Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Late term abortions in UK -- for club feet! :-(

May 28, 2006 2:40AM PDT
Babies with club feet aborted

MORE than 20 babies have been aborted in advanced pregnancy because scans showed that they had club feet, a deformity readily corrected by surgery or physiotherapy.

According to figures from the Office for National Statistics covering the years from 1996 to 2004, a further four babies were aborted because they had webbed fingers or extra digits, which are also corrected by simple surgery. All the terminations took place late in pregnancy, after 20 weeks.

Last year, according to campaigners, a healthy baby was aborted in the sixth month at a hospital in southeast England after ultrasound images indicated part of its foot was missing.

News of the terminations has reignited the debate over how scanning and gene technology may enable the creation of ?designer babies?. In 2002 it emerged that a baby had been aborted late ? at 28 weeks ? after scans found that it had a cleft palate, another readily corrected condition. ...


How this is knowingly tolerated is beyond me Sad

Evie Happy

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Horrible, repulsive and tear jerking. :-(
May 28, 2006 11:13AM PDT

My own son had a birth defect that required several surgeries. It was painful to put him through these and he still has visible scaring. He's never said he was sorry to have been born and we'd never have considered ending his life because he was not physically perfect. He was wonderful as a child and is now a young adult soon to be on his own. I know plenty of "pretty people" that.....well...never mind....you probably are ahead of me. Happy

- Collapse -
What also bothers me ...
May 28, 2006 7:42PM PDT

... is that in the overall scheme of things, the US has more liberal abortion laws than the UK and other European countries. If this is happening there, I shudder to think of the scope on which it occurs here.

Evie Happy

- Collapse -
My own view must be that abortion
May 28, 2006 9:05PM PDT

needs to be avoided. Certainly there are cases when medical necessity dictates that it should be, at least, considered. My big problem with our current law is that, those favoring the choice of abortion were given pretty much the whole enchilada. As a male, I must feel some indignity that men are kept completely out of the decision making process in all cases. Consider a case where a man and wife will be ending a marriage but she is pregnant. If she wants to terminate the pregnancy as part of the divorce she is free to do so even if her husband wants the child and is willing to take it and full financial responsibility. Yes, she would have to go through with L & D and the associated risks. But this is no change from the same risk taken when they slept together. I cannot reconcile this at all. Of course there are many other possible scenarios where having a child in the womb is not convenient or desired at all. Of course modern medicine has given us the ability to know much more about a growing fetus including gender and general health. It's also provided, in some cases, important life saving information. Some corrective surgery is even performed prior to birth. But to use modern techniques solely for the purpose of determining whether or not the child meets the parents ideals for what is worthy of continuing the pregnancy to term is, to me, an abuse of respect for human life.

- Collapse -
It's a terrible thing to do
May 28, 2006 9:25PM PDT

but it is rare and probably from those that would abort for brown eyes if they wanted blue if they could see the eye color in the womb. 600-700 are born per year with club feet. Taking the lower number we are talking about 4800 babies in eight years and only 20 were aborted because of this. The others are less than ten all together in eight years.

Let's get some perspective - these people probably shouldn't be parents anyway - we're talking about .4% or less of the kids that are born with club feet.

Diana

- Collapse -
Not sure of your position
May 28, 2006 11:43PM PDT

Is it ok or not?

- Collapse -
So ...
May 29, 2006 1:08AM PDT

... as long as we keep the numbers low, it's acceptable? What quota limit should we put on this before it becomes of concern?

No matter the percentage, we are talking about TWENTY lives snuffed out Sad