Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

(NT) BUYING A NEW COMPUTER FOR $424.00 IS IT WORTH IT

Aug 17, 2005 10:02AM PDT

ITS A COMPAQ PRESARIO SR1503WM-B , ITS A BUNDLE FROM WALMART, IT HAS 80 GB 256 MB 2.93GHZ, CD-RW/DVD AND A 17INCH FLAT SCREEN. I HAVE IT IN LAYAWAY, AND I TRIED TO FIND INFO ON THIS MODEL BUT NOTHING HAS COME UP. I NEED SOME ADVICE PLEASE..THANKS

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Yes...
Aug 17, 2005 10:19AM PDT
Click here to view HP's product page about the Canadian Compaq Presario SR1503WM-B. According to the page, the recommended price is $796...much more than Walmart's price of $424. Even Emachines' lowest-priced model, the T3990, is priced at $$339.99 (after a $50 rebate), but doesn't include the monitor. Since the HP includes a monitor (would that be a 17'' flat screen or flat panel?), is a better name brand overall, and has a (slightly) faster processor, it is definately a good deal.

However, be aware that it is a ''budget'' model, meaning it is not expected to perform a lot of multitasking, play high-end programs/games, etc, and has limited upgradability. But, if those specs are good enough for what you want and you don't want to spend more money on a more advanced computer, then that is the computer for you.

Hope this helps,
John


P.S. Since you didn't mention what you currently have, I'm assuming that the new computer is a big step up. If your current computer isn't much slower/older than this one, then you might want to weigh the cost verses the performance increase. But, if nothing else, at least you'll get a keyboard that doesn't have a stuck Caps-lock key...all caps not only makes a post hard to read, but is considered shouting, and thus rude.
- Collapse -
YES
Aug 17, 2005 12:47PM PDT

For the price it's worth it. I looked the computer up at walmart.com at http://www.walmart.com/catalog/product.gsp?product_id=3946852#long_descr
You aren't going to be able to do much gaming or using high-end applications but it can be upgraded to 2GB RAM which is good and I'm sure upgrading the graphics card won't be a problem, if you want to do it in the future. It all depends on what your using it for. If you want it for internet, music(included iTunes) and word processing and even digital photos it will be fine. The only down side is that it has a CRT monitor it is flat screen but don't confuse it with flat PANEL which are LCDs, the CRT flat screen will take up a decent amount of space. Compaq is a good band with quality comparable to HP. Overall its worth it for the price especially if this is a considerable uprgade from what you have now.
Until you get your new computer, good luck with the caps lock.

Jason

- Collapse -
YES
Aug 17, 2005 1:05PM PDT

You are funny, thanks for the check about caps, i forget how bad it is to some~ my current computer is an old compaq presario 5204..the hard disk is 3gb, terrible! Im finally getting a new one just for the speed and space, also XP. the flat screen is not a lcd, (i wish!) but its nicer than what i have. I dont play alot of games on the pc, But i hope it can atleast play some popular games. Im excited! Thanks for your feedback it makes me more comfortable now!

- Collapse -
Glad I could help
Aug 17, 2005 1:42PM PDT

Glad I could Help and have fun with your new computer. Just remember to look at the requirements for the games because the graphics card is 64mb shared which means you can have up to 64MB of video ram, because it is shared video memory it will slow computer down a little while gaming close to that 64 MB limit, more RAM will help will system speed and graphics card is upgradable since that computer model offers plenty of upgrading space (3 PCI slots). And I can relate to that 3GB hard drive, it got annoying.

- Collapse -
64mb
Aug 18, 2005 11:37AM PDT

Im a bit confused on that, is that the video memory? and if i do upgrade how much do you think ill spend?

- Collapse -
Video Memory
Aug 18, 2005 12:36PM PDT

Yes the computer your looking at has a graphics card with 64MB of video memory. What shared means is that the graphics card uses system RAM whereas a graphics card with dedicated memory has its own RAM. Shared memory will lower cost but will limit graphics capabilities and slow the computer while gaming. This computer also can be upgraded to 2MB of RAM which is good. I would recommend at least 512MB of RAM and with a graphics card with shared memory at least 1GB. I say this because if you have 256MB RAM(which is what the computer comes with)the graphics take up 64MB RAM leaving the computer 192MB RAM left. If you have 512 your system has 448MB left and at 1GB(1024MB technically) your system has access to 960MB of RAM. This happens because the system cannot access the RAM being used for graphics. Replacement graphics cards will vary do to manufacturer and current sales. I found a card at circuit city for $70(after rebates) with 128MB dedicated memory, not top of the line but will do fine unless you want to play the more sophisticated games. When buying graphics cards make sure they are the correct type, for this computer your looking at I believe its a PCI card, since there are 3 PCI slots and that's the price I quoted. I've also seen 256MB cards for 100 to 200 dollars. Whether you do upgrade the graphics card or not I recommend upgrading RAM. I have 1GB and my computer runs 50% to a 100% faster than it did with 512MB, so just doubling will do wonders, I got 512MB RAM for $40 at circuitcity also.

Hope this Helps
Jason

- Collapse -
look for an e machine from gateway
Aug 17, 2005 1:21PM PDT

more bang for the buck. make sure to see some online reviews though. not every e machine is an editor's choice, but for about $100 more you can get 512mgs. ram and a 200gig hard drive + opportunity for extended warranty. e machines model T 3256, for instance, is a refurb and is about $429 at refurbdepot.com. this model is rated an editor's choice by cnet.com.

- Collapse -
emachine refurbished
Aug 19, 2005 1:16AM PDT

What exactly does refurbished mean? Im a bit nervous doing that. although for 289.00 it may be worth it.

- Collapse -
Refurbished...
Aug 19, 2005 2:32AM PDT

Refurbished means that the product was previously owned, but returned for some reason...usually because the product was flawed or defective in some way. The product is then shipped back to the manufacturer, which inspects the device (in this case, computer) and repairs/replaces any damaged/flawed parts, touches up the device cosmetically, and resells it at a reduced price. They will usually include a manufacturer's warrenty with the product, although it's usually reduced. (For instance, HP offers a 1-year warrenty on new computers, but only 90-days on refurbs). Typically the computers are just as good as new, and thus a good bargain. They've been inspected, and run about the same risk of having problems as a new computer. However, some poeple prefer to stick to new computers, as the warrenty is better and they feel more comfortable with a computer that has not ''had a history.'' The ultimate decision, though, is up to you.

Hope this helps,
John

- Collapse -
Thanks All!
Aug 19, 2005 8:25AM PDT

I think i'll stick with the Compaq, Hopefully i wont have to start a new thread with problems..lol
I wish i had a dollar for each of you! :} Thanks again!
P>S> Ive never used the windows xp, Is it difficult to learn?

- Collapse -
Windows XP's not bad...
Aug 19, 2005 9:27AM PDT

The entire interface received a makeover, so it takes a week or so to get used to, but it's still the same Windows underneath (with some nice new features), so there's not much to learn. The major differences:
---------------
*** Great new design, though you can choose to revert to the old Windows95/98/ME look if you want. (To do so, right click the desktop, select properties, click the ''appearance'' tab, and select ''Windows Classic Style'' under ''windows and buttons.''

*** By default, the My Computer, my Documents, and My Network Places icons do not appear on the desktop (only the recycle bin is shown)...they're on the start menu. To bring them back, select the desktop tab, click ''customize desktop,'' and place check marks next to the ones you want. (Then, to chage the start menu, right-click the task bar, select properties, click the "start menu" tab, then select the style you prefer and click "customize.")

*** If you create multiple users, you be greeted with a new login screen. (By default, you'll start with the ''administrator'' account, but it's best to create another one and only use the default for emergencies. (To create new ones, go start->control panel->user accounts->create a new account.)

*** Administrative account have full access to all files, programs, and settings. Limited accounts only have access to their own files, and basic settings, and not all programs may be available for use unless advanced settings are enabled per program.

*** Pressing ctrl+L will allow you to remain logged in to one account, then return to the login screen to log into a second or third. It's a great feature if your spouse or kids need to do something on their accounts, but you don't want to log out and lose what you were doing.

*** Pressing ctrl+alt+delete twice no longer restarts your computer. However, there is an option to restart by pressing the key combination once.
---------------
Aside from that, it's not much different. You'll run in to several other changes and new features, but they're pretty easy to understand and use. Microsoft made this version more ''friendly'' and easier to use/understand than it's previous releases. However, if you ever have a question about anything, feel free to ask in the Windows XP forum. Just think of us as a free version of Best Buy's Geek Squad. Happy

Hope this helps,
John

- Collapse -
E machine!!!!!! NO!!!!!!
Aug 20, 2005 3:07PM PDT

DONT DO IT TO YOURSELF!!!!!!! ITS NOT WORTH IT!!!!!!

- Collapse -
e machines T3256 review
Aug 18, 2005 12:14PM PDT
- Collapse -
How are u going to use it?
Aug 20, 2005 3:05PM PDT

Really it depends on what you do w/ it. If you just surf play simple games and like mp3's it'll do fine. Just dont bog it down w/ heavy ram intensive programs cuz 256 MB's of ram in todays standards is the bare minimum it would have a hard time running AOL 9.0 not that i suggest using AOL (its evil) 3 Ghz deffinitly not bad and 80 gigs is plenty for the average user and HP who makes Compaq are nitoriously slow and unreliable..... is suggest Apple... that will put me up for ridicule but if you use one you will never go back trust me i work on PC's why would i want to own one

- Collapse -
Here's you model
Aug 24, 2005 1:57AM PDT

If you type that model into the HP site it comes up fine.

http://h10025.www1.hp.com/ewfrf/wc/genericDocument?lc=en&cc=us&docname=c00387081

I bought an HP on special from Walmart for $400 3yrs. ago and I have been very happy with it an no problems what so ever with it. Just about the same specks as this model. I am not into gaming so use it for e-mail, to edit my photos and make VCD's, work with paint shop pro and stuff like that and it does what I need just fine.

- Collapse -
(NT) did you?
Aug 25, 2005 2:07PM PDT

did you get the operating system software including, i mean the actual cd roms?

- Collapse -
From my experience...
Aug 26, 2005 12:02PM PDT

No you most likely won't get the actual cd-roms with the computer. I have two computers and neither came with the OS cd's. Not sure what you would need them for other than recovery if your computer crashes. But for that, when you first turn on your computer I think you will be asked to create a recovery drive on your hard drive and recovery cd's. At least that is what my HP did.

- Collapse -
hmm
Aug 26, 2005 1:40PM PDT

thats what i thought i would need them for the xp anyway, just in case in crashes. thanks