You would have to read the small print to say what it says about data on a hard disk and the property rights on broken parts. What do they say?
It's a good example of what we say here: "You only lose what you don't backup." It's so easy to copy your own new and changed data to a USB-stick or an external hard disk a few times a week, that there is no real excuse for not doing it.
Kees
Having had my shiny new HP laptop only 6 weeks to have a hard drive failure was disappointing, but HP were quick to repair it. The problem comes when you try to recover your data. HP will only give you back the old failed drive if you pay them the full price of a new one. This is clearly just a way for them to make customers pay for their own warranty costs. In reality it will cost HP to dispose of the old drive so they could give it back to their customers and still be better off. They argue that after a warranty repair the old parts belong to them, however they don't own my data which is on the drive. Is that theft?

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic