Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Hillary's Energy Plan: Burn Old Tires

Apr 29, 2005 4:30AM PDT
New York Sen. Hillary Clinton is backing a plan to burn old tires to supply energy to an upstate New York paper mill that will produce clouds of acrid black smoke - a proposal that has nearby residents in a panic over potential health risks.

In an April 13 letter to the New York Department of Environmental Conservation, Clinton urged that the agency approve a two-week test burn at International Paper's Ticonderoga, N.Y., mill ? adjacent to environmentally pristine Lake Champlain.

Yep, the same HRC who was upset about air quality at ground zero.

With this and so very many other fine examples it isn't any wonder that Webster's might be considering that the most easily understood and preferred spelling of HYPOCRITE is DEMOCRAT.

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
While the fire is burning,
Apr 29, 2005 4:32AM PDT

a lot of her papers would fall in. Better than the shredder

- Collapse -
So is Hillary going to be
Apr 29, 2005 5:05AM PDT

there when they burn the tires? Or will she be a safe distance away? Or do I even need to ask??

- Collapse -
Actually, Ed, there are many good uses for old tires;
Apr 29, 2005 8:51AM PDT

this just isn't one of them.

A partial list just off the top of my head includes (after shredding them and recovering the steel for recycling):

Reusing the rubber (the chemical components can to a degree be separated);

Grinding up the rubber and using it as an extender in asphalt mix (the resulting coumpound lasts longer, has better water resistance, offres better wet traction and gives a quieter ride than asphalt alone);

As a decorative top cover in landscaping (it's cheaper than wood chips and rocks).

And of course, there's no reason why retreading couldn't become viable again. Lohg haul trucks often use retreads, since modern retread technology is far superior to what we had 20 - 30 years ago...

- Collapse -
They can also be used to build retaining walls
Apr 29, 2005 11:48AM PDT

covered with earth and plants you'd never know they were there. I think some people have also used them to build houses.

Then there's the favorite, paint a tractor tire white and use it for a flower garden. Very attractive in front of the trailer.

- Collapse -
Another fun use....
Apr 29, 2005 11:52AM PDT

A new town park has a playground that uses rubber pellets for the ground... great at absorbing shock. They're made from recycled tires. Also, a local indoor soccer arena uses it to pad their floors under the turf.

- Collapse -
Of course there are, and there is even...
Apr 30, 2005 1:26AM PDT

at least one HOUSE (in New Mexico and another in Montana) built from them.
http://www.motherearthnews.com/library/1991_October_November/Mass_Appeal
http://www.hgtv.com/hgtv/remodeling/article/0,1797,HGTV_3659_1369263,00.html

ANY of those other uses could have been incorporated into an environmentally friendly, energy conservative posture but that is not what she chose to support despite her many attacks on Bush's Clear Skies Initiative. Of course that may well have been her intent because soot and smoke filled skies definitely indicate that she is against the Clear Skies Initiative.

- Collapse -
Paul, aren't retreads inherently dangerous
Apr 30, 2005 8:12AM PDT

because there's so little rubber left beneath the tread? Much more susceptible to blowout if any road debris is hit, frinstance...

-- Dave K, Speakeasy Moderator
click here to email semods4@yahoo.com

The opinions expressed above are my own,
and do not necessarily reflect those of CNET!

- Collapse -
Aren't retreads inherently dangerous? Not anymore, Dave!
Apr 30, 2005 9:18AM PDT

The technology of tire retreading has advanced immensely over the last 30 years or so, prodded along by long haul truck fleets that are actively seeking cost reductions without compromising safety.

These days, if the carcass to be retreaded is sound (no punctures, cuts, etc.), retreading can be safely done. A new method is the so-called "doughnut" retread, where the new tread (with an underlayer which addresses the issue you raise in your post) is cast in one seamless ring that's fitted over the carcass and then molded to fit in the same way a raw new tire is assembled, using high heat and air pressure to bond the two pieces together.

Such retreading results in a tire that gets 85 - 90% of the treadlife of a new tire with no sacrifice in performance and traction; as a matter of fact, the use of advanced polymer rubber can result in a retread that gives better performance and resistance to road hazards (punctures, etc.) than the original tread.

We have not yet been able however to retread speed rated tires (H, V, Z and other service designators for use at speeds you'll only legally see on the Autobahn) and keep the original speed rating due to the requirements of such tires' production. But for trucks and probably 60% of the cars on the road, retreading would be a viable (and less expensive) option; only the misconceptions based on past history keeps them from being produced in large numbers...

- Collapse -
What are those long hunks of truck tire treads I see
Apr 30, 2005 9:27AM PDT

on the highway all the time? I thought they were retreads? One peeled off a truck and almost wiped out my brother-in-law on his motorcycle. Smashed the fairing pretty well.

Where can cars get these new retreads? I wouldn't mind saving some money if it's safe.

- Collapse -
I've used them for years...
May 1, 2005 12:25PM PDT

without problems. You will see sloughed caps from tractor or trailer tires along the various roadways mainly because most tractor trailers are wearing them and they tend to travel long distances without stop at relatively high speeds. Very seldom will you see a passenger car or light truck throw a cap.

This link might help you out.
http://www.retread.org/packet/index.cfm/ID/30.htm

(The link for retread tire buyer's guide will link you up with any in your immediate vicinity)

- Collapse -
Fine for cars maybe .
May 2, 2005 1:21AM PDT

But if they are peeling off of trucks that says to me that they are inherently a hazard. My BIL could have been killed and I am sure they must cause other accidents. I see them on the highway all the time.

- Collapse -
Actually the hazard...
May 2, 2005 2:46AM PDT

is comparable to that of rocks or gravel or stray bits of luggage being kicked up onto following traffic.

Any of the above can happen and can happen catastrophically but the odds against and actualities recorded make it a limited and acceptable hazard of the highways--kind of like blowouts at minimum safe tread depth or "rating" a two ply sidewall as equivalent to a 4 ply.

- Collapse -
Two week test burn?
Apr 29, 2005 12:11PM PDT
- Collapse -
Do you really think she's
Apr 30, 2005 2:58PM PDT

proposing that they just find i tire dump and set a torch to it?

Dan

- Collapse -
Do you really think that I think that?
May 1, 2005 4:16AM PDT
- Collapse -
Then what was the point of your post?
May 2, 2005 5:40AM PDT

You say that tire fires smolder for years. This can be true in some uncontrolled circumstances. Do you expect that the proposed test would yield that same result? Your comment leads the reader to think that you expect the proposed test to escalate into the uncontrolled event that your refer to.

Dan

- Collapse -
I just expect
May 2, 2005 9:41AM PDT

That all the contingency plans are provided for before they light anything. Murphy's Law, environmental concerns and all that, ya know.

--Cindi
Speakeasy Moderator
click here to email the mods

- Collapse -
Oh come on! She's not a HYPOCRITE! She's just STUPID! You
Apr 30, 2005 1:25AM PDT

have to know something is wrong before you can be a hypocrite. She needed Tyson advice to make money in commodities (hint: Tyson rigged the deal). She formulated a health care plan that the ENTIRE COUNTRY rejected in spite of being able to get advice from tons of specialists. She shut down vaccine manufacturing in the US which created the recent vaccine shortages. She got herself and Billy into Whitewater and covered her tracks by hiding documents in the Whitehouse. Need I go on?

We may elect her President. Just think. The left calls George W Bush dumb! They'll worship her.

- Collapse -
I don't think she's stupid...
Apr 30, 2005 1:37AM PDT

crazy maybe.

- Collapse -
Please post evidence. She doesn't look all that bright to me
Apr 30, 2005 3:35PM PDT

Remember, she's in the political arena. The people there usually aren't the brightest bulbs, and it's not too hard to shine. For evidence, I cite the senior Senator from Illinois, Richard Durbin. I hear he's an up and coming light in the Senate. Dim.

- Collapse -
She has a basic command of the English language
May 2, 2005 1:39AM PDT

That alone puts her light-years ahead of George W. Bush.

Then there's the whole Yale law degree thing too.

- Collapse -
Mayor Daley had a poor command of the English language also.
May 2, 2005 2:21AM PDT

Did that mean he was dumb or inferior to LBJ?

You use eloquence to judge competence? That's very shallow. Too bad. Sad

- Collapse -
''Eloquence'' is not really at issue
May 2, 2005 3:14AM PDT

Making up words out of thin air is not a sign of lack of eloquence, IMO. Being President of the US and not knowing what the State of the Union Address is called ("the State of the Union Address") is also not a sign of lack of eloquence.

- Collapse -
State of the Union Address
May 2, 2005 4:38AM PDT

Has it always been called that Josh? (Hint == NO!)

Hint #2 == Research President's Annual Message to Congress (added hints 1935, FDR)

Hint #3 == 1801-1913 no speech at all

Picking on the President's speech habits and wording with regard to a phrase that is not even required by any president isn't much of a demonstration of eloquence. He could have called it "My Outlook" and been perfectly correct.

- Collapse -
Nice try...
May 2, 2005 6:01AM PDT

...but I suspect that you've seen the clip in which Bush struggles to remember what the speech is called before giving up and saying "That speech I give to Congress" or something like that.

- Collapse -
Something like that?
May 2, 2005 7:27AM PDT

Why don't you KNOW? What's the matter with you?

This is so pathetic. Please find something productive to do. Jeeeeez!

- Collapse -
He's anti-American, of course.
May 2, 2005 7:30AM PDT

What were you expecting?

Wink

Dan

- Collapse -
(NT) What in tarnation is THAT supposed to mean?
May 3, 2005 12:13AM PDT
- Collapse -
Man, it would be great if
May 3, 2005 1:24AM PDT

you asked that same question when people were seriously being accused of being anti-American.

Dan

- Collapse -
But, you seem to think that eloquence is all there is. Mayor
May 3, 2005 12:02AM PDT

Daily, as an example, was known for his 'inventive' use of the English language. It meant nothing. He had one on one relationships with several presidents including Kennedy and Johnson. By your standard, he was a flaming idiot and ignoramus to boot.

I think I'll be up all night worrying that President Bush might have called the "the State of the Union Address" something other than "the State of the Union Address". We'll have to call up the education department troops.