Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Home movie transfer (Super 8, VHS, and Hi-8) and new camcord

Jan 9, 2005 12:49AM PST

AND GOING FORWARD WHAT MINI DV CAMCORDER TO GET???

My hope is to convert 30 years of different home movie tapes (about 37 50 foot super 8, 40 VHS/and C, and 12 Hi Cool. Digitize all and be able to edit. And make DVDs for other family members.

And then, buy a Mini DV camcorder to be able to have digital recordings and computer edit.

Please help with specific recommedations? Suggestions. I have a PC...P4 with XP.

Have looked online for transfer services the pricing and end product seem to vary.
Super 8 anywhere from .08 to .30 cents a foot.

I think I am entering a world with many potential pitfalls...?
cwda1@yahoo.com

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
What's worse than a pitfall?
Jan 9, 2005 12:58AM PST
- Collapse -
film-to-video.com referral
Feb 23, 2005 3:28AM PST

I noticed that you have referred many video transfer questioners to Bob Mayfield of film-to-video.com. I have read through his entire (rather lengthy) tutorial. I came away quite impressed and am convinced of his approach. However, before I use his services for my old 8mm silent film I checked here on CNET for any comments about his work. Do you indeed recommend his approach? Are there others doing film "transfer" this way?

- Collapse -
For starters, if Super 8 is film, you're going to need a
Jan 9, 2005 8:30AM PST

variable speed projector and a digital camcorder. The variable speed ability is needed to synch the projector with the camcorder so that the camcorder will see the movie properly. There are web articles on how to do this although I can't point you to one right now. Try using Google. You will, of course, also need a good video editing package to put everything back together the way you want it.

- Collapse -
No chance that I will try this.
Jan 12, 2005 10:36AM PST

Many thanks for the post, but with my limited knowledge, I was thinking that I could get the super 8 Film transferred to a digital medium that I could then transfer to computer for editing.
So was looking if anyone could recommend that medium and a place that could do it well.
Then secondly seeking a recommendation for the editing software, and finally....
a recomm. for a mid priced camcorder that could save the first step above and let me edit and burn from my computer.
Thanks for any input.
r,
CA
cwda1@yahoo.com

- Collapse -
Super 8 to video
Feb 23, 2005 10:13PM PST

I just sent four Super 8 50' rolls to
http://www.homemoviedepot.com/
but can't comment on the quality as they have not come back yet. This company (for a fee) will let you add limited info like titles, music, etc. to your movies (on line) before they burn them to a DVD. They also will output your movie to a Mini DV or Digital 8 tape that you can load into your own computer then edit. It is my understanding pulling the files directly off the DVD may be a problem but my son "the hacker" says, "No problem" so we will see...
I was also told if the movies are really old they may have shrunk so DON'T play them on your projector as the sprocket holes may rip out. I was going to use my variable speed projector to copy them myself but, 1. it was dirty and I could not get it clean without taking it all apart; 2. the films would not stop "jittering" maybe due to shrinkage; and 3. the bulb burned out after 15 minutes. So I decided to let someone else do it. Send me an email in a week or so and I'll let you know how they came out with Home Movie Depot.

- Collapse -
Any referrals?
Mar 8, 2005 10:36AM PST

Any referrals on good reliable film to digital video transfer houses? Looking to convert Super 8 film to mini-dv format and make a couple of dvd copies.

Anyone have experience or good recommendations?

- Collapse -
Any referrals?
Mar 8, 2005 11:58PM PST
- Collapse -
Yes. Go to http://www.simplydigitalvideo.com/
Dec 1, 2008 9:33AM PST

I had 50 year old reel-to-reels converted into avi format so I could edit and am so happy. The owner is an engineer that has the equipment to copy every frame--no chemicals. Of note, if you send the reels, he will make a DVD copy only. If you want to edit, then you have to send a peripheral for him to load it onto. He is very honest, reliable and the quality was wonderful.

- Collapse -
does it still exist?
Jun 12, 2009 11:25AM PDT
- Collapse -
Worked today.
Jun 12, 2009 9:29PM PDT
- Collapse -
Checking it out
Jun 12, 2009 11:35PM PDT

Got it! Will send a message when I have more info and/or DVDs of my films. Thanks!

- Collapse -
Your experience with Home Movie Depot?
Apr 15, 2005 5:56AM PDT

How did your movie transfer work out with this company? Where you satisfied with the result?

- Collapse -
film to video
Nov 9, 2008 8:51AM PST

Bob,

Can you tell me how your film transfer went with the company homemoviedepot? I am presently looking for a professional company to do just that. Any tips for me?

Thank you
Skydoll1234

- Collapse -
Experience with Home Movie Depot
Nov 17, 2011 9:44PM PST

Your postings about experience with this company are old, but in case it is helpful for anyone else, Home Movie Depot is NOT recommended. It has taken 6 wks plus to get products pre purchased at 100% at the time of ordering. I haven't seen anything yet but they told me two days ago they were sending my order. Their service did not meet minimal expectations which were set according to FAQs on their website, and would not even respond to simple questions about the order which was fully prepaid, over $450. After several weeks of no information, they finally started to give me a few tidbits of information. They blamed delays on burner issues and equipment failures and also said some of my tapes were blank or damaged but they would not consider any adjustment. Since it was prepaid I had no leverage. Besides not providing the service I paid for, or meeting expectations they set out themselves, they are arrogant and apparently incapable of putting themselves in the customer's shoes. The originals you send are invaluable and irreplaceable, their complete email response to my requests for information about the delay and what was going on for weeks was this - "your originals are fine". Not reassuring. I'd strongly encourage you to seek local services, where you can talk to people and know where your stuff is.

- Collapse -
I am currently in the process of doing this.
Mar 9, 2005 9:04AM PST

I am transfering VHS, 8mm video tape and Mini DV on to my computer. I, like others who replied, would recommend having a professional transfer 8mm film to another medium. I would first buy a good mini DV camcorder. I don't know how easy one of the new DVD camcorders would be to navigate while uploading to your computer, but I like Mini DV because the tape records digital video, is easy to navigate, ie fast forward, rewind, etc. Whatever new camcorder you choose, I would have the 8mm film transferred to this medium.
My mini DV camcorder connects to my computer via fire wire. You should have this capability on both your computer and your camcorder. Windows will know when you are connected and turn your camera on, and will either select a program for uploading or give you a list to choose from. I like to transfer my video in scenes rather than dumping the whole tape or whatever to my computer. This way you can give each scene a name describing what the clip contains, and a date if you know it. The software I use is one that came with my DVD writer called "Sonic My DVD" I like this program because I prefer a DVD that has navigation capability. I can choose which scene I want to watch, or just choose the first one and let the whole thing play. It also allows you to select up to one minute of video and seperate audio for the background while providing full motion video screens and titles for each scene, and the ability to cut the beginning and end of each scene. I have several video editing software programs that have all kinds of fancy title and transition effects from one scene to another but use them rarely because the whole thing has to be replayed while storing it on your computer after modifying it, which is time consuming, and the finished DVD has to be played from start to finish without any navagation capability. Maybe there is a software program that allows both navigation capability, and titles and transitions but it seems to be an either or proposition and you have to decide which is more important to you.
You will need a GOOD Video card in your computer. I have a Radeon all-in-wonder with a TV Tuner. This card has a plethora of input/output capabilities. I have a VCR connected to this card (not difficult) for transferring VHS. If you don't have a HI-FI VCR with four heads, and S-Video out I would reccomend buying one. I also connect an older 8mm camcorder using the connectors that came with the Video card. Any chance you have to use an S-video input to your video card, do so. The Video is significantly better than RCA connection. All I have to do to record video from either 8mm camcorder or VHS is click on "TV" on my ATI bar, and click what input I am using and click on record, and type in a name and location. Video editing and writing is time consuming, but worth the effort to preserve your family memories for the far distant future. Good Luck, Brad