Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

htib?

Feb 24, 2006 1:00AM PST

Home theater in a box? I'm sure there is a bunch out there, any recommendations on a brand? Sony, panosonic etc?

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Here are some.
Feb 24, 2006 2:46AM PST
- Collapse -
Help with buying a $200 HTIB system
Feb 26, 2006 11:26AM PST

Here is a something I wrote down earlier - hopefully it can raise some critical questions either to think or someone to answer

Could anyone advice a newbie HTIB buyer?

I am totally newbie to audio, but I would I always would like make an informed decision. I am looking for a home theater system to play DVD's (maybe hook up to computer and do HDTV in the future)that costs MAX $250. I did all the research I could in the internet and am considering the following. If anyone knows anything about particular model or even the brand in general I'd love to hear your advice. I am considering:

Samsung HT-WP38, $200, 800W (I really don't need the DVD player, as I have on already, and I don;t know if samsung is as good in audio as it is in TVs , but the wireless speakers and usb port are welcome. On the other hand, it only has optical digital input, no coax digital input - is that a problem?)

Pioneer HTP-2500,$200, 1000W (lots of wats, but I don't need loud music. Pricey considering it doesn't have wireless rear speakers [has pre out puts, what ever that means])

SONY HT-DDW670, $159 600W (Good price)

Panasonic SC-HT05 , $150 (claims to have 1% THD, when other systems have 10%. How is that possible, when they compete in same price (=cost)range? Also , the amp is in the subwooofer, where as the other systems have the amp in the receiver)

or Logitech Z-5450, $250, 300w (THX certified - does that really mean anything except that the price is higher because of the cost? This is supposed to be a computer system, will it be enough for a 250sq ft room? Am I over paying because it targets a computer gamer niche?)

Thanks for any help, and let me know where to post this if I posted this to the wrong place.

- Collapse -
Help with buying a $200 HTIB system
Feb 27, 2006 3:20AM PST

No $200~250 system is going to have 400~1000 wats!!!!! That figure is just bull feathers!!!! Meaningless it is.
Go for the that says 1% THD or less.
Are you hooking up to a PC or a TV????
Yes the THX does mean something, most likly the better unit. John

- Collapse -
you're wrong!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Feb 27, 2006 7:27AM PST

hair dryers have 1000+ watts. and since wattage is the only thing that matters in a receiver, i'll just plug some speakers into it so i can get the best sound possible.

- Collapse -
Apples and oranges. . .
Feb 27, 2006 10:58AM PST

You can't compare wattage between a hair dryer that USES a thousand watts, and a stereo system that DELIVERS a thousand watts. Hair dryers are using current with an input of 110-115 VAC at 60 Hz, and use the built in resistance measured in Kilo-Ohms. Receiver amplifiers deliver power with a frequency range of ~20-20,000 Hz to a device with an impedance of between 4 and 8 Ohms; the speakers. The sub-woofer receives an input measured in micro-volts called pre-amp.

Do some homework before you post such an absurd statement.

- Collapse -
(NT) (NT) lol, it was sarcasm.
Feb 27, 2006 1:19PM PST
- Collapse -
(NT) (NT) Oooooo, sorry.
Feb 27, 2006 8:09PM PST
- Collapse -
Yes, but it gave me an chance to,,,,,,
Feb 28, 2006 1:22AM PST

Give a basic lession in electricty. John

- Collapse -
you're wrong!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!,,,maybe not!!!!!!
Feb 28, 2006 1:19AM PST

Lets think about this,,,, Yes a hair dryer will use 1200watts. Ohm's law for watts is,, voltage x current(amps)= watts. For a hair dryer to have 1200 watts at 120volts it will take 10 apms of current.
This appiles for ALL electrical usage!!!!!
For a reciver to have a 1000w output it will take 8.3amps at 120v.

Now all electrical equptiment will have lable on the back of the unit stating how many watts the unit uses.
This question came up about a year ago. A Sony unit was calming 1000w. But when I checked out the specs on the Sony web site,,, the unit was rated as 245w of power usage!!! So the unit output 4 times more power than it takes in???? Not going to happen!!!!
You CAN NOT HAVE MORE OUTPUT POWER THAN YOU TAKE FROM THE LINE!!!! Usualy it is less!!!!

The FTC came up with a set of rules for amp power ratings, this is ingorned by most makers of consumer amps/ Recivers.
So check out some of thoes units,,, compaire the wattage rating on the back of the unit with the "claimed wattage output" Sony magic or Sony balony???

- Collapse -
Thanks
Feb 27, 2006 11:33PM PST

Thanks for the advice. As to you question, I am primarily planning to hook up to TV (CRT).