You also said you hooked them up after booting the system and that one had an OS. A new drive will not have an OS and you cannot hook up a new hard drive in the way you mentioned. By any chance are these USB drives and are they used? There's something missing in the sequence of events in your post. If your Toshiba had Windows installed on it, the OS wouldn't format the drive it resides on.
So i acquired a couple of new hard drives and wanted to add them to my system. I boot up my pc without either of them attached then hook them up once fully booted. They show up in computer management as drive D and E. D has an operating system on it but i didnt know how much of a problem this would pose when formatting it. After formatting D and rebooting, my computer had no operating system and for whatever reason in my BIOS my original hard drive ( a toshiba) now reads as a Hitachi (two new hard drives) Im aware i probably screwed this up beyond repair but could someone at least tell me what i did wrong? Should i not have tried to format a disk that had an already present OS EVEN IF it wasnt the one i was currently running off of?

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic