Harddrive players are not good. They're big, heavy, consumes a lot of power, easily broken, and some are even noisy. Definately not something you would want to carry around in a gym.
Put it in your pocket and feel your pants drop down...
1 GB isn't measly. In my opinion, 512 MB is more than enough. An average 5 minute mp3 file at the typical 128kbps quality is just under 5 MBs. 512 MB would take more than 100 songs. Do you really need that many? Most people just load the player with favorite songs that they were actually gonna listen to. Let's say that you get a 20GB harddisk player, are you really going to move the entire music collection into it? It wouldn't be very convinent, as you'll have to constantly browsing through songs to find favorites to listen to.
I would recommand any of the smaller iRiver players.
http://www.bananapc.com/promo/general/0412_iriver/0412_iriver.htm
I brought the first one on the list, with 128MB, more than a year ago. The price then was twice as it is now. It works perfectly so far, there have been problems. 128MB, or 26 songs, and a FM turner, is enough for me. I change the songs once in a while, and keep the music collection on the computer.
The joystick is really useful. You can change the volume, fast forward and rewind without having to take it out of the pocket. Don't have to try to push small, tiny buttons with fingertips. Also, the old models are rock solid. I'm a really clumsy person, the bruise on my forehead from this morning says something about that. All my possesions are broken, except the mp3 player. The glass panel covering the screen has a crack in it, but display and back lit light still works fine. It was practically indestructable. The small triangular cylinder case is supported by 2 solid chrome triangle plates at both ends. You can hit it with a hammer, and the plates would take on the weight. I once dropped it in the kitchen sink filled with dirty dishwater, and didn't realize until about an hour later. It doesn't turn on right after I fished it out, so I let it sit in the sun for the afternoon. Later, when it's dry, I turned it on and all the songs are still there. Didn't even change to fresh battery. It just works as if nothing happened.
That's the old IFP player. The new ones look less sturdy...
I want to get an MP3 player to take to the gym. Is it ok to get a harddrive payer (iPod or Karma??). I want to have lots and lots of songs available but I am concerned about the moving parts. Must I get a measly 1GB flash player??

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic