I decline to dive into why. But you will see this even in the same make camcorders...
Bob
Hi
I have a problem with viewing miniDVs recorded sometimes back with Sony camcorder.
Now I changed to a brand new Panasonic camcorder. I am able to use and record over those old DVs and play it but the old stuff which was recorded with Sony doenst play (on the same DV) . I get an error says " Unplayable Tap (other format)."
So I have two recordings on the same tap. 10minutes recorded with Sony and next 10minuts with Panasonic. I can watch what was recorded with Panasonic but It is not playing the recording by Sony (It displays the above error)
Is there something which prevents viewing the recording on different branded camcorders ?
Please let me know your views and questions.

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic