Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Iwork versus mic. Office

Feb 8, 2011 11:27PM PST

I have always used a pc and will still do so. BUT..I have also gotten my first MacBook pro. I was told to buy the IWork which I did. Now I'm thinking that it might be better to have Office on my new mac. does anyone really know which one is better for me in 2011?

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Your choice?
Feb 9, 2011 3:57AM PST
- Collapse -
There is also
Feb 9, 2011 4:29AM PST

Open Office, which NeoOffice piggybacks off of. Open Office now has a normal Mac interface just like NeoOffice, and doesn't suffer from being a release or two behind.

- Collapse -
That's news!
Feb 9, 2011 9:03AM PST

Nothing better than fitting in.

- Collapse -
and it also depends on just what
Feb 9, 2011 8:55AM PST

you plan to do with Office.

Pages is capable of opening/saving as Word documents
Numbers ditto for Excel documents &
Keynote will do the same for PowerPoint presentations.

Keynote is arguably better than PowerPoint.

What is the drawback with iWork, as you see it?

P

- Collapse -
iwork or office
Feb 9, 2011 11:02PM PST

I don't see any drawback with iwork as I haven't used it. But before installing it in my new macbook pro. I really wanted to make sure I was doing the best for me. Since I've always used office and will continue to do so with my other comp. a pc

- Collapse -
Try this....
Feb 11, 2011 8:52AM PST

No one can tell you what's best for you except you. Here's what I'd suggest. Install iWork and try using it. Any files you create on iWork can also be saved as Office compatible files so you'll not lose any work if you don't like it. If the small differences in the interface makes it too annoying switching back and forth, by all means buy a copy of Office for Mac. But beware, if you wind up liking iWork better.... well there's no iWork for PC.

- Collapse -
Just my opinion
Feb 11, 2011 2:30PM PST

This is just my opinion, but having both loaded onto my iMac (iWork '09 and Office for Mac: 200Cool I find I like each for different things.

For example, I prefer Pages for simple letter writing or creating specialty documents (like brochures, cards, etc.), but I always turn to Word for heavy-duty work processing capabilities, in particular mail merge.

Number is fine, but coming from an accounting background there is no replacement for Excel. It is the best spreadsheet program out there. Period. If you need that sort of thing I can't recommend Excel too highly.

Ultimately I'm certain you can work with either iWork or Office. Or the various free options like Google Docs, OpenOffice or NeoOffice.

Oh, one thing I do really like about Pages is how you can Save As documents as PDFs. I have found this to be very handy when I know I'm going to need to share a document with another party. They do not have to have installed anything other than Adobe Reader.

- Collapse -
Yes, Excel is still the best
Feb 11, 2011 3:34PM PST

Yes I wholeheartedly agree. I have used Excel for many years and I think it's easily the best. I have iWork 09 but am waiting for Office for Mac. I may have another try at Numbers at a later stage to master it but to get it to eg simply print a selection from a sheet was frustrating. I also have the Open Office Spreadsheet program (v 3.2.1) but it is a poor cousin to Excel. The other thing is that I'm sharing spreadsheet documents with PC users and it's easier if I have Excel too.

I also like Pages for the reasons you outlined and use it more frequently than Word (ie Open Office version) now.

As an aside I really am glad I am now a Mac user after many years of Windows. My experience with Macs has been overall very good.

- Collapse -
You know that you can do that with any document or graphic
Feb 11, 2011 9:56PM PST

in any program on your Mac.

If fact you can make a PDF of anything that you can print, just select the option in the Print Dialog box


P

- Collapse -
With the new app store
Feb 11, 2011 5:32PM PST

I have both office and iWork on my iMac, but with the new App store on Snow Leopard, it is easier to buy just the programme, i.e Keynotes that you use.

I love keynotes and Pages is okay but for doing more complex graphs and other functions Numbers seriously lets it self down, the reason I went out and bought Office.

So on my Macbook Air I didn't originally buy iWorks but I have Office as mine has three licensees with it. i have now bought Keynotes through the App store as at

- Collapse -
iWork
Feb 12, 2011 7:58AM PST

I like Keynote very much. I use PowerPoint (on a PC) at work and much prefer Keynote at home. I find it easier to create attractive presentations with nice transitions. Keynote also has a number of useful export formats. Pages works well, especially, the layout mode. I use MS Word so much at work that I am more comfortable using that for word processing on my Mac. Numbers has some very interesting capabilities that Excel lacks, in terms of easily creating attractive pages that contain multiple spreadsheets or graphs. I am not sure that those capabilities are tremendously valuable in the real world, though. In the end, I would have stuck with iWork, until my employer connected me with a copy of MS Office for almost no money. (They let all employees buy Office very cheaply so that we can do work on our home computers.) I think you will be happy with either one once you spend a little time with it.

Dave