whether the child is ready for school and education, it's about her mom's "right" to free public daycare/babysitting
Given this story about the handcuffed 5-year old, I am curious about what Kindergarten is like these days. It seems to me that if this is a behavior pattern for this kid, she's NOT READY for school. Has day care so transformed us that the notion of keeping a kid home an extra year until they are ready is passe? My brother was almost one of them but they gave it a shot and he managed. A friend of mine's son was held out of Kindergarten for a year and he coped much better. Later he probably should have skipped forward that year, as once his behavior settled down he was advanced even for his age, let alone the one-year younger group he was with. But he probably would have forever been a behavior problem (or more likely so) had he been put in a situation he wasn't ready for.
I didn't go to nursery school -- only about half of my neighbors/eventual friends did. There really wasn't day care as we know it back then either. My parents had to write a little note to the teacher about how I was ready for Kindergarten (Mom gave me that note recently - neat thing to have
). We only had half days back then. I know full days were discussed in several districts, has this become the norm? We had a wooden "jungle gym" right there in the classroom. We each had a cubby for our stuff -- that included a towel or mat for "nap time". I'm straining to remember if we had desks -- if we did, I have far more memories of us sitting in circles on the floor, and at least half of our class was PLAY. Most of the stuff we learned wasn't heavy on academics. We had a class pet guinea pig that a lucky kid got to take home each weekend to look after. We had teacher aides in the form of parents that volunteered to help out at times. I remember Mom doing this.
My babysitting days are long behind me and I don't have kids of my own, but I can relate to what a "regular" 5-year old is capable of, and that not all 5-year olds are alike! I guess the question is whether it is even considered anymore if a kid is ready for school. This kid may well be one that isn't ready, although she might be a bad example in that more time with Mom may not do the trick. I guess I wonder if we don't expect too much from all 5-year olds these days?
Evie ![]()

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic