The problem with tri-mode phones is that when they get into the analog mode, the battery is depleeted much faster.
My tri-mode when in digital mode lasts very long, but in analog mode the battery is depleeted much faster. Once I was in an all analog location, fully charged battery died in 10-15 minutes of talk, I was with a roadside assistance operator, so I know. But, if I had a digital phone it would not have worked at all. I rather have the reception.
So, having said that, digital is more efficient on battery life, however if you travel to analog coverage areas a tri-mode is a must, so you will suffer with the battery life.
As a basic phone, with speaker phone, I think LG VX3300 is a good choice. I have the samsung 650 but it does not have the speaker phone. I don't know enough about the LG VX5200 as it is new in the market. The 3300 has been around for a while (originally as 3100 and then 3200), so I would recommend it.
Hi,
I'm looking for a little advice in purchasing a new phone. We have a remote cabin and need a good tri-mode phone (analog is the only way to get service in the boonies). I currently have a Samsung SCH-150 and have always been happy with it, but the battery is finally dying and I'd like to get something with a speaker phone and a bit better screen. My want and don't want list:
Wants
Good voice quality
Good battery life on standby
Flip phone form factor
Easy to use, uncluttered menue. No crazy graphics
Good, easy to see screen
Speaker phone
Voice dialing
Verizon service
Don't Need
Camera/Video
Web access
Trendy ring tones. I want it to ring like a phone!
MP3 player
The nice guy at Radioshack recommended either an LG-VX3300, VX-5200, or Samsung A650, but reading reviews here didn't exactly sell me on any one of them. He said the Motorola Tri-Mode phones had poor battery life and I didn't care for the screen menues. Most of the other phones they carried were all-digital.

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic