Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

Question

How is AMD Radeon R2 6110 APU for strictly video playback

Aug 4, 2015 9:50PM PDT

I was recently left with a Radeon R2 6110 based Acer laptop that had been dropped, destroying the mechanical hard drive. Besides this there appears to be nothing wrong with the unit. It is a cheapo for sure and I know it is no powerhouse at all.

I currently have an Intel Core i5 Sandy Bridge with HD 3000 series graphics in a laptop serving as my media PC. Like this one, it was left behind by a customer who chose not to get it repaired. I know the i5 processor is far better than the AMD but it looks like the AMD may actually outdo it in a few areas of video playback and such due to the onboard GPU. It looks like the AMD can do 4k video while the Sandy Bridge cannot along with a few other small benefits.

I was thinking about pulling the i5 out of this position since it is more powerful overall and putting this one in that slot as it uses less energy and besides video playback, doesn't need to be a powerhouse.

I have an external Blu Ray drive I will connect via the single USB3.0 port and otherwise watch streaming video off the web.

Is this a good idea or not? I was simply going to reload the OS on an SSD and go with this one if so.

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Answer
Simply no.
Aug 5, 2015 4:02AM PDT

A dropped laptop is best avoided. You can't know the damage and they tend to fail without notice. I would not put this into any position I will depend on.

The AMD can not do 4K video. I'll skip vetting this. It's an easy no,.

- Collapse -
Yes on one, no on the other
Aug 5, 2015 8:03AM PDT

OK, I agree on the chipset not being able to handle the task. As for the fact the laptop was dropped, I don't think that is a reason to count it out. I have repaired dozens of dropped laptops with good results. Many belong to police, firefighters, and other "on the go" workers. When they get a call, handling their laptop with care is the last of their priorities. My solution for this is to install an SSD. The hard drive is always the first thing to go. There is no other physical damage like cracks or scratches and the unit is clean. Usually these trash units are owned by trash people and I can count on soda spills, cigarette smoke, and just otherwise nasty. This one is not.

I often get them left behind too. Several Core i5 and i3 units have been left behind along with lots and lots of these cheapos. I personally would never buy something like this but since it was left behind, I figured I would try to make use of it. I personally call them $300 throwaways and feel people who buy them are just wasting their money. Yes, it came from Wal-Mart.

- Collapse -
Here's a rig and it still strains to do 4K gaming.
Aug 5, 2015 8:45AM PDT

Yes, it's not video playback but it shows it takes a lot of oomph for 4K. 1080 is more likely and let the 4K TV upscale.
http://www.cnet.com/news/hands-on-with-nvidias-new-titan-x-graphics-cards/

As to the dropped unit. I didn't elaborate that it's your choice. Here the clients can be litigious if a repair fails so we always do it the right way. A dropped unit can not be warranted so the clients don't want them. I can imagine in some city what you wrote is accepted by the client but here...

- Collapse -
People can be pains here too!
Aug 5, 2015 9:12AM PDT

I make them sign a form stating that coincidental damage that may appear later on down the road isn't my fault. I started this after a few incidents including a computer that failed SIX YEARS after I had repaired it and they tried to come back and blame me. This one will remain in my personal collection so failure won't impact a customer. They bought it at Wal-Mart for about the price I quoted them for the repair with an SSD installed so chose to abandon it. As for the ones who proceed with a repair, I make sure to let them know the risks. I require them to sign the form but some still call. For example, a guy got his computer home and the sound didn't work because he had no clue where to plug in the speakers. He calls me all hopping mad and won't listen, yelling at me for like 15-20 minutes. I told him to listen to me, otherwise I was hanging up and wouldn't talk to him again. 30 seconds later I guided him to the correct port using the color codes and everything was fine. Some people.....

As for the chipset, I bet it can DISPLAY 4k resolution. There is a big difference between supporting and displaying the resolution and actually running it well without hesitation and choppiness. I know 4k takes a lot of horsepower so was surprised to see this low end chipset support it.

- Collapse -
Good to read. Nice to see you slice it finely.
Aug 5, 2015 9:23AM PDT

Display 4K
Video on 4K
Gaming on 4K

Exponential requirements!