What do you see if you go to the webmail interface of your mail provider? Exactly the same amount of mails in your inbox as you see in the Mail app? Or 3 more?
Kees
My Windows 8 Mail app shows I have 3 UNREAD messages in my inbox, but I dont actually have any unread emails. I have gone through and opened every single email, but it still displays 3 unread emails. When a new email comes through, it goes to 4 unread emails, but when I open the new one it reverts back to 3. Its as though its stuck?!?!?!?! I have no idea how to fix this, aside from uninstalling and reinstalling the program, but then I have to remove a few apps with it (calender etc) and that will lose too much stuff.... Any suggestions would b awesome!

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic