Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

PC or laptop?

Jun 19, 2007 4:05PM PDT

My computer is dying. I can't decide whether to get another PC or a laptop. I was leaning towards laptop but just read that they don't have a very long life. Is this true? Do they last as long as PCs? Any other pros or cons of each would be appreciated. Thanks.

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Re: PC or laptop
Jun 19, 2007 5:09PM PDT

Laptops
- are more expensive to buy
- are more expensive to repair
- are less configurable
- generally only have basic video
- generally have smaller hard disks
AND
- personally I strongly prefer a real keyboard above a laptop one
BUT
- you can take them with you!

Kees

- Collapse -
re: PC or laptop
Jun 19, 2007 11:09PM PDT

as a counterpoint, a laptop:

is compact and takes up less room than a desktop
is typically quieter and consumes less power
can be cheaper than a desktop if the monitor is factored in

the cheapest intel dual core at circuit city is $500 after rebate and has 1gb of ram, basic video, dvd burner, and 250gb hard drive. the cheapest dual core laptop is $650 after rebate and has 1gb of ram, basic video, dvd burner, and 120gb hard drive. but the laptop's core duo cpu is a bit faster than the desktop's pentium-d and the monitor is included.

add a usb hub for your keyboard, printer, external drive, etc. and a laptop can match the typical user's desktop.

on the downside, laptop's aren't that great for gaming. as for repairs, an extended warranty can cover all types of repairs including those caused by drops and spills for about the same money as an extended desktop warranty.

- Collapse -
Decide by your needs
Jun 19, 2007 10:46PM PDT

If you truly need one or decide one is better than the other because of your needs, then get it. After all, you're one going to be using it and paying for it. You may like the mobility of the laptop but find some items lacking, while the lacking part is easily supplanted by a desktop but not mobile. However, pricing on laptops has never been better but if you applications or s/w needs truly are intensive, go with the desktop, IMHO. Overall a laptop is an expensive beast to feed and desktops are your favorite pet more easily tamed.

tada -----Willy Happy

- Collapse -
Laptop vs. desktop
Jun 20, 2007 2:34AM PDT

That is a difficult decision. I have a laptop and two desktops, and would hate to give up any of them, as they each have their unique advantages ? as well as their disadvantages,

The main advantage of a laptop is, of course, its portability.

Although I am retired and have no need for one on business trips, a laptop is still convenient for downloading and viewing digital pictures when on pleasure trips. The Web can be accessed and e-mail handled without hunting out an Internet caf

- Collapse -
To all who answered my post
Jun 20, 2007 7:48AM PDT

Thank you all so much!!! This is such fantastic information. It really helps me to make the right decision for me. I really wish I could get both a laptop and a desktop but for now I will have to choose but at least I will do so with the background information I need. This is such a great site!

Thanks again.

K

- Collapse -
(NT) You're welcome
Jun 20, 2007 8:27AM PDT
- Collapse -
Laptop Keyboards
Jun 21, 2007 10:35AM PDT

I'd just like to reply that even though at first laptop keyboards can throw you with their different shape and size, you can just as easily get completely used to a laptop keyboard. I, for one, find myself slipping up on regular desktop sized keyboards because I'm so well adjusted to my Inspiron 9300s keyboard size.

- Collapse -
Laptop Keyboards
Jun 22, 2007 7:25AM PDT

Good to know since I'm leaning towards a laptop. Thank you!

- Collapse -
It may be the "old dog" syndrome
Jun 22, 2007 6:25PM PDT

(and yes, I am an old dog Sad ), but despite rather heavy use of my Inspiron the last two or three years, I still make more typos than I like. Although the key spacing is the same, the shape of the Inspiron keys seems to reduces the effective inter-key gap, and I get too many double strikes.

First for me was the typewriter (and mechanical calculator); in the sixties were the 029 keypunch and Teletype console/terminal; in the late seventies came the VT100 terminal (WOW! video and 9600 bps rather than 110); the eighties brought the IBM-PC style keyboard, which is still common for desktops. Those adaptions were rather easy -- but those keyboards were quite similar, and I was younger. Use of keyboards such as those must be deeply ingrained in my motor responses, and adaption is now harder. Even worse than the laptop keyboard is, for me, the Microsoft angled, "ergomatic" keyboard.

Critz is no doubt right, and adaption is easy for many -- and especially for young dogs (from my point of reference anymore, anyone under about 35 is a pup, and anyone under 65 is a young dog Wink ). And, as I indicated in my original post, despite this little problem I probably would get a laptop if it were to be my only system.

Frank

- Collapse -
It may be the "old dog" syndrome
Jun 23, 2007 7:49AM PDT

I have decided to get a laptop and the keyboard is probably the thing that worries me the most. I'm not a young pup either. I hope I can adjust. I've tried the ergonomic keyboard and hated it beyond description. Can't imagine anyone getting used to that. Anyway, thanks again for your input.