Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Older software - Windows 7 compatibility?

Jan 4, 2010 5:43AM PST

I am in the market for a new desktop.
My present system still works okay, but is dated. Its operating system is Windows XP Professional.
I am not a computer beginner, and I can use the various programs installed in my computer, reasonably well, but my computer knowledge and skills are admittedly, limited.
The new Windows 7 is a source of concern and confusion, for me, as I want to keep using several software programs, that while several years old; suit my needs just fine, and I feel comfortable using them.
I have heard that many older software programs cannot be used with Windows 7, and replacing those programs that I?d like to retain, with newer ones; could be rather expensive, I suspect.
I am speaking of older versions of programs of Adobe Photoshop, Auto Cad, CorelDraw, etc.
.
As I understand it; if Windows 7 Professional is installed in a new computer; older programs installed and used with Windows XP can installed and used in something called ?XP mode?. Is this correct? If so, is it an easy process, or one that only those with rather high computer skills can accomplish?

After the Windows Vista fiasco; I can?t help but wonder if it might be best to just hold off on buying a new system until Windows 7 has been in use awhile, and any new system flaws have been corrected.

Any help that can be offered would be genuinely appreciated.
Thanks in advance,
Bob W

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
compatibility
Jan 4, 2010 5:59AM PST
- Collapse -
Older Software
Jan 4, 2010 7:58AM PST

Bob,
My wife just got a laptop with Win 7 Home Premium (64 bit). It is not supposed to have an XP mode. However, I successfully loaded some software that we were running on XP (ACDSee ver 5) and it works just fine. I also loaded a piece of freeware that didn't say whether it was for Win 7 or not. It works OK. It has two folders for program files. One is named Program Files and the other Program Files (x86). I'm not sure what this all means relative to your question. I can't tell if the files are separated 32 bit/64 bit or not. Maybe someone else can elaborate on this.

- Collapse -
It is
Jan 4, 2010 8:07AM PST

It is. In the 64-bit versions of Windows you have Program Files for 64-bit apps, and Program Files (x86) for the 32-bit files.

- Collapse -
Odds are
Jan 4, 2010 8:06AM PST

Odds are, if an app works in XP it'll work in 7. Under the hood, the two really aren't all that different. However, if you had to do anything funny to get an app to work under XP, then you can probably count on it not working in 7.

- Collapse -
Older software Compatibility
Jan 4, 2010 11:05AM PST

Perhaps I'm being overly comcerned about my existing software, that suits my needs perfectly: being rendered useless.
Thanks to all, who responded to my inquiry for the input.
Bob W

- Collapse -
Keep XP
Jan 5, 2010 12:59AM PST

Bob,
I've been having the same concerns about XP. With the help of comments from others (see my thread "Anticipating Waning Support" in the XP forum) and brief use of Win 7 on my wife's laptop, I have pretty much decided to keep my old desktop running with XP Home as long as I can. It serves my purposes and considering the cost to upgrade it to run Win7, It would be better to buy new. Again, in the brief time we have had Win7, I haven't found anything that I like about it better than XP. But, my demands are not great and I'm getting old and set in my ways. Perhaps if I had a need for some of the new features, I would feel differently. To me, they have just made changes for the sake of change. They say there are some performance improvements but I don't need increased performance badly enough to make the change.
Like you, I understand that 7 Professional and Ultimate have an XP mode. I have also read and have been told by sales people that 7 Home Premium will not run XP software. However, that has not been my experience so far (see my message above). Also, the Setup Guide that came with my wife's laptop (Dell Inspiron) outlines a method for loading "non-Windows Vista" (I guess the Vista and 7 environments are similar) programs if you have problems with normal install. I haven't had to use it yet but that indicates to me that 7 HP is written to run many older programs.
Good Luck
Bill

- Collapse -
You're confusing a few things
Jan 5, 2010 2:30AM PST

You're confusing a few things. Win 7 Home Premium won't run the XP Mode that's part of Win 7 Professional. That is basically a copy of Windows XP running in a special virtual machine. However, Win7 Home Premium still has a large amount of backwards compatibility built into it, you just get a little additional with Professional is all.

- Collapse -
Thanks!
Jan 5, 2010 2:42AM PST

Dear Bilyo,
Many thanks for the objective assessment of staying with XP vs going to Windows 7. I certainly have no complaints with XP, and feel comfortable using it.
My son bought several computers (both for business & home use) that were Vista equipped, and rapidly considered it to be a big mistake.
Why Microsoft touted that system as being the "latest and greatest" sure is a mystery, other than just to lure new buyers.
Maybe Windows 7 is just a overhauled version of what Vista should have been?
Apple had to be overjoyed with Microsoft's apparent profit only mindset!

It sure is hard to sort thru what is honest technological improvement vs advertising hype and plain old BS, when it comes to computer manufacurer claims.

Thanks again for your comments.
Bob W

- Collapse -
Keeping XP
Jan 6, 2010 12:42AM PST

Bob,
It might me worth noting that in answer to the question "Do You Need Windows 7"?, Woody Leonhard, in his book "Windows 7 For Dummies", states: "Probably not. If you have a PC with Windows XP installed and it works well enough for what you want to do, leave it alone". And, he goes on to expand the point.

Jimmy: I understand what your are saying that backward compatibility and XP mode are not the same thing. I was only expressing my surprise that the older apps would run after having been told emphatically that they would not. We were even considering a dual boot with Win 7 and XP. We are in a "wait and see" mode now.
Bill

- Collapse -
Dumping Windows 2000 and XP.
Jan 5, 2010 1:59AM PST

As the machines fail and the ones with the OEM licenses we all know pass on with the passing of the machine at the office we have done the 7 RC, the 7 Beta and now we use Windows 7 on the spiffy new machines.

Anything that didn't work were items we didn't expect to keep like that old Norton etc. So no loss.

Sure we'll keep Windows XP around where we paid for the retail license but as we move off desktops and onto more laptops there has been no need to carry the baggage of the old stuff around anymore.

Moving on.
Bob

- Collapse -
Another compatibility tool
Jan 5, 2010 2:28AM PST
- Collapse -
Both Windows Vista and Windows 7 have compatibility modes
Jan 6, 2010 12:38PM PST