Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

Question

Motherboard Upgrade

Mar 28, 2012 4:26AM PDT

I am in the process of upgrading APU, Motherboard and power supply in my CPU operating Windows XP Pro/3.
I have read the typical install tips about replacing a motherboard but have hit a problem. I inserted my OEM CD and after clicking Install XP, I get an error message that tells me the installed version is newer than the one on the disk. Is this because the CD has on Service Pack 2 installed on it and I have Service Pack 3 on my computer? It is the CD which I installed the OS in the beginning. Do I proceed with the upgrade?

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Answer
Problem #1
Mar 28, 2012 4:58AM PDT

Problem #1 is you say you have an OEM copy of XP and that you're changing the motherboard. That won't work. The license for the OEM version of Windows lives and dies with the hardware it was activated on. According to Microsoft's way of thinking, and since they control the activation servers, theirs is the only one that counts, what you're doing basically constitutes building a new computer, so you need a new Windows license for it.

Even if you get past where you are now, it will fail to activate and you will get nowhere with the phone reps in Microsoft's Activation Center.

So I would just cut my losses were I you, and rethink the whole setup. Based on what you've described, I already know what your problem is, but it wouldn't matter if I told you how to solve it. Odds are installing Windows is beyond your current skill level, especially since if you're replacing the motherboard you're probably going to be using a SATA HDD, which adds a whole new level of complexity to what is already more than a lot of people can manage.

- Collapse -
Microsoft Article 824125
Mar 28, 2012 5:07AM PDT

If what you say is gospel, then could you explain Microsoft Article 824125. My current skill level is a bit higher than you have given me credit for. I have built several computers from the case on up. Look forward to your reply.

- Collapse -
Error in Original Post
Mar 28, 2012 5:15AM PDT

In referring to my Windows CD, I may have misled in using the term OEM. The CD is Window XP Professional Version 2 with Service Pack 2 installed. I have installed it on two different CPU's. Sorry about that.

- Collapse -
Then that is another problem
Mar 28, 2012 6:35AM PDT

Then that is another problem, because unless you have a license for each of those copies, one of them is pirated. The Windows license also stipulates that you can install a SINGLE copy on a SINGLE computer.

And the article you refer to assumes a RETAIL or volume license copy of Windows, not OEM.

- Collapse -
Answer
It runs deeper than this. However.
Mar 28, 2012 5:44AM PDT

Yes it has to do with a mismatch but this area is very grey. The OEM versions did not support upgrades so that's why.
Bob

- Collapse -
Is Article and Instructions Valid?
Mar 28, 2012 6:53AM PDT

So, what now? By Windows Article, I can accomplish what I want to do but still the question is unanswered as how to overcome the question of versions. Do I continue with the install based on the article with the CD I have?

- Collapse -
Installed version newer than the one on disk.
Mar 28, 2012 7:25AM PDT

So you wipe the disk. Then it will install. Then you upgrade again to SP3.

Kees

- Collapse -
Wipe the drive and install your XP?
Mar 28, 2012 9:15AM PDT
- Collapse -
Best Upgrade
Mar 29, 2012 4:05AM PDT

After rethinking my issue, I am inclined to just build the computer and upgrade to Windows 7. Now the question remains what edition do I purchase (on line) Windows 7 Home (Upgrade) Windows 7 Home (OEM) with Service Pack 1 or Windows 7 Professional.

- Collapse -
Upgrade versions
Mar 29, 2012 4:34AM PDT

Upgrade versions do not have a license, they transfer the existing license from a previous version of Windows, so you would need a copy of a qualifying upgrade product to get it to install. OEM versions are discounted "full" versions that come with no support of any kind from Microsoft, and will live and die with the hardware they are first activated on.

Full retail versions of Windows are the most expensive, but they come with the full retail license which allows you to transfer that license to a different computer. So if you build your own computer, and then later on want to replace the motherboard, the extra money you pay up front is so that you can reactivate that copy of Windows on the new hardware.

Unless you get a volume license, which is highly unlikely given they cost tens of thousands of dollars and Microsoft doesn't give them out to just anyone with the cash, you are still only allowed to install a SINGLE copy of Windows on a SINGLE computer. That goes for OEM and full retail versions. If you build one computer, and then build a completely new computer, wanting to install Windows on the new computer, you need to remove Windows from the first computer before activating it on the second to stay on this side of the license agreement.

So when in doubt, it's probably best to go with full retail copies of Windows rather than OEM. That little bit of extra money can save a lot of headaches down the road.

- Collapse -
Procedure
Mar 29, 2012 5:32AM PDT

Should I upgrade my XP to Windows 7 prior to installing new motherboard since I am keeping my present HD, or should I remove my files to an external HD and then replace MB and load new OS?

- Collapse -
There is no upgrade
Mar 29, 2012 6:11AM PDT

There is no upgrade from XP to Windows 7. It has to be done as a clean install.