A few months ago we got the change to re-load XP (I take your word on this and not that's it's XP SP1 or later) and sure enough XP could only connect to WiFi that was unprotected or WEP. It could show a WPA/WPA2 hot spot but give nonsense error messages (which makes you wonder why after over a decade they didn't clean that up?)
So it's true. XP is pretty old and you might be able to try WEP on that router.
Bob
I just got a netbook (used) and can't get wireless wi-fi. Staples says the router that Frontier (Verizon) uses for internet access is not compatible with my computer. How can I get wireless? Or is it impossible unless I get a different router? How can I get Frontier to give me the compatible router? Help, this is my husband's little e-mail machine and although it was very cheap we can't afford another one.
It's an EEE PC machine running Win-XP, and it shows wi-fi connections.....
Thanks!!!

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic