Firstly when you clicked export and you had the option to choose the accounts to export did you use the shift key to select every folder inside th account? e.g. Inbox, Sent, etc.?
Another alternative is to simply select all the messages in the first account and simply drag them into the other account.
I just installed Windows Live Mail for two different users on my computer with the XP operating system. Am trying to move some of the e-mails from user 1 account to user 2 account.
From the user 1 account, I used the Export command to move the e-mails folder in the Windows Live Mail format to a specified folder (after I did this, the folder showed various files, corresponding to the various e-mail messages).
Then from the Windows Live Mail in user account 2, I used the Import command to import the e-mail messages (in the Windows Live Mail format) from the same folder. Looked like everything was working fine because a message on the screen showed each of the various e-mail messages being copied one by one. At the end, got a message saying that the Import of the messages was successful.
However, the messages never appeared in the Windows Live Mail in user account 2. It shows a new Imported Folder (generic name, not the actual name of the folder), but there are no messages in it.
What do I do differently to make the e-mail messages do actually get transferred?

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic