Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

I like my ME !!! Its so stable

Jun 12, 2006 11:44AM PDT

Me was fine if you knew what you were doing.

I love my ME version, no issues with activation and spyware, Its faster than Xp, OK drivers could be an issue for some, But I have never had an issue.

I love ME and see no reason to change it, But with a Piii 700 Mhz, I would not be wiling to let XP anywhere near it.

Its very well firewalled (2 layers) and its not my net box (but none of those are windows anyway)

ME ROcKS .. Its what 98SE should have been

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Posted because Tom said ME was bad.
Jun 12, 2006 11:47AM PDT

I missed this line, But ME was only bad if you didn't treat it right.

I suffered with 98, I Am Suffering with Xp, but all my ME Boxes are really nice to use, fast and featured.

"Hey Tom, Leave ME alone" ... with appologies to Pink Floyd and the brick in the wall song.

- Collapse -
ME is NOT good
Jun 12, 2006 12:22PM PDT

Yeah it isnt. I had a WinME, and out of the blue, the computer doesn't boot. Took me months to figure it out. Apparently something was buggy with the installation CD. I tried to reinstall it, but it gave me an error at like 87%! When it crashed, it read an invalid boot diskette in Drive A, yet there was no disk in drive A. I fixed it (eventually), but there was no computer I could use for a month. WinXP is WAY better

- Collapse -
XP has its own issues.
Jun 12, 2006 1:27PM PDT

I'm looking at 2 boxes right now that are running ME, and one laptop too.

The laptop becasue its only a 233Mhz and XP would be a pig.

The Destops are 1Ghz athlons with 512Meg of ram They at one time had XP for trial but as soon as SP2 was installed they crashed.

Windows Blamed the Bios, The manufacturer blamed windows. We installed ME again and they have run fine ever since.

They will be migrated to Linux soonwhere they will have their cycles added to the cinerella farm, but as ME boxes they ran just fine. One does all day video captures for work and the other is used for Displaying the video as well as entering information dialogs into the timestamped video. And they do all this with low resources. The hard drives are hot swappable with USB-IDE interfaces and the uptimes are measured in months. (XP has more patch reboots)

The Athlon XP1600 running windows XP needed more memory and scalled down video resolutions to do the same job. XP was a lot more bloated than ME ever was. .. Its just getting old and unsupported. But with enough memory it was fast and stable.

I still think ME was a pretty good version. Even if I retired the IBM K6-2 500 which I had used for years here. (its now in a homework centre for Kids ... Yep Still running Windows ME without issues)

- Collapse -
I've used it successfully.
Jun 12, 2006 1:02PM PDT

So many people have complained about ME and normally, I would jump on the bandwagon and fuss about MS too (I'm a Linux junkie) but honestly, I have sucessfully deployed 3 Windows ME workstations. If you had anti-virus software, anti-spyware software, used an alternative browser, firewalled it with software and a hardware firewall...it ran rather well.

With that said, when I first got ME and DID NOT have all those things installed, it was a pain in the rear!

- Collapse -
Yep I had an ME machine, It was ok too
Jun 12, 2006 7:07PM PDT

Cant ever recall having a lot of issues with it. From memory it was a bit slow when I first got it, but after a memory upgrade and a couple of Microsoft patch downloads it went just fine

I think most of its issues were IE based and when either 5.5 or 6 came out it got fixed.

Anyway it worked for me until I brought the mac.

- Collapse -
I feel sorry for you...
Jun 12, 2006 1:36PM PDT

Really. 2k all the way!

I used it a little while ago, and I had to beg my dad to let me upgrade.

Anyway, by then I had found out how good Linux really was, and was using Ubuntu as my main OS. I still installed 2000 for when I -needed- to use Windows, but I can tell you, WinME is horrible. (It had bugs as soon as I installed it, explorer.exe continually crashed and it wasn't a virus etc.)

- Collapse -
You would love our Linux Farm
Jun 12, 2006 2:44PM PDT

I wish I could show you our rendering farm. All Linux and so fast it makes even our hardiest Mac geeks heads swim. But I cant give any details on it. Or on what its doing right now. But we are in NZ .. so think.

For the record, I am a slacker all the way (Thats Slackware Linux for you "non-linux peoples") But I am partial to a little SUSE on my desktops too.

I use Linux or OSX (which gives me native Unix terminals when I need to SSH to another box) for all my personal on-line stuff. Sadly we sometimes need windows, and I get paid to support all the machines - Which means Fixing broken windows all day.

Ironically most spyware and virus no longer support Win 98 and ME so they give me a lot less trouble, Even the ones in the Lunchrooms which are pretty insecure, by our standards. Add to that our Firewalls, seperated networks and Very high level of security at work and we are probably not your normal PC users.

I used to work in the military, and the securiy there was nothing on this lot. I once read how Star Trek movie scripts were specially treated so that leaks could be traced, I thought it was a joke, but I tell you theres real money to be made in security.

and not without reason.

/http://home.nzcity.co.nz/news/default.asp?id=63019

Our paranoia level here just went up a few notches.

As for IE crashes .. When doesn't it .. Firefox it dude. IE is responcible for 60% of all backdoors into PC's. Its the first thing I kill on a win box.

2K is stable, but has much more issues with drivers than does ME. and its never been the most media friendly. Not ideal in a media based workplace.

Fortunately the Boss is a Mac fan all the way, Very creative and very hard on equipment so I have a real fun job and get to travel a lot in summer and work hard indoors in winter.

Very cool life for a geek .. Esp one who loves Gaming or Sci-Fi

- Collapse -
Win2k
Jun 12, 2006 9:57PM PDT

Despite the ridiculously long boot time, I think 2k is the most stable windows release i've used (i'm a coward, i haven't tried linux yet for fear of drivers), I used to be able to tweak it to make it almost impenetrable and with a very small memory footprint.

- Collapse -
My (limited) experience
Jun 12, 2006 6:20PM PDT

I've mostly seen 98 and XP Windows machines in my life, but there have been smatterings of 2000 a few places and one ME machine. I once saw about 10 blue screens within 5 minutes while trying to fix something on the ME machine. That's enough to make me not want to touch the vile pile ever again.

It's about as bad as Mac OS 7.5.2, which crashed every 2 minutes.

-Ryan