Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Notebook for a photography student.

Jul 15, 2006 4:22PM PDT

Hi, I know there are a lot of student notebook threads, but my requirements are a bit different. I'm going to be starting at Brooks Institute of Photography this fall, in the Professional Photography BA program, and I'm going to need a notebook for use while I'm there.

The issue is, unlike most students, I need a system that isn't going to make using Photoshop CS2 a nightmare. We're going to be using PS in our coursework quite heavily later in the course (after the first year, mostly), so it's imperative that I can run PS quickly and effectively.

Additionally, I'll need all the usual stuff any student wants, like a cavernous HD (tons of high-res photos, including gigantic large-format film scans, 20gig or so of music, etc), WiFi, CD/DVD burner, and so on. Less common needs include Bluetooth. (For using my cellphone as a modem in the field)

There are a few things I defenitely don't want, though. Desktop replacement-style laptops are too big and heavy, and the battery life too short, to carry from campus to campus and so on, especially if I'm also lugging my 4x5 camera and accessories as well. Secondly, I'm a lifelong PC user, and am extremely reluctant to get a Mac (it'd have to be the MB Pro) due to the lack of native Photoshop CS support and, more importantly, the huge number of reported defects/issues present in those units.

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Choices :

Ok ... I see what you need.

Platform : Centrino Duo for better performances and a better battery life.

Processor : 2.00 GHz Core Duo T2500 OR 2.16 GHz Core Duo T2600 OR Wait a little bit for the Merom.

RAM : 2 GB DDR2 533 MHz OR 667 MHz ( there is not a very big difference ).

Battery : Extended battery 9-cell or 12-cell.

GPU : At least an ATi Mobility Radeon X1400 or nVIDIA GeForce Go 7400.

Hard-drive : 100 OR 120 GB at 5400 RPM OR 7200 RPM ( battery life will be better with the 5400 RPM but performances will be better withe the 7200 RPM hard-drive. For the difference, go with the 5400 ).

Model : Dell Inspiron 6400 /E1505, Sony VAIO SZ Customized line, Lenovo R or Z Serires, ASUS A7J series or A6JA Series with the powerful ATi Mobility Radeon X1600, HP Pavilion dv5000t with the nVIDIA GeForce Go 7400, some ACER Travelmates like the 8200, HP Compaq nc8430.

Make your choice Happy

Good luck !

- Collapse -
Thanks.
Jul 16, 2006 5:15AM PDT

Thanks for the advice.

However, I've realized an issue...

Everything at this school is totally mac-based.

Does anyone have enough experience with Photoshop CS2 on both platforms to tell me whether they're similar enough (in terms of commands, menus, etc) that I'll be able to follow along with mac-oriented instruction, or will I be lost due to differences in the way the program operates?

I'm afraid that I may be stuck having to get a Mac Book Pro if the differences are large enough that working on a PC when everyone else is on a Mac will prove to be a problem. It's a tough school, and the last thing I want is to fall behind in class because my version of Photoshop works differently from the one the teacher/other students are using...

- Collapse -
PS...
Jul 16, 2006 5:18AM PDT

It just occurred to me that the school may require us to use certain programs that are Mac-specific...

If that's the case...

What's good in the way of an ultraportable/ thin & light laptop for a student? I'll use the PC for all general tasks and the Mac just for photo work if I have to get a Mac, and if the photo requirement is removed, I'm more than willing to sacrifice screen-space in order to have something that's small, light, and easy to carry around.

- Collapse -
Ok ...

I never worked on a MAC computer, but I can say you that many many people told me their experience with this operating system. I can tell you that the majority ( if it's not 100 %! ) love this OS and they still working with Mac OSX. Now that you can run both Windows XP/Vista and Mac OSX Tiger on the same machine, go for with this. You will not regret this new world.

I would recommend you the MacBook Pro. It is more performant because it has the powerful ATi Mobility Radeon X1600. MacBook laptops have only the Intel GMA 950 chip. The ATi is far better than the intel chip for graphically intensive tasks.

The smallest MacBook Pro is 15.4", but its design is slim and light.

Some say that the MacBook Pro is the fastest mobile computer. I don't have misery to beleive this !