Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Kamikaze Kars

Jan 31, 2010 11:01PM PST

Anyone here driving one of these type of cars? Hard to believe Toyota wasn't more on top of this. What happened to this one family, and the driver a police officer, is horrible. Do people panic and forget to turn the key off or forget there's an emergency brake? These cars remind me of those planes WW2 pilots were sent off in, never expected to return.
=======================================
LINK

The 911 call came at 6:35 p.m. on Aug. 28 from a car that was speeding out of control on Highway 125 near San Diego.

The caller, a male voice, was panic-stricken: ?We?re in a Lexus ... we?re going north on 125 and our accelerator is stuck ... we?re in trouble ... there?s no brakes ... we?re approaching the intersection ... hold on ... hold on and pray ... pray ...?

The call ended with the sound of a crash.

The Lexus ES 350 sedan, made by Toyota, had hit a sport utility vehicle, careened through a fence, rolled over and burst into flames. All four people inside were killed: the driver, Mark Saylor, an off-duty California Highway Patrol officer, and his wife, daughter and brother-in-law.

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Toyota Prius Brakes
Feb 2, 2010 5:03PM PST

when it rains, it pours. The chips are sure falling the wrong way for Toyota lately.

=============================
http://finance.yahoo.com/news/Toyota-hit-by-over-100-Prius-apf-61349718.html?x=0&sec=topStories&pos=2&asset=&ccode=

Toyota Motor Corp. has been hit by over 100 complaints in the U.S. and Japan about brake problems with the popular Prius hybrid, the latest in a spate of quality troubles for the automaker as it grapples with massive global recalls.

The U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has received about 100 complaints involving the brakes of the Prius new model. Two involved crashes resulting in injuries.

Japan's transport ministry said Wednesday it has also received 14 complaints since July last year about brake problems with Toyota's new Prius hybrid.

The 14 complaints included an accident in July 2009, in which a Prius crashed head on into another car at an intersection.

- Collapse -
Apple founder complaining now too.
Feb 2, 2010 10:38PM PST

the other "Steve", as in Wozniak. This is odd, since he's complaining that his Prius, built in Japan, is experiencing acceleration problems too. This begins to look more and more like some sort of computer problem, or electromagnetic interference from some source (cellphones?) on these vehicles. Also, I mentioned "bad caps" on motherboards starting around 2005, and those ended up not just in desktop and laptop computers but in many other items too, probably automotive computer systems. I wonder if some of the problems we see developing now could be due to that. Although most of the bad capacitors were Taiwanese, there were some Japanese produced bad caps too.

That's one reason my current motherboard is a Gigabyte all solid capacitor MA785G-UD3H.

http://www.cnbc.com/id/35202321/site/14081545?__source=yahoo|headline|quote|text|&par=yahoo

Toyota has always maintained there's no problem with the Prius.

Now Japan's Ministry of Transportation wants to make sure the gas-electric hybrid is safe. It's ordering Toyota to investigate a rash of complaints about braking problems with the Prius. Here in the U.S., the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has received 102 complaints. Among those now questioning their Prius is Apple co-founder Steve Wozniak. He says his Prius unintentionally accelerates. If it does unintentionally accelerate like millions of other Toyota's, it creates an even bigger headache for the Japanese automaker. The recall for faulty gas pedals has focused on models built in North America. Cars and trucks build in Japan have been cleared by Toyota. That would change if the Prius models were found to unintentionally accelerate. That's because Toyota builds the Prius in Japan.

- Collapse -
How can this be written?
Feb 2, 2010 11:13PM PST
"If it does unintentionally accelerate like millions of other Toyota's,...." (underline is mine)

Is there evidence that this problem occurs in the million of Toyotas? Not heard that yet. You can't even be on the highway without seeing one of these cars. You'd think they'd all be whizzing by with drivers having mouth agape and bulging eyeballs. This has to be made up.
- Collapse -
Wozniak may have ulterior motive
Feb 2, 2010 11:27PM PST

Seems he's on the hook for speeding in his Prius. Something starting to not pass the smell test for him.
=============================

http://www.cnbc.com/id/35216106
Steve Wozniak is no stranger to lead-foot syndrome. He was famously pulled over for speeding when authorities clocked his Prius at 105mph, and slapped with a $700 fine for his efforts. I have detailed Woz's mobile mania, from his speeding tickets to his almost obsessive love of his fleet of Segways. Woz has joined the chorus over Toyota's sudden acceleration issues and those sticky gas pedals that are dominating the media discourse nowadays. Woz reportedly says his 2010 Prius can unintentionally accelerate to as much as 97mph when he's on cruise control. I'll try to reach Woz later this morning to see if he wants to re-open his traffic cases with this "new evidence" and a new defense.

- Collapse -
Not sure how to interpret this
Feb 2, 2010 11:47PM PST
"Woz reportedly says his 2010 Prius can unintentionally accelerate to as much as 97mph when he's on cruise control.

My Dodge might do the same...if I'm cresting a hill at 95.

I don't think this is going to beat too many speeding tickets. Wink
- Collapse -
you just know...
Feb 2, 2010 11:54PM PST

...everyone with a speeding ticket in the past couple years in a Toyota will be trying to get it overturned. Just remember to tell the officer at the time, "It just took off on me!" or probably will be tossed, if not laughed out of court.

- Collapse -
NHTSA "Park Those Cars", Looking toward onboard computers.
Feb 3, 2010 12:21AM PST

LaHood is going to call the CEO of Toyota. Seems there's a growing discord between NHTSA and Toyota. Also more pressure about the onboard computers, which Toyota continues to insist has no connection to the problem. That mats are a known problem, some gas pedals are known problem, what's unknown is if that's all there is to this or if there's more.

==============================
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/04/business/global/04toyota.html?partner=yahoofinance

Ray LaHood, the transportation secretary, said Wednesday morning during a House Appropriations panel hearing that owners of recalled Toyotas should stop driving them and take them to their dealers to be repaired. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration ?is not finished with this safety issue involving Toyota,? he said, explaining that the department would look into the possibility of electromagnetic interference with the accelerator system.

?I think at the department, we will continue to look at the electronics, continue to study that, continue to work with Toyota on that, and then make a judgment about that,? Mr. LaHood said.

Representatives Henry A. Waxman and Bart Stupak asked the automaker to provide documents showing that the computer systems on its cars were not at fault ? something Toyota has vigorously denied.

- Collapse -
What's next.......Blaming Toyota for potato famine ?..
Feb 3, 2010 2:47AM PST

I'm trying to figure what LaHood's agenda(if any)is.They're coming out of the woodwork on this one Happy

I've been a Toyota master tech for over 20yrs and I've seen it all.I've been to the regional headquarters with other master techs to be instructed on the current "fix".I can say this,no tech in the entire NY region has ever seen or been able to confirm a case of unintended acceleration.Sure,we've all seen the occasional driver nail the gas instead of the brakes,cream the car and say the car "took off"(much like Woz transferring the blame for his speeding tickets).

Toyota's attention to detail in the current concern is exemplary.We take our jobs quite seriously and are required to check even the "JT" vehicles with our laptop scanners.We must supply Toyota with printouts of the live and monitor data of the 15-20 computer systems in every vehicle,no exceptions.

I don't know enough about the alleged Prius complaint to comment but I'm quite familiar with how the braking system works.Much of the braking force you feel when stopping a Prius is not the brakes themselves but the 2 motors in the transaxle slowing the car.The car's brakes take over at the very last moment to stop the car,the "pedal feel" is built in to fool you.This is why the brake pads on a Prius will last well over 100K before replacement!

There are redundant systems built in,the system would set a code if there was any type of "interference".No,cell phones are not a concern for interference in the Prius.The system has no alternator,it has an invertor/convertor that supplies the 12V systems and works off the 288V main battery and charges the 12V aux batt.

There is a very small window where it switches from regen braking to the mechanical brakes.

- Collapse -
(NT) Already been retracted
Feb 3, 2010 3:42AM PST
- Collapse -
sure enough
Feb 3, 2010 8:24AM PST

About time someone in this runaway administration of Czars got called on the carpet for over aggression and running off at the mouth. They all seem intent on seeing who can talk the toughest. Of course the consumer is concerned with safety, so everything beyond that is politics as usual.

- Collapse -
Wall Street Journal Urges Sale of Toyota Stock
Feb 4, 2010 12:49AM PST

Not good for Toyota. It trades in the US under the ticker "TM".
http://finance.yahoo.com/q/bc?s=TM&t=5d
It looks like there's been heavy sales volume in the past two days already. If they get some good news in a few weeks it might be a stock worth jumping back into.

Wall Street Journal story

Do you want to sleep peacefully at night without worrying about a stock? Then avoid -- or sell -- Toyota Motor shares.

Toyota has a full-blown crisis on its hands. As has been widely reported, sticking gas pedals and potentially dangerous floor mats caused Toyota to recall 5.3 million vehicles since last fall, including some of its most popular models. The floor-mat problem led the company to call back models from its high-end Lexus brand, hitherto renowned for quality and reliability. These incidents alone would warrant investor caution. But the problem has been compounded by a long-delayed and less-than-reassuring response from Toyota.

This strikes me as more than a mechanical issue, albeit one potentially affecting millions of vehicles. Toyota's credibility is also on the line. The damage to Toyota's reputation is incalculable. The damage to its brands isn't: That's apparent in the weak January sales figures Toyota released Tuesday.

Toyota shares were over $90 as recently as Jan. 19. They closed Tuesday at $78.18, which strikes me as a modest decline under the circumstances. If I owned shares, I'd seize the chance to get out. Toyota has a vast infrastructure and a long history of quality and innovation. But its floor-mat and gas-pedal nightmares are likely just beginning. (more in article)

- Collapse -
Well, I'm not a member of the investor class but
Feb 4, 2010 3:07AM PST

if I was and had stock in Toyota, I'd hold it. If I had none, I'd start buying some soon. My wife has a 2000 Camry that, besides oil changes, brakes, tires and other general maintenance items has only been in the shop for one problem...a faulty oxygen sensor that caused no driving problems. Except for the way she junks up the interior with all her school crap, the car cleans up to almost immaculate condition. A few scratches but no rust in 10 years...and still has the original exhaust. To me this speaks well of what Toyota can do but perhaps, like in most manufacturing segments, some quality has been sacrificed over the decade. I'd trust Toyota to bounce back quickly. We'll consider another one, I'm sure. I bought Corollas for my kids to use in College and have had only one problem. A starter died on the first one...a '96 we bought used. I replaced it myself for about 100 bucks. Unfortunately, my daughter totaled it while driving in the rain or we might still have it. It was replaced with an '05 that hasn't had a hiccup in almost 5 years.

There was a day when I said I'd never have a Japanese car as the first ones I remember weren't good at all. They drove like buckboards and rusted quickly in northern winters from road salt corrosion. Toyota fixed all of that while people buying from Detroit were still relying on Ziebart and Rusty Jones in the aftermarket. I think they'll be ok.

- Collapse -
Balderdash!
Feb 4, 2010 3:10AM PST

Toyota will regain the confidence it earned over the years.

And it is smart to ride out the ups and downs.

if enough people sell, there will be enough people who realize the recalls were not that common for Toyota, so will buy the stock while it is low.

Angeline

- Collapse -
Toyota doing a bad job with recall
Feb 4, 2010 6:16AM PST

I bought a 2010 Corrolla and when I call the dealership they keep telling me that I'm unable to bring my car in for the fix. Toyota is not handling this recall very well. Obviously, I know all you have to do is throw the thing into neutral but I want the piece on the pedal just in case.

- Collapse -
I think they're doing the best possible
Feb 4, 2010 7:40AM PST

but nothing happens instantly. Consider that it's only been just recently that the H1N1 vaccine has been readily available but we've been hearing about it since last Fall. From the time the pedal problem was isolated to when the redesign "fix" was determined was quite short in comparison. Consider that the manufacturer of the part has to tool up to produce a massive number of replacement parts is nothing that happens overnight and, if it does, the quality of replacement parts will be suspect. If it's just a mechanical problem with the pedal, just take it easy with the accelerator for the time being and you should be ok. The news media wants us to panic. They enjoy the ability to do that. I'd rather take away their fun. Drive sensibly and be patient.

- Collapse -
I'm waiting to see...
Feb 4, 2010 11:00AM PST
- Collapse -
I hate that I feel this way but a whistle blowing
Feb 4, 2010 6:26PM PST

lawyer may not be so much about exhibiting ethical behavior as being self serving.

- Collapse -
Ralph Nader to the rescue? Still tilting at windmills.
Feb 4, 2010 10:55PM PST

And here he comes, riding in on his old nag, (got no car) wild hair to the four winds, reliving glory days long gone by, leveling his rusty lance at Toyota and proclaiming, "?Toyota dropped the ball -- too little, too late, It was an unseemly coverup.? About NHTSA, "?They?re not supported by the White House over the years, They didn?t have enough data, enough analysis to catch this problem....Over the years, most manufacturers have had problems with sudden acceleration,??


http://www.businessweek.com/news/2010-02-04/nader-accuses-toyota-of-unseemly-coverup-in-vehicle-recalls.html

- Collapse -
I wonder why Ralph doesn't drive...
Feb 4, 2010 11:34PM PST

Could it be that, every time he approaches an automobile dealership, he sees the lights go out, blinds drop and a "Closed" sign suddenly on the front door? Wink

- Collapse -
I also wonder about Ralphie......
Feb 5, 2010 12:32AM PST

"he served 6months in The Army in 1959"

Trying to find any info on Nader's illustrious military career is like trying to find obama's senior thesis,it ain't out there.Either that or it's where I can't find it Happy

I wonder if the clown has "bad paper".

- Collapse -
Prius recall for brakes issued.
Feb 8, 2010 5:35PM PST

This one's been in the works for awhile, surprised it took this long to do the recall. Basic problems seems the regenerative braking system that uses the car's charging system for also braking, maybe in similar manner "gearing down" is done in older cars, works only to a point when standard brakes are supposed to takeover, but have too long a pause between the switchover under some conditions.

This all has impacted Toyota's share price too. It's down below $73 from a recent high near $92. Last March the price was $60, so the stock price might visit that level again before recovering.

http://finance.yahoo.com/news/Toyota-recalls-437000-Priuses-apf-1092884921.html?x=0&sec=topStories&pos=3&asset=&ccode=

TOKYO (AP) -- Toyota says it is recalling about 437,000 Prius and other hybrid vehicles worldwide to fix brake problems -- the latest in a string of embarrassing safety lapses at the world's largest automaker.

"I apologize for causing trouble and worries for many customers over the quality and safety of Toyota," President Akio Toyoda said at a press conference Tuesday in Tokyo.

"We sincerely acknowledge safety concerns from our customers," he said. "We have decided to recall as we regard safety for our customers as our foremost priority."

The recall is the latest blow to Toyota Motor Corp., which is in the midst of recalling more than 7 million vehicles worldwide because of problems with floor mats, which can trap gas pedals, and faulty gas pedals that are slow to return to the idle position.

- Collapse -
Congress attacks NHTSA over Toyota situation.
Feb 10, 2010 3:20AM PST

Congress thinks NHTSA has been too soft on the automotive industry lately and toward Toyota particularly. Looks like problems for Toyota will grow, politically at least.


LINK


"This is the most extensive vehicle recall in history, and we want to know, what did Toyota know about its defects and when did they know it, and what did N.H.T.S.A. know and did it act quickly enough?" Representative Henry A. Waxman, the California Democrat who leads the House Energy and Commerce Committee, said on Tuesday.

Some Congressional officials and outside experts say they believe the safety agency has become too close to the industry it is charged with regulating, as a number of agency employees have gone to work for Toyota. Among other issues that need to be addressed, they also cite the agency's limited use of fines or subpoenas against auto manufacturers, a dearth of technical expertise in areas like electronic throttle problems and frequent turnover in its leadership.

- Collapse -
This is nuts, why make 911 call?
Feb 11, 2010 2:21PM PST

The police aren't gonna be able to do anything for you in time. I am just perplexed why he took the time to take his phone, dial 911 and inform somebody. Screw the call, try the ebrake or neutral. IDK, maybe suicide.

JJ
article marketing

- Collapse -
Agree...
Feb 11, 2010 10:05PM PST

That's why I am suspicious of its authenticity.

- Collapse -
when seconds count...
Feb 11, 2010 11:17PM PST

...the police are only minutes away.

- Collapse -
Recalled. Fixed. Same acceleration problem afterwards.
Mar 3, 2010 7:39AM PST

Looking like besides the rug problem, besides the pedal problem (if that was actually the cause of more than a few) that there may still be yet another problem causing sudden acceleration. My suspicion all along has been some sort of software problem or electronic interference caused by outside sources such as cell phones, passing microwave towers, etc.

So, are all these just panicky people, or is there something more to it? It took awhile to get the right people to listen the first time, I'm betting it won't take so long this time.


http://finance.yahoo.com/news/Govt-still-hearing-complaints-apf-2087001762.html?x=0&sec=topStories&pos=main&asset=&ccode=

March 3, 2010, 6:19 pm

WASHINGTON (AP) -- Some Toyota owners say they're still having trouble with unintended acceleration after their recalled cars were repaired, and the Transportation Department said Wednesday it is looking into their complaints.

The complaints raise new questions about whether Toyota's remedy will solve the problem. David Strickland, the administrator of the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, said in a statement the agency is reaching out to consumers about the complaints "to get to the bottom of the problem and to make sure Toyota is doing everything possible to make its vehicles safe."

"If Toyota owners are still experiencing sudden acceleration incidents after taking their cars to the dealership, we want to know about it," Strickland said.

- Collapse -
Ar eyou familiar with the Kane&Gilbert Hoax ?
Mar 4, 2010 5:25AM PST

When David W. Gilbert testified in front of Congress on 2/24,he manufactured the problem he testified about.A problem that could never happen in the real world,Gilbert is a lying scam artist.

This 8min video rips his congressional testimony down to the lie it was.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G3gQWGZ8uBw

- Collapse -
I'll watch the video.
Mar 4, 2010 6:38AM PST

I've not heard of him. I went back to the article and checked the names in it, including the author. I don't see a Kane or Gilbert. What's the connection?

- Collapse -
OK, I watched it. He's misleading too.
Mar 4, 2010 6:59AM PST

I doubt those 2-3 wires are just waving around singly under the hood. Most times wires are wrapped or put in plastic tubing and it's often likely that wires get bared at the same point because of that. In the past it's been one of the more common ways for shorts to happen, between wires, wrapped next to each other, both impacted by something that knicked or rubbed against them till bare wire was exposed.

Also he'd have us believe this only happens in the wires, but since the wires are coming through a firewall the short could happen at the firewall connections, where once again many wires are all bundled together closely.

His description of the sensor may or not be accurate. I know in past, the cars I've worked on had sensors that had minimum and maximum values which related in the onboard computer to whatever programmed values were in it. Sometimes by totally removing the plug from a sensor, or shorting across the plug, you could achieve either minimum or maximum value.

For example, one of the things most likely to fail on Chrysler products in years past were the MAP sensors (Manifold Absolute Pressure). The car could be driveable or completely disabled unable to keep running although usually able to crank since the MAP didn't kick in until the start cycle was finished. The easiest road repair enabling someone to drive the car to a dealer was to simply disconnect the MAP sensor. The onboard computer either ignored it or set at a middle value and then relied on the other sensors alone. End result is someone could drive the car without advancing the timing too much if they didn't try to accelerate too fast and thereby make it to a service center.

So, does that mean the Toyotas have a problem with the sensor or sensors controlling the throttle and timing, thereby the speed? If the problem can't be found in the computer programming, the sensors should also come under scrutiny, but ONLY on the cars where the problems are reported. For cars without the problem, it makes no sense to look at them to discover it.

Electronic problems are commonly intermittent. Nothing I hated worse in a car than tracking down a short that was intermittent. Some sensors may be messing up intermittently too.

I can't believe all these people are messing up on how they are driving, causing the problem while looking to blame Toyota for it. Some maybe, but I believe the majority of them are honest about it. Trying to blame the victim is not the proper approach.