20 total posts
Re: Office 2007
Those users of Office 2007 who object to this product should have been buying Office 2003 (as far is I know it's fully compatible, and comparable in price) or downloaded free OpenOffice.
Why not post the details: what incompatibility in what program and what version of MS Office? It would be interesting to see the list.
Its like MS ran out of ideas and just decided
to change stuff for the sake of changing it. Office 2007 has the WORST UI design I have ever seen in a major software release. "The Ribbon" is a clunky, half baked idea.
Not a single person I have talked to in my office of 35 likes any part of Office 2007. Having to hunt down the little unmarked graphic doo-dads that opens up submenu after submenu to get to a basic command that used to be clearly visible in the menu is a huge waste of time and energy.
Our office will not be upgrading again and is considering a third party alternative.
For a few dollars ...
you can buy a third party addon that restores the old menu's in Office 2007. If the new version really is a "huge waste of time and energy" your boss might find it a VERY good investment of the companies money.
About three seconds of research...
Would lead you to a free (for personal use) GUI add-on for O2K7 that brings the old menu functionality back. It adds a tab on the ribbon (see screenshot in the link below) labeled "Menu", and you just stay within that tab to use the old menu structure. Geez, people...as Arnold once said "Stop Whining!"
The free version is free. The commercial version is ~14.00 plus 90 cents per client. Big Whoop.
With 35 people ...
that's a lot of money in this economy, considering they already spent a fortune to buy and learn a program they didn't want :-).
A lot of money?
$45.58 <b>total</b> for 35 clients? I guess we don't agree on what constitutes "a lot of money". Not to mention the fact that productivity will go up substantially if these individuals truly don't like the ribbon interface. That, then, falls into the "priceless" category.
Just to be clear...
$45.58 / 35 clients = about one dollar and 30 cents ($1.30) per client. That's pretty darn cheap, in my view.
Sorry. It was meant as sarcasm.
But you didn't understand. Sorry again.
I should have gotten that given your comments earlier in the thread. Doh!
Web address for Ubitmenu download?
Thank you so much for that information ... I have been going mad trying to use the new methodology and it just takes too much energy! Your suggestion sounds like a godsend
2007 UI is vastly superior to the old one. Much more logical and quicker to use.
Not everybody agrees with you.
But most people need some time at least to get accustomed to it. And maybe they even start to love it, like you do.
IMO there is nothing logical or quick about the Ribbon.
The most egregious error it makes is that it departs from unified computing standards that made GUI OS's like Windows and Mac so easy to use in the first place. If every program feels free to reinvent the wheel then the end user ends up wasting time figuring out a new paradigm for every single piece of software.
Kind of like having to spend time learning the latest multiplayer game. Darn it! The keyboard shortcuts are different! They should all look the same!
I don't want to live in a world where every software app is always going to follow the same menu structure ad infinitum. At some point, you have to update it. And, some people will moan and groan, while others say "it's about freaking time!". From my reading, there does appear to be a split. I'd say, though, that the people who have taken the time to learn the Ribbon by and large tend to like it.
About the only thing I can agree on with this switch is that they should have provided a way to opt back to classic mode. But the very cheap (and even free) add-on I linked to above gives you the best of both worlds. You can stay within the classic structure in the Menu tab, or use the Ribbon, itself.
Consistancy is vital, yes
It is the most important thing you need for an easy to use system.
But don't you tHink the menu, toolbar paradigm just was not serving an app as complex as micrsoft office well? The menu was a maze of commands and sub-commands with multiple lays of dialogue boxes under those...
The menu and palette system ties it all together.
Its what makes using Photoshop and Dreamweaver not all that different (at a root level) than using Autocad or Quark Express. Good UI design should be simple to get into for the casual user yet have depth for the power user. Office 2007 fails on this account in my opinion.
The analogy to games might actually be appropriate but not for the reason you might think. When you look at how huge an industry casual gaming has become you understand the appeal of simplicity. People love these kinds of games because, unlike the games for the hardcore players, they are easy to get into and the controls are simple and intuitive.
2007 UI superior? Not Really
I have used it for 2 years and it has been depressing. The main problem is you can't have multiple ribbons visible at once, and, when you tab to another ribbon, thinks move.
What is maddening is it MS could not see fit to allow for the old menus (not new menus incorporating new parts of Office 07) and claiming at the same time as more user friendly. Not for an experienced user.
In Microsoft's eyes, anyway. If I were on the office 2007 team, I would have made a provision to revert back to the previous version's UI. The vast technical differences between the two office platforms prevent this, but it would not have been impossible to facilitate. Hell, they are Microsoft, they can do this if it were in their interest. Making their latest office product easy to use for everyone should be amongst their priorities, but it is not.
Microsoft is in the midst of a decline in the market space. Poor product releases and a lack of true understanding in the consumer space has steered this course. Soon the enterprise will be next...
I also find the Ribbon UI nice and neat and much cleaner to use, but that is me. 90% of the folks I talk to about it, hate Office 2007's UI and sluggishness. For example, the default menus in MS Access 2007 contain the top features I regularly use in the database. I never have to go any deeper in the menus at all. That is at work where someone else pays the licensing for this ridiculously priced suite. If the aquisitions were up to me, we would all be running OpenOffice 3.