Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

Resolved Question

iMovie 11 and HDV

Dec 14, 2013 6:13AM PST

Looking at the apple.com site for compatible cameras, I don't find this one that I am considering buying, listed: Sony HVR-V1U. Included is a 60Gb hard drive that mounts on the camera, so I need not use it as a tape-based camera. But I am worried that these formats: HDV/DVCAM/DV - might not be compatible with iMovie! Any comments?

Discussion is locked

bwanadave has chosen the best answer to their question. View answer

Best Answer

- Collapse -
You did not tell us which Mac.
Dec 14, 2013 12:36PM PST

If you use digital tape, then connect the camcorder's i.LINK (firewire, IEEE1394, DV) port to the Mac's Firewire port. It the Mac has no firewire port, hopefully it has a Thunderbolt port. Apple has a Thunderbolt to firewire adapter tail that works great.

The optional HVRDR60 external hard drive unit connects to the camcorder's DV port, too. And the HVRDR60 connects to the computer's firewire port, too. Since we don't know which Mac, we don't know which firewire cable(s) you need.

When importing to iMovie:

CAMCORDER OFF.
Connect the camcorder's firewire port to the Mac's firewire port.
If the Mac is not already on, now is a fine time to power it up.
When the computer is at a stable desktop, power up the camcorder and place into Play/Edit mode.
Launch iMovie.
Under File, select import or Capture...

or...

Download and read the manual for the HVRDR60:
http://pro.sony.com/bbsc/ssr/cat-broadcastcameras/cat-hdv/product-HVRDR60/

HVRDR60 OFF.
Connect the HVRDR60's firewire port to the Mac's firewire port.
If the Mac is not already on, now is a fine time to power it up.
When the computer is at a stable desktop, power up the HVRDR60 and place into Computer mode (see page 19).
Launch iMovie.
Under File, select import or Capture... You can also choose to copy the M2T files to the Mac, transcode them with something like Mpeg Streamclip from www.squared5.com or HandBrake from www.handbrake.fr.

NOTE: Refer to pages 6 and 27. There is no USB port on the HVRDR60. Only i.LINK which is Sony's implementation of firewire/IEEE1394.

We assume you have set the HVR-V1 recording format to DV or HDV - iMovie can deal with both. I don't think iMovie understands Standard definition DVCAM format video. Final Cut does.

If your Mac has no firewire or Thunderbolt port, you will have some extreme challenges. There is no firewire-to-USB converter/adapter/cable that will work (this is not Mac specific - Windows has the same issue).

In this case, some sort of external box from Blackmagic Design can work... but we can stop here until we know which Mac you are using.

Yes, I use Macs for video editing. (I've used Windows computers, too.) Yes, I use the Thunderbolt-firewire adapter tail (~$30 from the Apple Store or Fry's Electronics - among other distributors.) Yes, I have iMovie 11 and have imported video from my HDR-FX1 and HDR-HC1 among many other Sony, Panasonic and Canon camcorders. I now regularly use Final Cut...

- Collapse -
Thanks for the Thoughtful Response
Dec 14, 2013 10:19PM PST

I used FCP from its inception to make marketing videos - but in my 'senior' years, I have been able to do what I need to with iMovie. The camera I am considering is a lightly-used HVR-V1U to replace my Canon GL1 and the HDR-HC7 that I have borrowed from my son. Your reply erases any concerns I had. My Mac is a 2012 iMac with Thunderbolt and I do have the firewire adapter. Thanks so much!

- Collapse -
my pleasure...
Dec 14, 2013 10:33PM PST

Heads up on the V1U - though you probably already know. As I recall, it is the pro version of the HDR-FX7. The FX7 has a built-in stereo mic and a 1/8" stereo audio input (so a XLR adapter is needed to XLR mics), but the V1U's XLR connectivity (and audio controls) replaced the built-in mics so you must use external XLR mics. Remember, no DVCAM with iMovie. If standard def is needed, then DV (not DVCAM). HDV is preferred and iMovie will be fine with that.

- Collapse -
The Mic
Dec 15, 2013 1:28AM PST

Included with the camera is this - ECM-XM1 Shotgun Microphone w/windscreen.
Couple of good batteries and a firewire.. but I have all the firewires already.
And the adapter, as noted above.

- Collapse -
Answer
I don't ask apple.
Dec 14, 2013 6:17AM PST

I head to the camcorder maker's site to see if they list apple compatibility or what apps or software is required.
Bob