Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

my next pda?

Aug 27, 2005 2:28PM PDT

ive been thinking of getting my 2nd pda, its been a few years. The one ive been using is Toshiba e755. i love it to death. works well still to this day no probliums. even with it being a white box refurb.

i havent been keeping up with pda news lately. so ill pass some things im looking for.

looking for memory, 64+ core memorey
must have CF and SD memory card slots
WIFI
Irda
Pocket PC OS

my questions are.

Have new memorycards been incorperated into pdas? im allllllways running out of memory. i have 3 4gb CF cards, and two 1gb SD cards. im always somehwers where there isnt a computer that will allow me to use dock or mem card reader.

have WIFI speeds increased since 11mbps?

have batterie life increased? i heard of fule cell reasurch a few years back, have they taken flight?

Are ppc being developed with arm still? or has xscal taken over...?

dose the new screen types decrease batterie life?

has java been developed on pocket pcs for web browsing? cause mine doesnt support java.


i think thats all i have for now, as ill look into pdas agen.

i dont really need anything fancy like built in phone, or camera, or radio. cause i already have a CF radio and a CF camera that are ppc 2003 ready. just memory and wifi and irda are my key.

thanks

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Answers...
Aug 27, 2005 4:27PM PDT

My that's a long list. Unfortunately, it's not long enough. So, I'm going to have to add a little information/commentary. Happy

* PDAs are currently able to connect at 11MB/s over WiFi. However, I'm willing to bet there is a greater chance that I've won the lottery and not known it that actually receiving the full 11MB/s. There are just too manu factors (distance, weather, and misc. objects) that prevent you from attaining this theoretical maximum.

* Battery life is still stuck at around 4 hours of constant use. The built-in backup battery Dell and a few others include is a nice touch, but I'm still waiting for a next-gen battery to appear in a PDA.

* All current processors are XScale, but most software developers still design for ARMs. For most downloads, you'll see SH3, MIPS, and ARM, so download the ARM version. Some of the larger publishers have added an extra XScale category, although the ARM version seems the same to me.

* The screens do take up battery power more than the older ones. (The VGA screen on the Dell Axim X50v is the worst.) The way to combat this is to turn the backlight down two notches...it helps immensely. Also, WiFi tends to deplete your battery quickly, but that's currently without a solution.

* PocketPCs still don't come with Java. The good news is that third-party developers have stepped up...click here for more information.

* PocketPCs can accept (depending on the model) SD and CF (Type II) cards, although some have problems with anything over 1GB.

* Windows Mobile 5.0 will run on units with 64MB ROM, but 128MB is recommended, and future units may go to 256MB.

Since you're looking for a PDA that will last a while and have plenty of storage, I suggest waiting until October. Why? That's when dell is planning to launch the X51 and X51v, and HP has a few units planned for release around the same time. Right now no official release has been made, and the only thing that's for sure is that they will run Windows Mobile 5.0 natively. However, where's what can spark rumors:

* WM 5.0 is the first version that supports mini hard drives. Palm's LifeDrive has been a hit due to it's 4GB, and Dell and HP are looking to catch up. They have been negotiating with a few Asian companies to see who can come up with the smallest and most power efficient hard drive prior to the fall launch. Thus, it's almost guarenteed that we'll see at least two PDAs with internal HDs.

* Intel has just announced the next generation of Xscale processors, which can reach speeds of 1.25 GHZ! While it's unlikely we'll see anything quite that fast initially, there's bound to be an increase over the 624MHz processors currently available.

So, if you're looking for a higher end model (which is what it sounds like), I'd advise holding off just a little while longer. The new devices will probably cost more, but will definately be worth it. If you can't wait, post a price range and I make a few recommendations. In the mean time, check out Dell's complete line of PDAs, which are on average $100 cheaper than an HP with similar specs.

Hope this helps,
John

- Collapse -
haha thanks john
Aug 28, 2005 1:16AM PDT

i was actually considering replacing my hp 4150 with the dell axim x50v and then i read on aximsite about the next x51v. i was liking the idea of a hdd but how long would these things last? i mean, it's mechanical so it wouldn't last as long as flash rom or ram. i haven't heard of the new x scale cpus, but now i am looking forward to it. the only reason i'd want to replace my ipaq would be the landscape viewing and the newer version of PIE. other than that, it's fine as is. i guess i'll hold off for awhile until i see some new stuff. Wink

konny

- Collapse -
5 years.
Aug 28, 2005 2:03AM PDT

My IIIc is approaching 5 years. My wife has the Palm Vx that shows little wear and it's over 3 years old and does great for what she wants.

Of course there are users and then there are users...

Bob

- Collapse -
thanks
Aug 28, 2005 4:25AM PDT

im a lil warry of internal hard drives, even my CF type 2 mem cards.

i hope they do like IBM and make a shock resistant modle atleast. lol i just droped my pda last night, batterie came out but it still works. lol.

thanks for your help, its verry apreciated. Thanks!

- Collapse -
My Toshiba e805.
Aug 27, 2005 10:17PM PDT

You could have it if I wasn't using it for some possible software app. The wifi range is terrible.

My iPaq RX3115 wifi is amazing.

And no, the move to 802.11g is rather slow but some will have it. With such a small screen and 64 to 256M of RAM, 802.11g speeds seem to counter what you want in a PDA. Such as battery time?

Bob