4, 2005 12:15PM PST
- Collapse -
I agree; nice review
Dec 4, 2005 11:38PM PST

In-depth, well-written, and generally unbiased. Good job.

I still think an FM tuner is an important feature in a flash player, but that's just me. Also, I think there are enough complaints to say the scratching problem is not just a rumor. Judging by how the one at my local Best Buy looked after just a couple days, even keeping it in a case all the time wouldn't totally protect it.

I do think the Nano is pretty well-priced, though--or at least, the 2 GB one. I would rather just pay $50 more and get 26 more gigs and video playback instead of the 4 gig Nano, but you can find the 2GB for around $190, which is a pretty good price compared to 1GB players that cost $150. Plus, the Nano IS very small, and I guess some would rather have a color screen than an FM tuner