Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

LCD's/Plasmas look cruddy in store. At home too?

Oct 2, 2005 3:42AM PDT

Ok, need some clarification. I hear how wonderful and great flat screens and plasmas ( and lcd's are.) However, when I go into any store, almost every flat screen from the biggest to the smallest to the most expensive, they all look really pixelated. Very few ever look crisp and clean and without any jaggies or artifacts. My home 27'' Magnavox tube tv looks crisper and doesn't have all the artifacts these super TV's have.

Why is this?

I had heard that the Sharp Aquos TV's were great, so I went to Circuit City today to look at one. They were playing a Monster's Inc. DVD on it and same thing. When I got near it, I saw all these jaggies. I asked the Circuit City guy if he new anything about Flat screens and he said he did. I asked him the question and he said that is just how the TV's work. Then he said it was because the contrast ratio is not good and that is why they are pixelated. That seemed strange. I was wondering if it might be because they are splitting the signal so many times to go to so many TV's in the store. I thought contrast ratio had to do with color, not artifacts.

Any ideas?

thanks!

Judge S

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
LCD's/Plasmas look cruddy in store. At home too?
Oct 2, 2005 5:42AM PDT

How close were you standing. I am know expert but from what i have read there is a min distance you should be from the tv like 3-5 feet. The other day i stood right in front of a panasonic and could see all the pixcels then i stood back about 7 feet and it looked very good. Dont have one at home yet cant make up my mind.

- Collapse -
I asked the Circuit City guy if he new anything about Flat
Oct 3, 2005 2:04AM PDT

Well guess what,,,, He dosen't!!! This should not be a surprise.
EVERY TV type has it's short commings or drawbacks and advantages.
Most plasmas that I have seen in stores are the ED 640x480 types. Yes they look pixelated. Most of this years modles are the HD 1280x720 they look much better.
But the stores are tring to clear out last years ED models. So guess what you get to look at.
In terms of sharpness the direct view CRT still RULES.
But if you want a 50" screen then you will have to get something else. John

- Collapse -
CRT RULES
Oct 3, 2005 10:12AM PDT

"In terms of sharpness the direct view CRT still RULES."

Don't forget about direct view CRT's superior black level.

- Collapse -
That may be true BUT.....
Oct 19, 2005 6:09AM PDT

CRT sets only get so big, everyone is being told to buy large TV's today, or projection screens. Even CRT projectors are going away. So unfortunatly, the average consumer is at the mercy of an entire army of salespeople working the floors of big box stores with little knowledge. So many of them end up guessing, or worse making stuff up that sounds plausable. And that is why you see so many posts on this site with people that seem so confused. (even some of the responses on this site are Just bad info)

- Collapse -
Depends on the Connections Used
Oct 3, 2005 6:09PM PDT

it really depends on which stores, which tv's, and what kind of connections they use. a while ago, very few hdtv's had built in ATSC tuners in it. that means the stores were forced to display them with component cables at best...and putting component on every tv will be pricey and probably not worth it.. so they most likely used Coax or composite for the smaller ones. especially with smaller lcd's....a store like CC will have 20+ of them on display and they will likely NOT spend that much money in cables to hook them up because markup on the tv's isnt really that high. whereas on projos and plasmas...they can use whatever cables they want cause the markup is so much.

now, as more and more HDTV's are being made with built in tuners, its so much easier to get a good picture from it. instead of using $50 component cables, one can easily use $5 RG6 coax cables to get a hd picture. the coax is actually the cable i perfer to use on the displays in the store i work at because we can save the component cables for customers, and the picture will actually be better then using component cables because of the built in ATSC tuner in the tv.

- Collapse -
you need to do some homework....
Oct 19, 2005 5:30AM PDT

If you are saving the component cables "for the customers" and not connecting your display sets to show what they look like with different sources, you are taking the same approach as mentioned somewhere above. Why bother people seem to buy them anyway. Not all plasma's and LCD's have HD tuners built in, what are doing to display those? One piece of coax, is that all you tell your customers they need when they take one home?

- Collapse -
sorry for the misunderstanding.
Oct 19, 2005 4:12PM PDT

we are just really low on stock on component cables and warehouse isnt sending us any even when we request them.

the tv's without builtin tuners are DEFINITELY hooked up with component cables. its just that lately, there are so many more new hdtv's comming in and our store is quite old so there arent enough component outputs for them. thats where the coax comes into play.

- Collapse -
thus the problems
Oct 19, 2005 11:50PM PDT

It's too bad you have to work somewhere like that, this is why these threads are being posted, the avarage consumer comes in, and see's a bunch of TV's, some look great others are just so so. They all have the ability to look good. Now you end up with a customer that "thinks" one brand must be better than another, because thats what he saw. If they come into this forum, suddenly they are trying to tell people that this brand is better than the next, and yet it may very well not be true. And even the sales staff in many of these places only know a couple of "spec's" and that ends up being what they base their information on, no actual knowledge of what the differences mean, or what the features of some sets are and how they relate to what the customer may be looking for, or wanting to use the set for. It's like selling someone a computer with a P4 blah blah blah, and all the great spec's, when all he was asking for is something to use for internet and word processing.

- Collapse -
Signal Split Among Many TVs
Oct 5, 2005 1:57AM PDT

I recently bought a plamsa TV. One thing the salesperson mentioned is that the signal is split among many TVs, which degrades the signal. After installing the TV in my house, it looks significantly better than it did in the store.

- Collapse -
Cruddy images
Oct 5, 2005 3:18AM PDT

One thing I never see mentioned here is what the screen "refresh" rate is on any LCD or Plasma TV. I, like you, hate seeing the pixels rebuild when motion takes place. Worse is seeing the pixels rebuild on facial flesh tones. A TV with a very quick refresh rate will have less pixelation vs. one with a slower refresh rate.

- Collapse -
LCD/Plasma and/or Flat Panel (edtv - HDTV) Does in Fact Look
Oct 7, 2005 8:00PM PDT

BEFORE throwing in the Towel, Check the connections on the END CAPs which advertise featured Items that are used to Draw You in (or over to ) the Pretty Little Flat Screen With the perfect picture. These in the most recent End Cap Change are hooked to a Basic Dvd Player sold in House for 20-40 dollars. Wholla!!! they are using correct cables thus having a picture perfect screen. As for the Isled Flat Screens, Most are powered with a rca or coax connection, that in itself is enough to make you think ...they want me to spend how much for this?

Dont Worry. Hopefully in your endeavor you have a laptop with DVI out . TAKE YOUR LAPTOP IMMEDIATELY, WITH A DARK MOVIE AND A BRIGHT MOVIE in hand so you can test the HD part of the screen at you . For what i think you are talking about, it is like going from the 20's straight to 2015 (ooops 2005...lol) you will more than likely be please with all but one or two of the LCD's or PLasmas after hooking up the dvi cable.

At one of the major retail outlets, i asked the non-commissioned sales person why they didnt have DVI or HDMI feeding the signals. He responded with...Why would we when we sell so many with them looking this bad..

My Advice, If you are buying the Bigger Plasmas, Read the Mounting part of the warranty very carefully, remember, i may have a level that says something is level, the service person's may read that few millimeters off that will hurt ya. Finally. Test the products at the local Stores, Dont trust the reviews. They all Have Good Pictures , better than the older tv models. Even the UN-Known Named units Found at the Cheaper Stores Make you say...I Want That. My First One Was Cheap (Best Buy tried to charge me 1699 but i found it at an online retailer brand new for 999) yet better picture than the $4800 unit. DVI Input or Other HD input is essential.

Use the major dept stores to test your future investment/purchase. Purchase Here; where you dont have to pay for the lousy wiring and uneducated sales staff. Use Your Best Judgement and let me know how things went.

ashley@dverse.com

- Collapse -
pixel size and resolution and signal quality
Oct 8, 2005 5:05PM PDT

When there are two TV displays with the same resolution, and one is much larger, well, the larger screen has larger pixels. Close to the screen, larger pixels are more noticeable as blocky "jaggies", so it may help to back away from larger screens.

For Plasma, LCD, and DLP TVs, check the "native resolution". These displays look best when fed a signal matching their native resolution. A high native resolution screen will have smaller pixels than a low native resolution screen of the same size. (CRT displays don't have a native resolution)

Check the signal used for the display - is the signal high definition 1040i or 720p, or standard definition? Or perhaps even standard analog? Feeding a standard signal to a high def set will not look as sharp as a high def signal. Stores don't always send the best signal to their displays, they may not have upgraded their video distribution system.

- Collapse -
crappy LCD plasma in store????????????????????
Oct 10, 2005 12:16PM PDT

I work at circuit city. I find it strange that you thoguht they looked like crap because in the store it is clear as day that they look better than any other TV, it does have alot to do with splitting the signal but you said you were watchin a DVD, PIXAR animated movies usually show you how vivid the color is on an LCD. Yes the contrast ratio is low on many of the LCD TV's however the color are also more vivid. The plasma technology is where the higher contrast is. However the samsung LCD has a fairly high contrast ratio, 3000:1. About the sharp Aquos, i find it to run a mid 4th to 5th place in the LCD's that we carry. The better ones are the Panasonic, Sony, and Samsung, if you count sony's XBR line as a separate LCD line then you can say a 5th place for the sharp. the LCD has the Highest resolution so i am not sure why you seem to have problems looking at them, esp in the store when you CAN compare with other TV's. we don't adjust any TV every TV we set up comes str8 out the box.

- Collapse -
Don't be Lured-In...Wait...Stick with CRT for Now...
Oct 19, 2005 4:32AM PDT

There is not a whole lot of full 1080 HDTV content now anyway so you're going to spend 90% of your time watching a perspective-corrected NTSC (regular 4:3 TV)signal anyway.
All flat panel devices are discreet pixel displays and there is no way to get around that. CRT's use a electron beam raster on phosphor that gives it a residual light charge and is much smoother to the eyes.
BTW - The rule of thumb for pixelated devices is that you should view them from at least twice the diagonal measurement for your eyes to smooth out the ''jaggies'' but they are still not as smooth or have as good a black level as the good ole CRT.
You can find CRT HDTV Monitors and TVs but only to about 34 inches diagonally. Samsung has some that have a tube that is not as deep (depth of the actual tube) that are HDTV and they look great.
But again, unless you have some favorite over the air or HDTV Digital Cable channel then I'll reiterate that you will be watching a stretched out version (or not using the complete width of the set) picture.

I love and thank all of the folks that are running out and buying flat screens because they are ''cool'', ''must-have'', or ''I can hang it on my wall'' because they are the ones that are going to make the HDTVs inexpensive WHEN there is enough content to justify paying a ''bit'' more for one.

Also if you do get sucked into the HDTV hype and buy one, make sure that it will accept DVI and HDMI connections as well as accepts cablecard, otherwise you will have sold your soul to the cable companies.

Good luck,
Fred Dunn

- Collapse -
The reason why it looked cruddy:
Oct 20, 2005 1:11AM PDT

While there are many factors involved...I think its because u're watching a Monster inc DVD (which is 480p), on a HDTV (which is 720p or higher).
I have a Samsung 27" CRT HDTV, and I used the component HD cable while playing Halo2 on XBox, and I can clearly pixels or jagged edges....while the colors are brighter, the flaws become clearer to see. Now if I just use the regular analog A/V cable to play Xbox on the same TV, the graphics somehow become less jagged, because the signal is not as clear, therefore not revealing as many flaws, as everything is blurred out a bit. Same thing if I watch analog tv/cable that is not HD, I can see how everything is all blurry or jagged.
This also happens with HD signals which are 720p...u can clearly see jagged edges...even on a CRT HDTV.
Next time goto Circuit City and ask them to put on 1080i, then everything changes...suddenly everything is crisp, and clear.
Starting 2006, supposedly "true HD" signals & TVs will be out, delivering 1080i or better yet, 1080p signals. Xbox360 will be using 1080i and PS3 will be using 1080p. And with the coming of HD DVD, and Blu-ray DVDs, they will also sport 1080p signals.
As of now, even 720p signals are visibly jagged, but it is still way cleaner, and brighter than any analog signal out there. Check 1080i, then tell me if its still jagged...many 1080is are outthere, with national broadcasts such as NBC, ABC, CBS supporting it....

- Collapse -
I've seen many, none are great.
Oct 20, 2005 3:28AM PDT

This may be an issue with my eyeballs, but I've wandered into dozens of stores that are all feeding the flat screen TVs the same signal (many are HD signals), and the one common issue I see that bothers me is what I call "swimming pixels." To me, it looks like areas of background or areas of solid colors have pixels that are "rebuilding" or moving around to reposition themselves. I heard there is something called "refresh rate" on these TVs and that a slower refresh rate may cause this, but I've noticed this in every flat screen TV, regardless of make or whether they are 720p, 1080i or the pixel-by-pixel resolution. I love how bright the screens are, but when I spend time watching any of these sets I see this pixel issue and I figure I will wait before plunking down thousands of dollars. Again, maybe it's my own eyeballs.

- Collapse -
You have to go with a sony; Preferably an XBR model
Oct 20, 2005 10:53AM PDT

I have been trying to tell people that Sony carries the best televisions, PERIOD! All televions except for projection based TV's uses pixels to create the picture. The only TV's that does not have pixels are projection and DLP, with DLP being a high tech projection and it is an outstanding technology. Now, if you want a great television Sony is the way to go and here is why. Sony is the only brand that makes their TV's with the smallest pixels possible of all the brands out there and, the pixels are joined tightly together. That is why the picture on a Sony TV looks extremely sharp. If you have the money to purchase an XBR model, it is well worth the money because the pixels get even smaller and tighter than a standard Sony Wega model. Trust me on this!! Now, DLP is a new technology that has come out and works like a projection TV but,the picture is sent to millions of tiny mirrors then reflected onto the screen, which creates the picture that you see. Toshiba and Samsung makes TV's with DLP now but they still can not match the quality picture of a SONY LCD or plasma. I love DLP technology but I will not purchase a DLP TV until SONY makes a TV with DLP and when Sony creates a DLP XBR model, there will be no competition. If I were to buy an HDTV right now, it would be a SONY WEGA LCD or if I could shell out the big bucks, A SONY XBR LCD or Plasma. Once you watch HD programming or a DVD on one of these bad boys, you will thank me. I have to say also that I worked as a Broadcast Operator for Warner Brothers for 5 years and all of our professional equipment was made by sony. I am not a Sony nut, I am just speaking truth. Check it out for yourself.

- Collapse -
Sony's stretch modes?
Oct 21, 2005 2:29AM PDT

I like everything about the Sony's except for their stretch modes to watch SD 4:3 cable broadcasts. I know this is the lowest common denominator of TV viewing, but 90% of what people watch is still 4:3. I wish Sony (and many other brands) would do whatever Toshiba seems to be doing because the Toshiba has one of the better stretch modes.

- Collapse -
Excellent post...And So True....
Oct 21, 2005 4:42AM PDT

...I own a 42" Sony plasma (KDE-42XS955) and I love it with one exception. The two stretch modes are awful and unwatchable. No biggie though, I watch garbage 4:3 SD in it's native aspect ratio with the bars on each side. It's not so bad and I'm hoping that in a year or so, true 16:9 HD will become more and more the norm.

- Collapse -
90% of what people watch is still 4:3 asspect ratio...
Oct 21, 2005 6:19AM PDT

So why be a "bleeding edge" buyer for that 10% of HDTV content for what the sets are costing now? I remember when Philips had their first 42" plasma unit out for over $16,000 some years back, prices aren't going up and your new set is not going to appreciate in value either.

As far as Sony goes, I'm glad you have had good experiences with them...I have had bad experiences with them. My instances they were non-responsive for product problems and they also charge more than a comparable product from another company. 10 or 20 years ago when everything Sony was made in Japan it was worth the extra money but now when Sony is outsourcing manufacturing to Korea and China there is very little if ANY difference in buying say from Samsung.

HDTV, and in particularly Flat Panel HDTV is the most over-hyped "gotta have" product in America.

Think before you buy, they are not going anywhere. That sale that "they" are having is not the last sale they'll ever have and you won't look at the ads for the $500 sets that are 10 times better than yours when you paid $3500 for yours.

Fred Dunn

- Collapse -
Whats the best TV out there under $2000?
Nov 25, 2005 12:24AM PST

why not to the DLP unless its a sony? I am looking for a 40'' plus model and am trying to figure out the one that has the best features, picture, sound, etc.. I am thing of the panasonic model, not a plasma but the projection model, y or y not?

- Collapse -
Sony vs. Toshiba
Nov 25, 2005 7:41AM PST

I was at Best Buy today looking at the Sony KDFE42A10 inch LCD next to the Toshiba 46HM95 model. The Sony picture was much better..compared to the Toshiba. I wanted to buy the Sony but it doesn't have the PIP. The Toshiba as $500 less...special Thanksgiving price. They apparently discontinued the PIP on this lower end model that was released in August. I am hung up on this PIP thing. The Toshiba model has it. The PIP is not something I use everyday, but I do watch some sporting programs that are on at the same time.

The resolutation was the same...but the Sony was much sharper. I asked the "salesman??" and if the sets had been adjusted..and he said.."they don't adjust them because they would be doing that all day". He was every helpful.

So the search goes on. I do have just about everything Sony makes from computer, to PDA, camcorder, digtal camera.

Any thots on this Toshiba??

- Collapse -
PIP Is One Of Those Dumb Things You'll Never Actually Use...
Nov 28, 2005 2:38AM PST

...Kind of like cruise controls on a car.

Absolutely worthless.

- Collapse -
I use my cruise control
Nov 30, 2005 11:19AM PST

Don't knock it until you tried it. Sports fans get the idea of PIP or POP.

I bought the Hitachi..with the POP...and it has a great picture..I was using the POP tonight watching two Primetime programs.. You get twice the satistaction.

- Collapse -
Cruise Control and PIP
Dec 1, 2005 2:12AM PST

I too use my car's cruise control. Aside from A/C in the car, cruise control is the next best thing, especially on the open road. It allows me to stretch my legs, take my shoes off, change sitting positions, etc. I can always tell when the person in from of me isn't using the cruise control as their speed varies from 60 to 80 to 70 to 65 and back up to 70.

As far as PIP, my old-school Toshibe RPTV has version of this. My 50" widescreen TV splits into to images, each about the size of a 27" TV. All I need to do is press one button and I can switch between the audio sources. Great for sports when watching two simultaneous "gotta-watch" games. No, I don't use it very often, but it blows people away when I can watch two huge images side-by-side instead of one little corner picture. I love my old-school Toshiba. Excellent picture with no pixel problems (smearing, lagging, dark details, etc.). The one con: The size. But I have it housed in a complete wall unit, so the size is not an issue.

- Collapse -
...Kind of like cruise controls on a car.
Dec 2, 2005 6:50AM PST

This depends on where you live,,, In a big crowed city,,no. But far away for the big city YES!
I did use PIP untill the remote died, The universal ones didn't support it. John

- Collapse -
You Folks ABSOLUTELY Floor Me...$2000-$5000 For a Freakin TV
Nov 28, 2005 1:52AM PST

WAIT! What's your hurry? New technology is coming your direction in this market every day. Everybody is buying this stuff because it is flat and paying out the nose for it. Relative to regular NTSC OTA or Cable, there is not much content for HDTV so unless you absolutely have to have it for your gaming console (get a life) then just WAIT!
I remember when an IBM PC with an 8080 processor and a couple of floppy disk drives and a monochrome monitor was over $2000, but it was a new market.

FOLKS, the same thing is happening here. By the time HDTV REALLY matures you are going to be stuck with the old technology and you're going to feel burned about how much you spent (you'll probably still be paying it off).

Spending that much or just HAVING to have a 60" screen when suggested viewing distance is (2 X diagonal size) is ridiculous.

At the component level there are so many developments taking place that are going to make your multi-thousand dollar monsters just IBM 8080's in a Multi-core, hyperthreaded, Hypertransport, 64 bit world.

But I thank you ALL for spending your money now so that the companies keep investing in the research so that I can buy my 36-42" HDTV in the future for $300.

Fred Dunn

- Collapse -
(NT) Someone Has To Pay The Price !
Dec 15, 2005 1:57PM PST

Hey guys! What is with all the posts telling everyone to wait. I, myself like to have the latest technology to a certain extent. I absolutely love to watch movies in the comfort of my own home because people have become ridiculously rude in the movie theatre. So, I will pay to have the latest high tech TV and surround sound. I wouldn't pay $300 for an Ipod, but I don't bash the people who do pay $300 for one. Besides, I am sure that you guys know that for the price to drop to 300 dollars for a plasma TV as Fred stated; You have to have people, such as myself, that are willing to shell out the big bucks for the technology now so that it CAN become old technology. It's the old supply and demand game. You know how it goes!! What everyone need to be saying is "Thank You!", to people like myself- As I say to the ones who are buying the Ipod at $300 now so that I may purchase one in the future for $25. So, to those of you who do so- Thank You!!