Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Need help picking out a camcorder!

Jul 18, 2007 1:36PM PDT

Hi, I have been overwhelmed lately with trying to find the best camcorder for myself. I have decided on one that has a built in hard drive so that I don't have to continually buy tapes or dvds, can easily transfer the video, and can store alot without having to sway tapes/dvds. I will be mostly shooting my newborn as he grows up. I need a camcorder that has good indoor/low light video as much of the video will be shot indoors. I have been reading that the Sony camcorders don't do well in low light situations. I want the color to be nicely saturated. I would like a good quality zoom with a good stabilization (not digital). Any help would be greatly appreciated!! My budget is around the $1000 mark. Thanks!

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
A slight misconception...
Jul 18, 2007 11:56PM PDT

Actually, Sony's Hard Disk Drive(HDD) camcorders performed the best in low-light situations when compared to JVC (it's other competitor). I haven't kept up much with the new Panasonic HDD camcorders, but other memebers have posted nice things about them. The thing Panasonic is famous for implementing in its camcorders is 3CCD. Usually this 3CCD configuration is beneficial in brightly-lit areas, but not as much in low-lit areas. You say you want good low-light, but also *great* saturation. 3CCD technology does the saturating better, but the 1 large CCD or CMOS sensor does the low-light shooting better. Sony only uses either a 1 large CCD or CMOS sensor. (The difference between CCD and CMOS is minute at best.)

About 2 years ago, Sony's first HDD camcorder (SR100) was perhaps the best HDD low-light performer to date. It would be hard to find that camcorder, but you could surely get it for no more than $800 new. The one thing that doesn't fit your criteria is the digital image stabilization, not optical.

Give your thoughts. Also, read the Camcorders Forum Sticky and search through www.camcorderinfo.com for some good info.

- Collapse -
trying to narrow down
Jul 19, 2007 11:49AM PDT

I have been doing a lot of reading on camcorderinfo.com and am just confusing myself even more. I'm trying to narrow it down from the one's available on the Crutchfield website. I've been able to get it down to these: http://www.crutchfield.com/S-V6H5o9Cmkxb/cgi-bin/ProdComp.asp?g=121300&s=0&cc=01&hidesimilar=&compareitems=257GZMG130&removeitems=257GZMG130&compareitems=257GZMG57&removeitems=257GZMG57&compareitems=158DCRSR42&compareitems=257GZMG77&removeitems=257GZMG77&compareitems=257GZMG155&removeitems=257GZMG155&compareitems=158DCRSR82&compareitems=133SDRH200&compareitems=158HDRSR5&compareitems=158HDRSR7&compareitems=257GZHD7 Any suggestions?

- Collapse -
html problem
Jul 19, 2007 11:54AM PDT

Sorry the link didn't work, just copy and paste it and it'll work. There should be 6 camcorders that come up: Sony DCRSR42, DCRSR82, HDRSR5, HDRSR7; Panasonic SDRH200; and the JVC GZHD7. I'm not against buying a couple year old model off of ebay. So if you think an older model would fit my needs better let me know. Thanks!!

- Collapse -
If those are your choices...
Jul 19, 2007 12:17PM PDT

I would first remove the SR42 and 82 since the others are much better. Again, I don't have first hand experience with the Panasonic HDD camcorders so I can't comment on their video quality. The SR5 and 7 are new so again I can't comment on their video quality. The JVC overall is a good camcorder, but its pesky file extensions are what turn me away.

Have you looked at the Sony SR100? Not made anymore, but can be found on eBay.

If I had to decide strictly on video quality, I would choose either the SR7 or HD7, but since there is much more that needs to be taken into consideration, I can't make a well informed decision without seeing an unbiased review yet.

- Collapse -
sr100
Jul 19, 2007 1:18PM PDT

I have been doing a lot of reading about Sony's SR100 and it sounds like an exceptional camcorder. I think I may buy one on ebay if you guys think it would be the best for me. I like the fact that it will be WAY under my budget because it's an older model but I'm afraid of not liking it and not being able to simply return it. Any comments about the SR100 or any other camcorder that would fit my needs would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!!

- Collapse -
sr100, 200, 300
Jul 19, 2007 1:49PM PDT

What are the main differences of the SR 100, 200, and 300??

- Collapse -
Well...
Jul 19, 2007 10:55PM PDT