I too faced this issue and discovered that the Seagate Barracuda drives offer a 5 year warranty (parts/labor) whereas all others only offered 3 years max. This becomes a great indictor of dependability for the drives. At less than $100.00 for a 500GB drive, add another $30.00 for a USB external case and your problem is solved.
I've been looking up solutions for networked storage. I want it mainly for my computer, so I just want to mainly put movies on it. I might do music, but I mainly need all the videos off my desktop.
I've looked at the Western Digital drives, but their network ones have a very low score. I was just wondering what my best bet would be for this, and I'm looking to spend under $200 for 250+GB, even if I need to use my own hard drive.
Any positive help is useful. Thanks!

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic