Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Is Sony HDR-SR5 compatable with Vista

Nov 9, 2007 1:52PM PST

I have windows vista Home Premium 32 bit version with an Intel

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Your computer might have an issue with the AVCHD, but
Nov 9, 2007 10:08PM PST

You need to provide more details such as RAM and total Hard Drive space. Since HD (High Def) video takes a huge amount of storage space, you need to make sure you have enough. Because of the processor, I see you have a laptop. How much space is on that laptop? AVCHD (the format in which High Def video is recorded with HDD/DVD/Flash camcorders) requires a lot of processing power and RAM, so your experience with AVCHD might not be "fast".

Another thing, you won't be able to get the High Def video onto your TV unless 1) you buy a BluRay (High Def DVD) player or 2) you connect the camcorder directly to the TV. This is because the HD video will not fit on a standard DVD or work on a standard DVD player.

Also, you will need video editing software in order to edit the AVCHD video that specifically supports the AVCHD format. There are plenty of choices now from ~$50 to $500+. Remember, the included software is BASIC, at best, but it will allow you to view the HD video on your computer and make a standard definition DVD for your DVD player.

If this seems like too much of a hassle, there are other options such as HDV (tape-based). Just remember that HD tape camcorders can take as much as 30GB of hard drive space for each HOUR of recording. A kind suggestion: For any camcorder you decide, buy an external hard drive along with it.

- Collapse -
The other thing that *could* be done
Nov 10, 2007 1:14AM PST

is to use that camcorder using standard definition (4:3 or 16:9) DV - that way, AVCHD compression is not applied... sort of defeats the purpose of getting a hidef camcorder (that compreses using AVCHD), but should bridge the gap until AVCHD decoding is a bit better...

The external hard drive for video projects is always a good idea. Though Firewire connectivity is recommended...

- Collapse -
HD camcorders compatibility with Vista
Nov 10, 2007 3:55AM PST

Thank you Whizkid for your response. The laptop have 1 GB Ram, 250GB of hard disk space.I am worried much about the space of the laptop hard disk the videos will copied to a DVD once transfered to the disk hard drive. As far as the software, Ulead movie factory software is oreinstalled on the laptop. Not sure if it will do the job editing Videos taken on the HD camcorder.
Hope this info is sufficient to address my issue in deciding on whether to purchase the camcorder.

- Collapse -
I'm thinking maybe a more basic camcorder?
Nov 10, 2007 4:29AM PST

The laptop has plenty of storage space, but the processor and RAM might give you "more than expected" editing time. Burning to DVD is another thing. If you record in high definition, that video will be downconverted to standard definition to fit onto the DVD. Usually, those pre-installed programs don't allow full functionality. Also, it most likely won't support AVCHD.

Have you tried looking at other standard definition camcorders? They will be less taxing on your laptop and will take up less space. Plus, they are most likely compatible with the Ulead software and easier to burn onto a DVD.

Do you want to stay with HDD camcorders, or are tape camcorders a possibility as well?

- Collapse -
The DVD burning software will downsample to
Nov 10, 2007 9:00AM PST

standard definition because if the DVD burner is not a HD-DVD burner or BluRay burner, the DVD drive does not understand how to burn that format.

If the computer is a new Sony with the optional BluRay burner, then there is most likely BluRay DVD authoring software to burn the BluRay DVD - and you would need to use either the laptop or a BluRay DVD player connected to your HDTV in order to watch in HD...

BluRay discs are not cheap... but they are getting there...
http://shop2.outpost.com/product/4863470;jsessionid=ocwTZH4HhP69LnXCkw8rFA**.node3?site=sr:SEARCH:MAIN_RSLT_PG

- Collapse -
Leaving Hi Def for later
Nov 14, 2007 8:20AM PST

Thank you for all your answers. I guess I will stay away from Hi Def at the time being. Again Thank you also goes to WhizKid